Another trip to Deweys and another great experience. We had the house salad and the BBQ chicken pizza Both were excellent. Service was quick and friendly.
Joel B.
Place rating: 5 Cincinnati, OH
Every bit as good as the original, with great service and all the same amazing pizzas, salads, and house-made dressings, available. The only real downside is that they built this store way too small so they’re almost always«on wait» — great for their image and $/sqft ratio, really bad if you’re looking for a walk in or expecting a super fast delivery time. They’re just as expensive as the other Deweys, so you know what you’re getting there — but you get your money’s worth at this establishment. Really happy to see more real food(ie non frozen reheated chain crap) coming out to the Anderson area, and especially happy when it’s done well!
Maria S.
Place rating: 4 Batavia, OH
Absolutely love Deweys pizza. The crust is the best crust I’ve ever had. I’m all about the crust. I like to keep it simple and get cheese pizza with ricotta cheese on it. My husband likes any kind of funky pizza he can order. Luckily, we can get both on one pizza! It’s amazing. The only reason that I gave four stars was because they need a TV over the bar. There is one TV behind the bar. It’s not necessarily to sit there for hours, but it would definitely earn you five stars from more then just me. We were told by two different servers that several people complain about the lack of TV over the bar. Food is fabulous though!!!
Ralph H.
Place rating: 2 Cincinnati, OH
For what it is, it’s very overpriced. It’s just pizza, and you get more bread than substance. I can get a PIZZAHUT pizza for crying out loud, for 2⁄3 the cost and twice the topping density. The music was too loud too.
Chanin D.
Place rating: 4 Batavia, OH
My mom and I ate here for the first time yesterday. We were very happy! Service was great. Constant refills of our ice water, brought xtra napkins without having to ASK for them, I asked for xtra dressing for my salad, and it actually came with XTRADRESSING! Imagine that! The only reason I don’t give 5 stars is because I think it’s ridiculous to categorize the toppings as regular or gourmet! Gourmet??? really? Why? So we can be charged twice as much? Eating my leftover piece for lunch right now, and it’s still YUMMY!
Danae R.
Place rating: 4 Cincinnati, OH
To be fair — my 1st timer experience was redeemed by our adorable red lipstick wearing server, Abigail and her team! Our H20 was consistently refilled as we enjoyed the yummy half-n-half pizza and fresh, fresh salads! Great food, exemplary service! We will dine again! You should too!
Sara S.
Place rating: 5 Cincinnati, OH
I tried carry out from Deweys last week, and it did not disappoint! I had one of my favorites, the Billy Goat! Their toppings were fresh, and their crust is the BEST! I like that you can do half and half pizzas in case you have individuals who want different toppings on their pizzas. Can’t wait to actually dine in at this new location!
Ron G.
Place rating: 5 Bethel, OH
«The Goat»… Something of an unfortunate name for my new favorite Dewey’s pizza. The goat cheese is super creamy but not overpowering. The sweet sun dried tomatoes offer that extra bit of pop you are looking for along with a perfect complement of mushroom. I was always a Bronx bomber guy… But the Goat is my new yum!
Ianp P.
Place rating: 5 Cincinnati, OH
I waited a few weeks so they could get settled and ordered carry out last week, it was excellent. Your going to pay a little bit more for this pizza but well worth it. Dante’s inferno is really good.
Unknown C.
Place rating: 3 Cincinnati, OH
I had tried Dewey’s in Newport about a year ago and wasn’t impressed, so when they opened up one close by I decided to give it another try. Ordered just a basic pepperoni pizza because I feel that is a good gauge of what to expect before I go all funky. The pizza came out and looked good, took me a slice and it was a bit limp for my liking, but took a bite. Couldn’t put my finger on it at first but it conjured up memories… What was it? Then it hit me, that’s it! I closed my eyes took another bite, it’s a fricking Chef Boyardee pizza! The pizza sauce, the pepperoni, almost identical. I will give them a pass on the crust but barely. So I just don’t get the clamoring about this place. Sorry, mediocre at best.
Tanya P.
Place rating: 5 Cincinnati, OH
I would like to be the first to say, Welcome to Anderson! Oh the pizza was so good! You can get just about any pizza for about $ 20. The service is wonderful! The wait staff is so friendly. The vegetables were crisp and the meat was cooked just right. The sauce is wonderful. There’s just a hint, not too much. The pizza came out so hot and fresh. If you can’t decide between the two just get the two halves combined. Everything is shiny new and clean. I think this will be bad for the waistline, it’s less than a mile away. They even have beer for$ 3 a bottle, all the time!