Fatbob’s Pizza

The very best pizza I’ve had in over 15 years. Gems like this are hard to find. The crust was PERFECT the toppings are FRESH the cheese blend on EVERY pizza is an ideal blend of mozzarella and QUALITY provolone. I am a former chef and know the taste of quality. Anyone who feels that the pizza served here is not to their liking, please go back to Donato’s, Pizza Hut, Domino’s, or some other factory flavored establishment. You don’t truly know food.

We drive out of our way to eat at Fat Bobs because it is sooo good. We like the thicker crust which is crunchy on the bottom. Great sauce and really good sausage. Always buy more so we have some to take home and eat later. We’ll be back!

I’m surprised by some of the negative reviews here. Although I noticed that most of those reviewers have gotten pretty «normal» pizzas. I have only ever gotten the signature Fat Bob, Chicken bacon ranch, and spinach artichoke pizza. I have always been satisfied, and I’ve gotten pizza from there probably 6 times in the past 7 months. I wish there was more indoor seating because it would be nice to not have to get take out all of the time. Of course this will look pricey compared to typical chains since it’s more of a specialty place. I’ve suggested Fat Bobs to many people, and they’ve all raved about it after trying the food.

The owners were nice and they checked on us several different times making sure we were taken care of. We ordered a sausage pizza and a fatbob pizza. The sausage pizza was a small and each piece had 1 –2 pieces of sausage on it. They were large pieces of sausage. The fatbob pizza was just different. We wanted to try it because it was so different from anything we’ve had before.

I really enjoy this pizza, I eat here at least once a week either dine in or carry out. They have a very convenient drive-​thru window for carry out orders; or the restaurant itself offers a laid-​back atmosphere for those wishing to dine in.
It’s deep dish pizza, definitely order the specialty crust. My favorite thing to order is the specialty crust pizza, with double pepperoni and light cheese. Don’t get me wrong, the cheese is very high-​quality. They just use a lot of it, so I prefer ordering light… Although the fact that they use a lot of it is probably a great thing to a lot of people! This is by far the best pizza in Brunswick, and I have sampled pretty much all of them. I highly recommend you check this place out.

So Brunswick’s best pizza right? Well I was hoping it would live up to those expectations considering this used to be a terrible Pizza Hut long ago. I was not really that hungry after lunch earlier that day but after viewing at all of the classic cars around the area, I knew that I really had to get something to eat… cravings were taking over.
You can go through a drive through if you don’t want to sit inside which I highly recommend doing because there is very little seating on the inside during the dinner hours. They have a nice carpeted booth area to the left but with only four booths and tour tables for sitting, you better hope there is at least one open. The tables to the right are good enough for groups but if you are just eating here alone, be ready to share with strangers.
I wasn’t a true fan of the Harley Davidson memorabilia scattered all about the entire walls but I can see how it can appeal to certain demographic, it just wasn’t for me but the television was distracting enough to hide away from the decorations. The most important thing to take in consider is the pizza itself. Was it the best pizza I have ever had? I can say it isn’t but coming from New York where I am in walking distance from some of the most amazing pizza slices, this comes off as slightly above average at the very most.
I ordered a small nine cheese pizza with the specialty crust to share with me and my brother which was decently priced and affordable. We chose to eat inside and thus we sat down at the table and patiently waited for it to arrive. We were given plates and silverware with no issues by a very attentive and friendly employee who we had no problems with. The wait was a tad long but I don’t consider that bad as it was already packed that day and I wasn’t expecting the food to arrive as soon as I ordered.
When the pizza arrived, I pretty much lost my taste buds after the second slice after my downright refusal to wait until the pizza cooled down a bit. The pizza had a lot of cheese on it but I had to put it down a few times because of the amount of grease coming off of the cheese and sauce. I did enjoy the pizza and I loved the flavor combined with the crisp and fluffy underside but in short, the grease turned me off greatly and the crust wasn’t that thick as described.
It was a mixed bag overall throughout the entire meal but I did end up saving some for the rest of the family to try to get their own opinions on it. However, I was a bit underwhelmed by the pizza but I would be willing to give it another try when I come back… just hope that it improves in that amount of time.

Cheap crust and cheap cheese– Extremely greasy. Made my entire family sick. Will never order from here again.

Gave Fatbobs pizza a try tonight. Overall my family found the pizza to be average to below average. For the high price we thought it would be better. There are many other pizza places in Brunswick with better pizza for a lower price.

Decided to try Fatbob’s Pizza during the holiday weekend. Pizza was very greasy, a sign that they are using cheap cheese. Sauce on the pizza was just average, didn’t have much flavor to it. For the high prices that they charge, I expected better quality.
Overall, I didn’t like the pizza, can’t recommend this place.

We have been here many Times and love it! everyone has been pretty nice every time we’ve ordered. the crust is yummy! the only time I did not like it was when we ordered it on New Year’s Eve. It was not as good as the several other times we’ve ordered it. Very pleased and will be back many more
times!

my Husband told me about this place since he has had it before and i haven’t. i love pizza so when i find something i like i stick with it. well fat bobs was amazing. the owners were really nice and even chatted with us for a couple. the pizza is amazing. ive had my share of pizza and its not like any other pizza places in town or in medina. you wont be disappointed in going. the store was nice and roomy.

This pizza is really good! The cheese is amazing and the 2 pieces will fill you up! If your are in the area defiantly try it out!

based on Luke M. s review, my lady and i had lunch at Fatbob’s pizza today. We really liked it. it cost more than i’m used to paying but man was it good. we’ll definitely be back for more. the owner (or manager) was walking to the tables and checking in on the customers — very nice and friendly.

best pizza in the area by far. one of the best i’ve ever had. the seafood pizza is absolutely amazing. great service and they go out of their way to make sure you are satisfied. so for everyone who said they had an unpleasent experience next time open your mouth and say something or don’t complain. unfortunately we know people who have avoided the restaurant because of some of the reviews people have written. if you don’t like the pizza then that’s your opinion. i understand but i eat there quite often and have never had a bad experience. i have never talked to anyone who has either. for those of you who are wondering no i am not th owner but i am one of his best customers i bet. the only reason i am giving them 5 stars is because it wont let me give them 6. to the management of fat bobs keep up the great work and for god sakes don’t change the sea food pizza.

First off, I’m deducting a star for the owner or whoever works here that is writing five star reviews and berating Unilocalers who write negative ones. You know who you are… stop it. Not everyone is going to like your pizza. Take the criticism, improve on what people dislike and move on. If you are making good food and have good customer service, the reviews will reflect that. Plus, it’s not good form.
Was the pizza good? Yea, it was OK. Do I think it’s the best pizza in Brunswick? No.
I would compare this to the sheet pizza you get at school when you’re a kid. I swear everyone had the same pizza even though I know it didn’t all come from the same restaurant. You know the kind I’m talking about. The sauce is kind of in delicious clumps with cheese that all comes off on the first bite. For some reason it’s always cold even though you just got it and the grease leaves your plate orange. There is no reason to like that pizza. But when you’re a kid, there is that wonderful time a month when you don’t have to eat your bagged lunches or cafeteria food. The pizza party day that serves the greatest pizza ever and you eat way too much.
Well I’m a grown-​up now. The pizza lacked sauce and the cheese all came off in one bite. Magical when you’re a kid, expect more when you’re an adult. I will say that the pizza with bacon, onions, and jalapenos was put together much better than the pepperoni. It held together nicely and each ingredient stood out. It was still light on sauce but it wasn’t nearly as bad as the pepperoni. Honestly, you’re not a solid pizza place if you can’t master the basics.
The taste was good. I think the nostalgia of it appealed to me more than the pizza itself but that’s not entirely a bad thing. So to sum up… If my office building ordered the pizza again I would eat it, but I would not order from here myself.

Honestly, it was a huge disappointment to me and my family. The staff was rude and stingy on their sauces. We asked for extra and our pizza came with hardly any sauce on it. When we picked it up and asked for extra dipping sauce the employee had an attitude and wasn’t friendly at all. We spent well over $ 40 on pizza and breadsticks and there wasn’t anything special about it. We heard this place was the best in Brunswick and we had high expectations. It was super greasy and the ingredients were not fresh what so ever. Everything tasted like cheap quality. We will never order from here again. The great American pizza company has our vote for being #1!

Overall pizza was good. I got the specialty crust. It’s thick with crunchy crumbles on the bottom. It definitely was a way to mix it up and good for a change but it became extra greasy and messy with this crust. Definitely a knife and fork pizza if you get this crust. The sausage was good, but the pepperoni was nothing special.

Ordered here based on previous Unilocal reviews… and it was really good. The seafood pizza was recommended and it was awesome! We also tried the Fatbob pizza with red skin mashed potatoes, bacon and cheddar on it. It was good too but pretty greasy. Cost me $ 40 for two large (12 slices) specialty pizzas which isn’t terrible. I will def be back again.

Great pizza place! You can dine in, carry-​out or have delivered — have a drive-​through as well. Can also order by the slice (during daytime only, I think)
We ate in & it has a nice décor — bright, cheerful, & clean w/​a Harley-​Davidson theme. Local, family owned.
Pizza is very good — I like the traditional crust best — it’s thin & crispy, but not too thin. Create your own or specialty pizza. Tried 3 small specials, as we couldn’t decide and all were great! The Seafood Supreme was surprisingly light w/​lobster cream sauce, shrimp, crabmeat & spinach. Also had the «FatBob» w/​red skin mashed potatoes, bacon, cheddar & garlic butter sauce — different but also tasty! I’m a veggie lover, so I really enjoyed the Veggie pizza!
Also has varied salads, hoagies, appetizers, pasta and dessert pizzas (tried apple & cherry ones — yum!).

This place just opened, and so far so good. The usual pizza shop choices including subs/​sandwiches, salads, pastas, and wings. I’ve played it safe on the few times I’ve been there and just got basic pepperoni /​sausage. You have your choice of their traditional crust or deep dish. (I hear you can get NY style if you ask). The crust was ok. The sauce a little sweet, but well seasoned. The pepperoni and sausage was of good quality. Overall, a pretty good pizza that’s worth trying again. I little pricey, but the normal coupon discounts can be found.
The have a great assortment of specialty pizzas that I will have to try. For instance, the FatBob has garlic butter, red skin mashed potatoes, bacon, red onion and cheddar cheese. Next on my list.
Has a number of tables and booth available for dining in. The place is decorated with Harley Davidson mementos (hence the FatBob name). Also has a convenient drive thru window, in case you worried about burning off too many calories on the ten steps to the door.