Rudy’s Subs McMurray

Got a Cheeseburger Sub and a Rudy’s Special both were very good sandwiches. The lady at the counter was super nice.

On a scale of 0 – 10 I rate this a 3 – 4. It was not expensive but was less than OK. The staff were pleasant but the quality was less than average. I ordered the cheese steak with peppers and got boiled peppers and steakums. The meat was heated, but it was not baked as you would get in a good hoagie shop. The Cellone’s hoagie roll was soggy as it was not baked, perhaps my preference. Across the street is Fiore’s competitively priced, yet much better quality. My prediction is they will be out-​of-​business in the next 2 years.

This place is amazing! I highly recommend it. The food is awesome and the service is just as great!:)

All time favorite sub place in Pittsburgh. Cellone’s Italian bread makes these subs a classic Pittsburgh dining tradition. All fresh, love the cheese steak!

These subs are out of this world. The bread is fresh and soft, the meat is good quality (I had the turkey), and Rudy’s special sub dressing is very flavorful with oil and fresh herbs. Definitely recommend. I called ahead and ordered takeout — the order was precise and on time which was important because I had to take it back to work for my other coworkers to enjoy within our lunch break. This was the first time anyone in my office has had Rudy’s and I gotta say, everyone was very happy. We will definitely be returning!

Okay not great. Ordered cheese steaks and the steak was basically minute steaks on a bun. Some herbs and I asked for tomatoes and onions. But if you’re use to real cheese steak these fall short. Pat’s and Gino’s in philly are tough to compete against so you’ll be disappointed if you’re expecting chopped steak, sautéed onions, etc. definitely can find better.

ITS A WINNER
very good. get it loaded and don’t forget the special herb oil. healthy portion. reasonable pricing. not QUITE as tasty as the original in monroeville, but super yummy. great speedy and courteous service. i hope to see this place to very well. updated, clean, great technology.
GOOD LUCK THERE!!!

Went today after golfing and ordered 2 full Italians hot. Both of them were excellent and while we planned on saving the second half, we both are the whole thing.
A previous reviewer mentioned the bread wasn’t as good as local bakeries. The bread comes from cellones which is a local bakery. It was soft warm abs delicious.
The food was ready in about 5 minutes and then they bagged my to-​go order shortly after. We got a kids meal (chicken fingers) which was fine but nothing to write home about but satisfied my toddler.
I can’t wait to order more from this place. I can’t believe this was my first time here after they had been open so long.

Get the Steak and Cheese it is a mouthful. Great Bread. A new place to go in the South Hills

Had the Steak and Cheese with Egg on it. I ate the whole thing it was so delicious. I grew up in the East and love Rudy’s Subs. Glad we have one in the South Hills. Will be going back agains soon.

Third time here, every time I stop in the food gets better. Only problem was I couldn’t finish the footlong and fries.

⁵⁰⁄₅₀. Ordered the italian hoagie, good tasting but light on the meat. Was underwhelming. Wife got a steak hoagie with egg, was very good. Had ordered fries and fried pickles. Discovered when we got home that they forgot our fried pickles. Was looking forward to trying. Want to like this place because the steak hoagie was great but for the price we paid and missing items not sure we will give another chance with other sub places in the area.

First impressions are everything, and unfortunately Rudy’s Subs left me with a poor impression of them. I ordered a ½ size Cheeseburger Sub to go and was upsold to the daily special (includes fries and drink) for $ 7.99. I wish I would’ve declined. About 15 minutes later (not great speed if you’re in a hurry or don’t have a long lunch) they brought out my order on a tray despite having ordered it to go. Usually this wouldn’t be a big deal, but they took it back into the kitchen and took another 2 minutes to simply bag what was on the tray. I got my food to the car and decided I would at least eat some of my fries on the way back to the office and they weren’t even close to hot. I’d have been better off having ordered a bag of chips.
The sub was OK, the fries tasted like they would have been good if they wouldn’t have sat out long enough to get cold, and the service was just way too slow. If you work at Southpointe, don’t even bother coming here because you’ll just end up disappointed and late coming back from lunch.

Got to love the website stating that the subs/Rudy’s is a legend.
Anyway, a nice new Rudy’s recently opened. Though, I have never been to a Rudy’s, I have heard the name.
How about the price of the lunch special. A half Sub, Fries and a Beverage for $ 7.99. Perfect for me this day. Had the Italian Sub. It was good but not nearly as good as my FAVE. The bread/​bun was OK but again not as good as some from some of the local bakeries.
The service was super friendly and helpful!