Yogurt Crazy in Commack, NY

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:	+1 631-486-6370
Website:	www.Yogurt-Crazy.com
Address:	2195 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY, 11725
Categories:	Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards	Yes
Parking	Private Lot
Bike Parking	Yes

Wheelchair Accessible	Yes
Wi-Fi	Free

Today

Today	11:30 am – 10:30 pm Open now
Local time (Commack)	12:01 PM Wednesday, June 18, 2025

Business hours

Monday	11:30 am – 10:30 pm
Tuesday	11:30 am – 10:30 pm
Wednesday	11:30 am – 10:30 pm
Thursday	11:30 am – 10:30 pm
Friday	11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday	11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Yogurt Crazy is a family owned self-serve yogurt shop offering a continuously rotating selection of 12 daily flavors of frozen yogurt, fresh-cut fruit and a massive variety of toppings, all of which customers can customize themselves.

Non Dairy Sorbets, and peanut allergen friendly flavors available!

History

Established in 2010.

Yogurt Crazy is a family owned and operated business, we take great pride in our establishments and products that we offer. We want to make every Yogurt Crazy visit, a great one!

Our mission at Yogurt Crazy is to promote a healthy lifestyle by bringing people together to enjoy a delicious and healthy treat in a fun, comfortable and family friendly environment.

We want our customers to feel like they are at home while in our stores. It is easy to see that our top priority is always customer service, cleanliness and the freshness of our products. We know in this industry that cleanliness is appreciated by our customers which is why we stop at nothing to keep our stores looking new every day. We see how much our efforts are appreciated in the way that our customers uphold the store’s cleanliness as well.

Related places

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:

Emilio’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

2201 Jericho Tpke

Athenian Greek Taverna

2187 Jericho Tpke

Eastern Garden

2189 Jericho Tpke

200

Deals

2185 Jericho Tpke

300

Halloween USA

2201 Jericho Tpke

340

AMF Commack Vet Lanes

2183 Jericho Tpke

13 reviews of Yogurt Crazy

No registration required

Heather L.

Place rating: 4
Patchogue, NY

I recently went back to this location and was very pleased with the experience in comparison to my last visit a while back. Plenty of toppings and so much fresh fruit it was a delight and everything I was hoping and craving for. Was greeted and saw employees working hard. Thumbs up x2

Stephanie C.

Place rating: 4
Commack, NY

Good variety of flavors and toppings. I love that they have a rewards card!

Jimmy F.

Place rating: 5
Huntington Station, NY

Amazing place. A little pricey, but that’s probably because I can’t resist filling my cup to the top at this place. The Fro-yo is top notch, very nice employees always giving us as much sample spoons as we need, and they also have frequent flyer cards for the addicts like myself and girlfriend. Highly recommend coming here for an after dinner snack.

Carolyna Z.

Place rating: 4
East Northport, NY

went to yogurt crazy with my boyfriend’s nieces since they love it and i actually liked it as well. read some reviews and they didnt look so pleasing but i still gave it a chance. They had a good selection of froyo, their toppings bar was clean and filled, also with a lot of variety of fruit and gummies and cereals. Staff was really nice and place was clean.

Ash F.

Place rating: 4
Brockport, NY

Yogurt crazy is my favorite yogurt place because of all the toppings! They are open very late and their store is always very clean. They change up their flavors which is good. I absolutely love cake batter! They have a lot of toppings which can get pricey, but they are so good. (I usually overload it with chocolate pretzels) Best of all, they do deals throughout the week and have punch cards for you to get money off your next yogurts or free ones. Don’t be afraid to ask about the deals!

Kelly F.

Place rating: 4
Centereach, NY

I think this place is awesome!
I’ve come here 3 times and every time the service is fantastic; very cleanly and very fast to get yogurt.
Compares to a lot of the yogurt places in California.
The design of the logo and the interior could be better; less green and purple coloring and a classier look would bring in more customers. To each their own!

Anthony H.

Place rating: 1
Dix Hills, NY

Ugh I really wanted to like this place. They are closed random days. Almost every single time I go there, they are out of something. Like today, they were out of hot fudge and chocolate chips. 2 things which I always put on my yogurt. They were out of cups for a few days and used to go soup cups. Another time I had made 4 yogurts for me and my family and the guy asked if I wanted covers and a bad. Are you kidding me? Yogurtinti is only 5 mins up the road, go there if you want good yogurt and service.

Melissa L.

Place rating: 1
Kings Park, NY

For some reason I always feel very bloated after eating here. Like I ate Thanksgiving dinner yet all I had was a cup of frozen yogurt. I miss Red Mango :(The staff wasn’t very friendly and the place was a zoo. I don’t plan on returning.

Pj M.

Place rating: 1
Kings Park, NY

Went by on Friday, 11÷28÷14, day after Thanksgiving at 2pm, and store was CLOSED. No sign on door, no lights on, place looked empty. Not sure if they are out of business, but this was the WRONG day to be closed… Emilio’s was packed because is was Black Friday and everyone kept trying to get some frozen yogurt and was walking away saying the same thing, they are closed today? at 2pm?
Not good business. Maybe they couldn’t find someone to work? Would have been nice if there was a sign on the door to let the customers know that they were closed.
Went down the block and got frozen yogurt from Yogurtini, they were opened!

H. G.

Place rating: 5
Commack, NY

The staff is extremely nice and helpful and gave away free samples to all customers. The flavors were very diverse and delicious for all sorts of taste buds. I especially recommend cake batter and cookies and cream flavor. They also have yummy toppings such as rainbow cookies, fruit, chocolate, and candies of all sorts. Kids, adults, anyone will enjo Yogurt Crazy!

Cecelia E.

Place rating: 5
Port Jefferson Station, NY

The best self-serve yogurt place around! The yogurt is great, and the amount of toppings is awesome… they switch the flavors often, so best to call in advance if you’re looking for a specific flavor. The seasonal ones are so good — the pumpkin pie flavor in the Fall is amazing! The staff is super nice and helpful, and actually acknowledge when you walk in (unlike other self-service establishments I’ve been to), and try to make sure you have all your needs settled! This place is also immaculately clean — to the point that I’ve never seen any other yogurt place this clean, let alone a self-service spot that’s usually insanely messy because of kids lol. they’re constantly cleaning the toppings bar and making sure everything is stocked and clean. Definitely recommend! I’ve been to a few of the their other locations and was just as pleased.

Mike H.

Place rating: 5
Kings Park, NY

By far our favorite of all these new self-serve yogurt places. The Peanut Butter yogurt tastes just like peanut butter. I put a little hot fudge and some chocolate crunchies (like the ones from the middle of a carvel cake) on it every time I’m there!

Dermot O.

Place rating: 3
Commack, NY

Yogurt is ok. Not very welcoming employees. I have been here numerous times and there is only one person that seems to be friendly. All the other employees only speak to you by telling how much you owe. Asked for covers on yogurt tonight and girl just put them on counter for us. Then said you don’t need a bag, do you? If my kids didn’t love the experience of filling their own yogurt I would never go.

Yogurt Crazy

Commack, United States