Posh Kosher Pizza

Small little pizza shop with some seating. A little different than your typical neighborhood pizza joint. They specialized in individual pizza.
We had their mexican and eggplant. The pizza style is thin crust. Never knew pizza could be so thin. The mexican pizza had an overwhelming taste of the tomatoes and sour cream so can’t really taste the pizza. The eggplant was good and was able to taste the cheese and sauce.
Overall, the pizza was pretty good but for the price we pay it is kind of not worth it. The pizza was ultra thin and i was literally hungry after 1 hour.

Really not friendly place. To be considered a neighborhood place, they really need to work on their customer service. Pizza is ok, might give it another shot. They will try to charge you for anything as much as they can. Watch out. Went there three times, and every time had to double check my bill.

Posh has the best kosher pizza you can possible get on the east coast. There is nothing like it. What can I say? Light, tasty, delicious, crunchy, thin, cheesy goodness.
Since the new management tool over customer service has really taken a step up.
I usually get a classic pie with extra sauce and light cheese with a lot of mushrooms.
The only time that I had a bad pie there was when I added anchovies to my pie… Yuch! But that’s just my style: I hate fishy stuff (lol I had no idea what anchovies were, oops)

Very expensive for pizza. One whole personal pie is equivalent to 1.5 slices and it’s 16 dollars. Can u imagine paying 16 dollars for 2 slices. Good pizza tho. Tastes great try the truffle pie

yes, they’re incredibly expensive for not much dough. But they’re still delicious. Skip the plain pies and get some toppings. When I feel like going all-​out, I get the truffle pie, and it’s delicious.

Best pizza ever! Simple as that :) I would suggest ordering to pies. I’m never satisfied with just one. The guys working there are always very nice and welcoming. The place is clean, well kept, and a cool vibe. I’m hooked on the Romano pizza.

Love the pizza! You must get the French Onion pie.
Staff: friendly and helpful
Décor: the place looks great
Food: Amazing!!!

This place was great it had great trendy looking atmosphere the service was good the food came out fast and if you like thin crust pizza this is the spot it was crunchy and tasty it was a orgasm with every bite in mouth it tasted to good to be kosher

Worst service ever!!! I was ordered a pizza and was told that in 12 min it will be ready. After half an hour i find out that they forgot about it! What a shmaks

I’m usually not a fan of thin crust pizza. My allegiance usually lies with pizzas that have plenty of cheese and dough.
Came into this place early in the afternoon, with nobody around. I ordered the classic, because as a first time customer, I wanted to taste the «foundational» piece of their assortment of pizzas.
The sauce itself was incredible, and the cheese was really great. I think that with myself being the only person at the place ordering food, it allowed them the time to cook the pizza crust to the appropriate and perfect texture.
I will certainly be making an appearance here again.

Service is terrible, people are rude and unhelpful, but pizza was delicious.

Good pizza place with some interesting personal pizzas. Crusts are thin.
It is a little on the pricey side though.

Posh is Nice spot good pizza something unique more like a pizza crackers, however very tasty.

I’m doing this because the guy at the counter was just nasty. I asked «how much do you get for a plain pie?». He said in a nasty tone «I don’t get anything for it, here’s a menu with the prices».
Besides being nasty, I can’t comment because I didn’t order after that lovely comment. I’m not kosher and this is one of the reasons… the restaurants have terrible attitudes and most have mediocre food if not worse. God doesn’t want that for anyone. Trust me.

Posh is a really cute place and I hope that it stays in business (the shop it is in has struggled to keep regular tenants). The pizza types are unique and varied which can be a fun novelty for people visiting the neighborhood as well as a welcome change from the grandma slice. To echo what other people said, the crust is super thin here. I never leave Posh feeling like I’m going to die of carb overload.
PS. Staff is friendly even when the place is packed.

I went their a few times, mostly because of my friends who like this place. The idea is good, consider that this neighborhood really in need of healthy and good quality food. Pizza was too dry for me and so simple that I asked myself a question why would I come here if I can make totally the same at home and perhaps have more flavor. Really, Make a dough and put some salad leaves on the top. Also, the place was really nosy at that time.

The place is nice but not posh at all. Customer service is not posh but rude! The pizzas are not posh but regular.

Posh Tomato is not your ordinary greasy, thick crust cheese pizza. Posh utilizes a machine that helps make the pizza as thin as possible without breakage. At first, I was skeptical of this. Thin pizza? I’ve lived in New York for 16 years, I don’t know of this foreign object. However, they won me over. They have lovely service and treat their customers nicely. They always apologize if the wait-​time is over 10 minutes and sometimes throw in a free soda.
I highly recommend the bianca (white) pizza, the pineapple pizza, the regular pizza, & the one with basil (I can’t remember the name). This is definitely different than your average pizza and in a good way.
The only con is the pizza is quite small for 7 – 9 dollars AND NEVER customize your pizza, you’ll be seeing stars with the price=/. Enjoy~

If you love you’re pizza to have thick, doughy crust, I dont suggest this place for you. They’re specialty is crispy thing gourmet personal pizzas. Its a clever idea, and these pizza stand out.
Their small restaurant on avenue M is nicely decorated. Its cute and perfect for like a girls day brunch. For me I want to say that ¾ of one of their pizzas satisfies me, but my husband hates this place because he need 4 pizzas until he starts to feel full, and by that time the bill is over $ 50 (for a personal cracker with sauce and cheese, and any other special toppings… lol)
Every time i go there i have their smoked salmon pizza that has capers on it and no sauce, it happens to be delish, but i think its like $ 15, which probably isn’t worth it, but its a nice snack so i don’t mind.
Another plus is that the place is kosher, if that applies to you, it’s fab! Its nice to have a cute little place like this that’s kosher, it really opens up doors.
I do believe they deliver, probably with like a $ 10 minimum… If they do thats great, another plus. Also my friend’s son goes to school around the corner, I they told me that they offer a student special, something like $ 5 – 6 for a regular personal margarita pizza and a soda, which is a fab deal, I WISH I WAS A STUDENT TO GET THAT, HOW GREAT!!!
The only reason I’m taking off a star is because of their prices. For what they’re offering, I do think it is a little overpriced. But they offer superb quality gourmet pizza, that looks to be made from the finest kosher ingredients, in a VERY CLEAN RESTAURANT, LOVE THIS IDEA!

If you’re looking for a cheesy doughy pizza, this place is not for you.
I’ve never had pizza like this. It’s definitely new and modern. They have a thinning machine that makes their crust as thin as possible.
I went early Sunday around 11:30 because I didn’t want to fight the lunch crowd. As luck would have it I came in right after a lady ordered 10 pies.
The guy behind the counter was very apologetic. He even threw in some free sodas for the extra wait. It wasn’t a terribly long wait. Only 15 minutes.
I like the smoked salmon pizza. I like also how the capers cut into the taste with it’s saltiness.
My husband preferred the Mediteriana with the cured black olives.
This place is a nice place to come if you want to take a break from traditional Italian pizza.
We ended up taking the pizzas home, but there is seating. I counted 21 and the atmosphere is pretty pleasant there with good music.
This place is Jewish-​owned so it’s closed on Saturdays.