Terry’s Toffee

«Thank you sir, may I have another.»
Ok, I really didn’t have to ask, nor was there any punishment going on, but man oh man, I loved how my son and I were offered sample upon sample upon sample!
Now the up-​front shopping area might be small but it is full of toffee-​goodness. The back is where the action is, where they mix and pour their delicious toffee.
When we entered, we were immediately greeted and told we could sample anything on the sample table – they basically had their whole line available for sampling and these were pretty good sized toffee bites too! Once I settled on my purchase (the Coffee Toffee – wonderful coffee flavor– and the McCalls Dark – the basic toffee just with rich dark chocolate) he offered a sample of their toffee popcorn and yep, I got a bag of that crunchy buttery goodness as well.
The toffee is excellent quality – you can tell they use superior ingredients and everything is so fresh. I really liked their Chai-​cago spice (sweet and warm, the spice is mild) and plan to send my team some of that for the Holidays. Nothing like showing off the local artisans and sharing some those goodies across the US!

So amazing. They have samples out of every kind… and they have a variety. This is a great place to get a gift for someone. Toffee for everyone! I like the lavender flavor.

Loved this place!!! I spent some time perusing their generous sample table before picking out some gifts for people back home. The packaging is great by itself but they also offer gift wrapping if you’re interested. The owner, Terry, was the best! Super nice, not at all pushy, and happy to share the story about the celebrity pictures and letters gracing his wall from his 13 years in business.
The toffee I tried was absolutely fantastic! Not something I would buy regularly for myself since it’s a bit pricy ($ 8.99 for ¼lb) but it’s great for gifts. It’s a bit out of the way of the regular tourist scene but worth it. Definitely stop in here if you’re from out of town and are looking for unique souvenirs!

A container of Terry’s Toffee makes a really good gift for friends! Really beautiful gift-​ready containers, and who in their right mind doesn’t like toffee?
For out of town friends, I tend to bring back some of the Chai-​cago Spice Toffee (#puntastic).
They have samples of all their toffees on the table when you walk in. My favorites are the lemon paradise (first time you’ll hear me saying that about white chocolate), Chai-​cago spice, and the McCallan’s classic.
Little on the pricey end though!

I might be one of the few females alive that could live in a chocolate-​less world. It’s not that I hate it but i don’t crave it either. When my friend Angela suggested a toffee place, I was in. Although I don’t have a sweet spot in my heart for chocolate, I do for toffee.
We were warmly greeted upon entry and were given the run down of how everything works. They have samples of every flavor to try. I had to try one of everything. I ended up buying a few mixed bags but the lavender, lemon and cran-​orange ended up being my fave. If you’re like me and prefer toffee without chocolate, they sell naked toffee for 3.99. I should have bought all of it but they only had a few flavors available.
All in all, I spent about $ 35. Way more than I’d spend at another candy joint, but it’s high quality and definitely worth the money. Plus I plan on sharing with my family.
For my friends that may also have braces (or sensitive teeth), I was a little nervous that I’d crack or break a bracket, but it’s not incredibly hard that you have to worry about it. The only worry you have here is how many calories you just consumed with all the free samples.

You haven’t had real toffee until you’ve had Terry’s. I will never look at a Heath bar the same way again.
The Lavender Vanilla and Chai-​Cago Spice were my two favorites, so I purchased each flavor in a ¼ lb. bag for a jaw-​dropping $ 8.99 each. I didn’t have sticker shock since I had read the reviews first, and I paid for a gourmet, quality product.
The storefront is small, with two displays of toffee including some already boxed up and topped with pretty metallic ribbons. The table in the middle hosts a plethora of samples of each flavor. I didn’t sample every one, but I also liked the Lemon, and the Cran-​Orange was interesting. I wasn’t a fan of the coffee; I expected a more robust flavor.
I would come back here for the occasional indulgence or gift for the toffee lover in my life, but luckily this is a little too far from home to make it a habit. Unlike Courtney C., I will NOT be sharing my Terry’s Toffee.

Very pricey, but extremely good toffee!

I accidentally stumbled in here one day thinking that it was a coffee shop where I could hang out for a while. The sign outside did not really make it clear that this was exclusively a retail space. The actual store front is pretty small, but as far as I could tell, all the different toffees that they offer were on display. They also have little plates with samples of everything they sell, which I explored liberally. I am not usually the biggest fan of toffee, but some of their flavors definitely won me over, and I ended up leaving with a sampler pack. Unlike a lot of dipped toffees you find at other sweet stores, the chocolate coatings do not fall off the toffee the minute you bite into it, which is a definite plus. My big complaint, though, is the price. The little sampler I bought was definitely a nice treat, but next time I’m in the mood for something sweet, I think I’ll go somewhere where I can get more bang for my buck.

I LOVE this shop! I was sad to see the bakery vanish from this space years and years ago when I was doing glass blowing down the street. I still miss her rugulah (I know I spelled that wrong) but the toffee is an excellent replacement. Terry & Michael are both incredibly nice guys. I used their toffee and spices from the Spice Shop for «Sugar & Spice» wedding shower favors. They even made sure to give me extra labels so I could let people know where it came from. My fav flavors are the orignal, kona coffee, lemon and eanut butter. I have got to go back there soon!

Let me begin by saying that I am not a big sweets lover, but the bites I’ve had here and there of the Wackerpop and orange/​macadamia chocolate toffee have made me realize why Terry’s Toffee is held in such high regard. We sell Terry’s products where I work, and I have been sent a couple times now to pick up our order. It wasn’t until my last visit that I noticed a picture on the wall showing a group of Soldiers wearing Terry’s Toffee shirts, and I asked him about it.
This is where my review turns into a slam-​dunk 5 stars: It turns out that in 2008 – 2009 he sponsored a deployed unit in Iraq, sending them tons of goodies and love. I ended up talking to Terry (who is an incredibly sweet, cool guy) for about ten minutes about it. As an Iraq veteran, I couldn’t express how much gestures like that are appreciated by servicemembers who are deployed. Truly, the smallest gestures from people back home are so great for the morale of the troops. Recieving surprise gifts breaks up the monotony of the day-​in-​day-​out routine of deployment, and the fact that Terry sent a ton of his delicious goodies over there, I can assure you was greatly appreciated by the guys and gals over there who had most likely been eating MRE’s for the past handful of months.
To touch a little on the store and business itself, everything here is made by hand, and there is an enormous variety of sweets, with some really unique and brilliant flavors. Perfect for the holiday season if you want to send someone a gift basket, or if you just want to bring something special home for guests and family to enjoy.
Support Terry’s Toffee, truly a local gem!

Great gift idea! Their toffee doesn’t get stuck to your teeth, comes in fun flavors, and beautiful packaging!

I would give Terry’s Toffee 6 stars if I could. This stuff is incredible. It’s truly the best toffee I’ve ever had. Also, they have SO MANY flavors. I must have tried about 6. My favorites were the milk chocolate, Mcall’s classic, and the peanut butter chocolate. I was surprisingly impressed with the Lavenilla – I usually find lavender too overpowering and floral in sweets but in this case there was definitely a nice balance.
The only downside is that it is pretty pricey but it’s totally worth it.

Person: Would you like some toffee?
Me: No thanks… I like my teeth to stay in my head.
Person: It’s Terry’s Toffee.
Me: Hand that ish over!
It really is the only good toffee I’ve ever had. Sorry to all the grandma’s out there, but I just can’t do those overly hard shards of toffee cutting into my gums and grinding down my teefs. I like that Terry’s toffee switches things up by actually being edible.
Beyond being edible, it’s also expensive as heck but I can see in the storefront and well-​balanced flavors how they got to that price-​point. Of course I’d love for it to be a little easier on my pocketbook, but that’s just not the case.
I’m a fan of the Chai-​cago toffee, which has a teeny tiny little kick on the end and full-​bodied buttery deliciousness throughout. If you haven’t tried their dark chocolate smothered popcorn — get on it, and if you happen to be in search of sugar free, Terry sells the only sugar-​free chocolate/​candy that I’ve ever had that doesn’t have that fake weird after taste.
Terry’s Toffee makes for a very merry Candice.

Lovely place to buy a gift. Wonderful service. Not a big toffee fan, but this was a welcome treat.

The best toffee I’ve ever had. Go for the lemon paradise! The store owners are also very lovely and give generous samples to boot in their store! Please support this business!

I have been meaning to visit Terry’s for awhile, and one day I actually finished work early enough to do so.
The woman behind the counter was very friendly and invited me to sample their specialty popcorn. She also pointed me to the sample trays in front of the store. Wow! Free samples of every type of toffee means I certainly will need fillings soon. Luckily, I maintained composure and tried only few before making my purchase.

OMG. So good.
Be. Careful.
You will seriously be in danger of eating everything in sight, and I am not even kidding. I love their signature toffee. My mom and I left with a few samples and bags.
Not much else to say, other than. try it. Then go to the gym the next day, like all day to make up for it. :)

Toffee has never been so divine! There was a generous sampling bar at the front of the store, and we helped ourselves, reveling in the diversity of flavor creations. Ended up purchasing a small box of Peanut Butter Chocolate — way yum! — and a small bag of Lemon Paradise Naked Toffee — surprising toffee flavor but still very good. The naked toffee definitely put me closer to my next dentist visit, but for this toffee, it was worth it!

I never thought I’d be a fan of toffee and it’s all because of Terry. Trust me.
It’s that darn good. And hey if you don’t trust me zillions of A-​List celebrities, politicians, the Queen of England, and renowned food journalists that like it.
I was introduced to Terry’s Toffee as gifts and was smitten. I like:
Lemon Paradise with lemon oil, hand cracked macadamia nuts, covered in white chocolate (with 31% cocoa butter). I didn’t expect to favor this but the sweet, buttery flavor mingled with the zesty lemon and crunchy texture were winners.
Chai-​cago Spice with cinnamon, cloves, ginger, nutmeg, cardamom, pepper dipped in dark chocolate. Super complex flavors and a fantastic candy for someone without an overly sweet tooth. I thought I’d like this best, and I DID like it but the PB &C was my fave.
Peanut Butter Chocolate with peanut butter chips mixed with toffee and covered in milk chocolate. It’s like a Heath Bar and Reese’s. Together. Yup! Delicious.
Terry and staff are really nice. They give samples so you can make the best choice.
This is some sophisticated high end candy, guys and galleons. They make great gifts for others OR from you to you. We ALL deserve a treat sometimes, right?

This place advertises itself as toffee that is given as a gift at the Academy Awards. I thought that was incredibly douchey but naturally, I had to try toffee that is given as a gift at the Academy Awards.
And it is some good toffee, worthy of awards. I love salt/​sweet candies and this is at the top of the totem poll. I massacred both boxes that I bought as gifts in two sittings. It is just too addicting. Kinda pricey for an addiction, however.
Stop by and try their massive display of samples.