Driving by, Casey’s is just Casey’s – the typical convenience store/gas station combo. Is the pizza the best ever? No. It’s good, though. We’ve enjoyed it many times and have never been disappointed. It’s made fresh there. They use quality ingredients. The crust is good – not too doughy, and not cardboard. The selection of ingredients is very good, comparable to what you will find at nearly any other pizza place in the area. And since Casey’s is the only pizza option here in Delavan(besides the«gourmet» pizzas at the Harvest Café or the freezer section of the grocery store or the Dollar General) Casey’s is definitely the way to go.