Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Love these guys. Staff is always friendly, pizza is consistently delicious. 100% recommend

I love Tony’s. Their menu is huge, and I have yet to pick something that I don’t like. The prices are fair and the staff is super friendly. I recommend this place for sure.

The pizza here is dope, but a word to the wise: stick to the basics… regular, pepperoni or something simple. Once you start to drift into the non-​pizza pizza category, the quality premium starts to fade.
The prices are very fair and the staff are friendly and generally pretty efficient. If you can, avoid going during the weekends … it can be a bit hectic and tough to get quick service if you’re just popping by for a slice.

Best pizza in Brooklyn!!! Delivery is always under 45 minutes. The options are endless and everything is delicious from classic pepperoni to the Caesar salad slice. Tony’s has a new regular :)

Tony understands all about gluten-​free safety. He makes his own pizza dough in a separate area to protect against cross contamination and bakes the gf pizzas in an oven that sees no gluten.
We were delighted to even get our own, single-​use, gluten-​free, pizza cutters.
Tony was a delight to talk to and we won’t hesitate to visit again if we are in the area.

This gem deserves a lot more love and recognition.
First off, the staff was great. They seemed to know everyone, and didn’t ask us to pay until we were about to leave. Really friendly and social. This definitely felt like the kind of place only locals go to.
I ordered the margherita pizza slice– I believe they call it the grandma pizza slice? My friend, who claims to only like cheese, got a slice of their popcorn shrimp.
I made pizza for years, and I was so incredibly impressed. Probably some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. It was, without a doubt, the best red sauce I’ve ever tasted. And I am not a tomato sauce type of person. My friend liked it so much she asked for a cup to dip her pizza in– which they gave her, no charge.
We tried their cannoli– which was wow. And got some nutella-​filled cinnamon sugar donuts to go. Which were wow– even though I don’t usually like nutella.
Honestly, I would go back here in a heart beat. Next time I’m across the country, I will.

This is by far the best pizza I have had in Brooklyn so far! The service was very fast paced to get you in and out. If you get a sweet tooth try the Nutella knotsl. I had to pray for forgiveness after I ate a whole order of 6 and ordered another to go. Seriously get em!

Amazing pizza, and the Nutella dough rolls will change your life. Great service fast, and super delicious, definite must visit

Every time I eat here I fall in love with pizza all over again… Tony’s makes pizza how it should be made and it makes you feel all kinds of nice.
The guys that work here are all so attentive, sweet and they make sure you are taken care of ASAP.
The Caesar slice is heaven. Actually they all are.
God bless pizza.

I’m not sure how anyone could hate this place; there’s seriously something for everyone here. And it’s all good! I’ve tried many different slices from Tony’s (baked ziti, potato lovers, 4 cheese, buffalo chicken, etc) and they are always delicious. It’s tough making a choice because there’s so many. Even when I went vegan for Lent, I could still come here! They have tons of vegan and gluten free options; seriously, vegan chicken, vegan meatballs, gluten free pizza crust.
Garlic knots and Oreo zeppoles are always a win too. It sucks they charge extra for marinara sauce (not for an extra one, you pay to just get one) for the garlic knots because who would eat them without it?
And their salads aren’t a bad deal either. I recently came for lunch and chose to make my own salad– it’s a lot of chicken for a small and they’ve got tons of add-​ins, and it comes with a pretty big breadstick. Avoid lemon herb dressing though, it’s basically just lemon juice.
There’s so many things to try here and their selection is obviously trying to give all customers an option, which is great and out of the ordinary for a pizza spot. Avoid coming right when school lets out though because the place will be slam packed with kids looking for dollar slices!

I love this pizza place! I can’t express how nice and friendly the staff are! I am always happy to call in and talk to them. I didn’t have the menu once and they actually took the time and listed every single pizza and ingredients! Their Hawaiian is sooooooo yummy! Oh, and their baked ziti pasta pizza is awesome too! And they have fried Oreos!!! How can you not order form here?!

Tony’s is a great place to come for all different type of specialty slices. They have everything from Chicken Caesar pizza, to Lasagna pizza, Taco pizza… even Tuna Melt pizza I believe.
On the other hand, if you are looking for an authentic Italia, brick oven style ‘thin’ pizza or even just a basic pizza slice … I’m not so sure this is the place I’d go. Definitely great for the special slices though, and one of the few places in the neighborhood that have Zeppole’s!

Their pizza is DELICIOUS. I was kind of disappointed that their lemonade wasn’t available but they had delicious fresh coffee so that was good. The staff was polite and friendly. And this place is very clean. The only thing is the music they play is a little loud. They could turn down the «elevator music» they play a little.

Tonys is the shit. There is little else to say. You wont be disappointed. They even have shiitake mushrooms as a topping.
One time, I was moving down the block, and afterwards I was tired. I called Tonys cuz I diddnt wanna unpack my dishes and cook. The delivery guy came way faster than expected, and I was up the block at my previous apartment. So I missed the delivery, and I called Tonys back to cancel and generally be a diq to them since I was hungry.
Tonys said theyd have my pizza to me within 5 minutes. I told the guy on the phone I diddnt want some cold pizza, and cancel my previous order. He firmly stated one of the most straight up, O-​G, Brooklyn-​to-​the-​core statements, in a proud as fuck, new-​york-​state-​of-​mind kinda way:
«TONY’S DOESNT SERVE COLD PIZZAS! Ill make you a fresh one and have it out to you in five minutes.»
He did, and it was spectacular. I had been a customer for two years prior, and have been for two years since. No other Bushwick pizza can compare. Tonys is the shit.

Great pizza from great
Employees– they were chill when
We came in late night

Nothing short of amazing ! From the pizza to the pasta to the deserts. Loved it all. They have so many different flavours of pizza and freshly baked sweets. The service was also amazing. We will be back for sure on the regular.

In New York gibt es überall und an jeder Ecke eine Pizza zu kaufen. Nachdem wir gleich in der Nähe von Tony wohnen, mussten wir sein Essen am Abend ausprobieren. Da wir keine Lust auf Pizza hatten bestellten wir uns Pasta a la Carbonara. Das Ergebnis: sehr sehr lecker! Mit dazu bekommt man einen kleinen Salat — mit einem Essig-​Öl-​Dressing– und Knoblauchbrot. Was will man mehr? Die Portion ist absolut ausreichend. Wir haben im Restaurant gegessen. Serviert wird alles so, als wenn man es für zu Hause bestellt hätte, also in einem Aluminiumteller. Das störte uns keineswegs, aber trotzdem will ich es erwähnen. Das Personal ist super freundlich und alles wird gleich nach verlassen des Platzes sauber gemacht. Während unserer Zeit bei Tony haben wir die Außer-​Haus-​Bestellungen nur so reinfliegen sehen. Muss also auch noch anderen Leuten gut schmecken.

Very good pizza. Their philly cheese steak pizza seemed interesting so we got that along with a few others. The cheese wasn’t the fresh mozzarella like the really good places so I can’t give it the full 5 stars. What made me want to come here is their zeppoles! They have an oreo one and a Nutella filled one. The oreo zeppole was good. They couldn’t execute the Nutella one correctly though. The inside became too soft and mushy because the Nutella was moist. I guess they fried it with the Nutella inside it so some of it got soaked into the zeppole instead of it all oozing out like I would have liked.
They normally sell each type of zeppole by 6’s for a certain price, with the nutella costing more than the oreos. I didnt want 6 of each cause it was too much so I had to pursuade the guy working there to sell me 3 oreos and 3 nutella. I offered to pay the higher price for them and it took a while but the manager finally agreed.

This business is a scam.
I ordered pasta alio e olio for $ 7.25, as printed on their menu. The man ringing me up charged me $ 8.98 (including tax). I paid and then took a look at their menu. I confirmed the price, and let the people behind the counter know that I was overcharged.
A manager immediately appeared out of the woodwork, and proceeded to claim that they could change the prices at their discretion. He said that on the bottom of the menu that they can adjust prices as they please.
The problem is that they did not inform me of their updated price before I ordered. Nor did they list the updated price on their readerboard (the one above the counter). They didn’t even have my dish listed there! Meanwhile, they continued to distribute a printed menu with information they knew to be inaccurate.
This approach is illegal, and if I encounter it again at any other establishment I will call the cops.
I insisted that I would not pay for a bait-​and-​switch item. I have more self-​respect than that. The manager continued to lecture me and make illegitimate claims about his pricing structure. Then, in a ridiculous turn of events, a job applicant standing at the counter heaped on, claiming that I didn’t read the stipulations on the menu. This was audaciously rude of someone who doesn’t even work there; a good manager would have told him to be quiet and get out.
A number of people rose to his defense, gathering around me and shouting at me. I was genuinely concerned for my safety and continued walking away.
The owner proceeded to nearly initiate a fist fight with me. He displayed aggressive bullying and an immature negotiating style. He exhibited no integrity; he did not stand by his word. He demanded that I pay an arbitrary price. Getting overcharged in New York is not new; nor is getting overcharged because you look well-​off. What is unique is the lengths to which the manager aggressively defended his illegal business practices, and the intensity of his visceral reaction. He is a bigger, taller, and physically stronger man than I, and he exploited this differential in an attempt to bully me into submission.
When you feel you are in physical danger over illegal business practices, you know you should stay as far as way as possible.
If you encounter a similar situation at any establishment, begin by calling the cops. If that doesn’t result in a favorable outcome, file a complaint with the Department of Consumer Affairs. A business can be held liable in civil and criminal court for illegal pricing.

Solid pie. It’s not Grimaldi’s, but it’s satisfying enough when you’re craving some of that triangle-​based goodness. Pepperoni and cheese are both good, with a proper balance of both on the slices. Crusts are a little crispy, but not bad.
The staff themselves are super friendly.

I came here for the first time and it literally took me 10 minutes to decide what I wanted. The menu leaves you so up in the air with all of the options listed. After taking forever to choose, I settled for a buffalo chicken slice and calamari, along with the Nutella zeppoles.
The calamari I absolutely loved! The slice was good, I like my chicken on my pizza in bigger chunks opposed to the pieces that Tony’s puts on theirs. All in all it was an edible slice. The zeppoles are the devil. The devil just delivered on a plate… yummers.
I would definitely be another customer but I would most likely order in. The décor is like an old school neighborhood pizza shop, I’d rather take the food home. Since there’s about 100 items on the menu I won’t mind trying the other 97.
By the way… Excellent service! They guys there care about their customers’ needs.