City Hall Cheesecake

Best and only cheesecake in Collierville, except for my wife’s. She’s not on Unilocal.
Our favorites are coconut, white chocolate caramel (I think) and also chocolate peanut butter. Can’t recall a bad one.

I wasn’t too impressed with their cheesecake. I tried the cookies and cream cheesecake and it was just okay. I’ve eaten better cookies and cream cheesecake elsewhere. However, to be fair since it was only the first try, I will definitely be back to try a different flavor and see if their other flavors are better.

If you like cheesecake, you should give this place a shot.

Quiet place for evening dessert. Nice plates were used, but they had plastic forks, they need nice metal forks. Turtle and Orange Creamsicle cheesecakes were good.

The exposed brick walls and hard wood floors, make this the perfect way to end a date! It is located in beautiful Collierville Square.
The cheesecakes are made fresh, and with a 24 hour notice, you can bring home your very own Cheesecake. They have 9 delectable flavors (Coconut, Whit Chocolate Raspberry, and Triple Chocolate among others). They also have a selection of weekly specials that brings the total flavor selection to 11 (they even have a sugar free selection for those who desire it). This is as close to authentic New York style cheesecake you can get without flying to Manhattan and dining at Junior’s.

I am giving only 3 stars based on my first time (and only time so far)…I am open to trying them again, and maybe I will have a different feeling after trying another flavor of cheesecake. I visited the Collierville location on the square, and ordered a slice of the chocolate peanut butter. The flavor of the cheesecake was pretty good, but I had an issue with the texture/​mouth feel of the cheesecake. It’s not light and silky texture like you would get with many of the varieties at a place like The Cheesecake Factory… it was super dense, and had a drier texture that would gum up in my mouth. I know cheesecake can be a matter of personal taste on what everybody likes, but this drier, denser texture just wasn’t as pleasing for me as a slice at Cheesecake Factory is. But please try the place out, and don’t let my personal cheesecake preferences steer you away.

For the name, you would think of taxes initially but if you love cheesecake, City Hall has some rich, thick, and decadent cheesecake. I would say that City Hall’s cheesecake is on par with Cheesecake Factory which is one of the best in my book. The prices might be high at $ 5.95 a slice but it’s worth it. You can share with someone but I guarantee that you’ll regret not getting your own slice.
You can choose from turtle, cookies and cream, peanut butter cup, orange creamsicle, strawberry, blueberry, triple chocolate but I recommend the white chocolate raspberry. It’s finished with a raspberry sauce and white chocolate chips. City Hall can take my money any day for a slice of their cheesecake.

C is for the Calories that I just consumed
H is for the overwhelming Happiness my tummy feels
E is for Each slice which I could consume
E is for Every last bite I will take
S is for complete Satisfaction
E is for Enjoying what your are Eating
C is for Confiscating the every last piece
A is the grade I give this Amazing place
K is for the Kisses I want to give the cheesecake
E is for Empty plate when it’s all gone :(
I LOVE CHEESECAKE! If Memphis lacked in frozen yogurt shops I would indulge much more often in cheesecake! I met a few girls up here to try it out and it is absolutely AMAZING. The only better cheesecake I have ever had was in Hawaii… and it probably just tasted that much better because I was in Hawaii… I tried the white chocolate raspberry and a bite of the cookies and crème. They were both heavenly.
Thank goodness this place is a 25 minute drive out of my way or I would be there way too frequently!