Minelli’s Pizza

Columbus, United States

4

16 reviews

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 614-870-2400
Website:
www.minellispizza.com
Address:
1050 Hilliard Rome Rd, Columbus, OH, 43228
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Today

Today –
Local time (Columbus) 2:04 PM Saturday, June 21, 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Vicinity

Near this location:
20
ft
Mugsy’s Pub and Patio
1040 Hilliard Rome Rd
1
mi
Super 8 Columbus West
5655 Feder Road
1
mi
Hoffman Farm Market
800 Hilliard Rome Rd
1
mi
R & D Tax Service
975 Hilliard Rome Rd
1
mi
Marathon Authorized Dealer
5501 Fisher Rd
1
mi
Ted’s Marathon
5501 Fisher Rd

16 reviews of Minelli’s Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Galloway, OH
For the price the amount of pizza you get is great.
They do not skimp out on toppings!!!
If you are looking for a doughy crust this is not the place. Think of Donato’s style, but better. lol
I only wish it were a bit cheaper. But all in all a great pizza joint!!!
Place rating: 5
Hilliard, OH
Love this pizza. Good price it’s old school square cut pizza, generous with the toppings.
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
We have friends that told us this was their favorite pizza place. We ordered a plain ol’ pepperoni and it definitely lived up to the hype. They cover it crust to crust in pepperoni. The crust was nice and crispy at the edges which I love. It was a bit greasy but the best pizza usually is. The garlic bread can be skipped as it was nothing special and a little dry.
Place rating: 4
Hilliard, OH
This is one of our go to pizza joints it is (in our opinion) one of the top 3 west side pizzas and for price vs quality it’s hard to beat. It’s not the best pizza you have ever had but if you are a west sider it is certainly one you can get and be happy with. They use good ingredients and are very consistent they have 12th pizza free coupons on the box so that is an added bonus.
Place rating: 2
Bellevue, OH
The pizza was alright, worth trying once. The crust is too hard and didn’t have much flavor but the service was fantastic. Moved here a little over a month ago and still trying to find that one go to place.
Place rating: 3
Columbus, OH
Minelli’s makes a good enough pizza. Not great, not bad. It’s the kind of place that I’d probably go to if I needed to pick up a few pies when my nieces and nephews are in town and I’m down in that area. The service was fast and friendly, but again, the pizza itself is, well, sufficient. It’s the almost the standard Columbus style pizza: square cut, crispy pepperoni. Only their crust seems a little bit thicker than most places.
Place rating: 5
Salinas, CA
Soo good! We were staying at the super 8 motel across the street and decided to give this place a try. It was great! Pizza was delicious, husband loved the wings and the cheese bread was really good too. And they delivered :) Definitely reccommend it to anyone in the area!
Place rating: 4
Las Vegas, NV
I guess I finally realized why its cut this way instead of its traditional pie slice way, but still… a very good pizza waited while it was being made over at mugsys he brought it over instead of having it in the oven I was like thank you so much well it was good and fresh and not too hot great pizza ! next time ill try the subs
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
I have ordered from Minellis to warrant a review. The pizza is good, reasonably priced, the subs are good, I have never had a complaint. I recently ordered a pizza for my son and myself with an Italian salad. Now I kept in mind how most places sell salads and they are small. Well, to my surprise the salad delivered was much larger than I would’ve ever anticipated! I have had the Italian sub, and super sub version.
Another pro to them is they will deliver with only a single sub order, which I have found to be very helpful upon a couple of occasions. Fast delivery, nice staff, and good food, all say 5 star in my book!
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
Moved & have had to eat pizza at other different locations & all we can say is that No other pizza place compares to Minellis!
We miss it A LOT!!!
Place rating: 5
Santa Monica, CA
Minelli’s is a local mom and pop shop that serves a great thin crust with speedy and courteous service!
Ordered a large pepperoni to go and as mentioned in other reviews, the person on the phone was very polite and efficient.
Showed up 20 minutes later and it was ready to go. When picking up, I saw the owner speaking to «regulars» getting their to-​go orders which is always encouraging. I hear their delivery experience is great as well.
Place rating: 1
Columbus, OH
0 stars.
This place is absolutely horrible. Was out at Mugsy’s Pub (which is attached to Minelli’s) drinking some beers with a friend. We were hungry and decided to get a pizza. I love pizza and love all types of pizza. I’ve tried over one hundred different pizza places and I’ve never had a pizza this bad. It was not edible. We each tried a piece and threw it out. Cardboard has more taste. The crust was tough, the sauce was more like marinara sauce but mostly water and the cheese was horrible as well. I’ve never been more dissatisfied with pizza. I definitely do not recommend. However Mugsy’s is a decent place with a great outdoor area
Place rating: 5
Hilliard, OH
I have had the pleasure of ordering from this establishment many times. Each time I called, the person on the other end of the phone was extremely polite and helpful while ordering. The delivery folks were also equally kind. Their pizza is absolutely delicious. I like the thin crust. I also really like the sauce which has little chunks of tomatoes. Their garlic bread is also good and the italian sub is delicious. Their prices are very affordable, which is great for us because we have a family of six. I was so disappointed that they don’t have a dining restaurant. Only pick up or delivery :(
Place rating: 3
Columbus, OH
OK pizza. First time rating here. Got a medium with the works. I’ll try a plain cheese next time.
Place rating: 4
Columbus, OH
This place is great. They have an awesome thin crust, and I hate thin crusts!
We do always have to ask them to cut it like a pie, because they cut in the «Ohio style» Pizzas are loaded with toppings.
It’s cheap, quick and tastes good. :-)
Not tried delivery, only pick up.
Place rating: 4
Columbus, OH
Great pizza! The cool thing about minelli’s is that it is connected to mugsy’s bar. So you can get a pizza and while you wait have a beer. The staff is very friendly! After 2 times they know you by name. The Italian subs are a little shy on meat.