Extreme Pizza – Denver

Like a previous poster said, it might be the best affordable lunch in Cherry Creek. If you’re solo. I wouldn’t know. But if you are ordering for a group, I would recommend to look elsewhere. We ordered a few large pizzas for a quick staff lunch — 21 bucks a pop. and they were hardly large at 14″.
I’m giving them a 3-​star rating based solely on the pizza quality. The pizzas were very tasty, not too greasy, and obviously prepared with quality ingredients. But not worth $ 21 for a pizza that feeds 2 – 3 people, per their website. I’ll pass.

Best affordable lunch in Cherry Creek! $ 4 for a slice and a small drink. Sandwiches and salads are reasonable too. Everything is delicious and made quickly. The staff is very friendly and helpful. All the ingredients are fresh and they have a wide range of housemate tasty toppings: pesto, caramelized onions, candied walnuts.
And they wash their hands, a lot. Seriously, sitting at the counter for 10 minutes and I saw every employee watch their hands at least once. If only I could get my kids to learn that trick…

Great pizza. Now that the place is under new ownership it has really turned around. The food is great and the customer service is good. I would recommend this to anyone who wants to enjoy a relaxed atmosphere and good pizza!

I decided to try it again after hearing about NEW OWNERS! Wow! Walked in and the place looks spic and span, the pizza was great (thin crust, thank you very much) Very gracious staff. They went out of their way to make it a great experience. I ordered again, this time delivery and it was speedy, hot and again DELiSH. I’m so happy to finally have my very own ONE go-​to place for pizza.

Apparently new owners make a difference! The pizza is still incredible, the staff is friendly and fun and the place is clean as a whistle – even the restrooms. Wow! I can’t say enough!

Was not very impressed with this place a little over priced. I did order through
took over an hour to get and my food was cold… I had to reheat pizza slices in my toaster oven to get it hot. Would of given it more stars had my food been hot pizza was pretty decent once it was warm and I could enjoy it

Horrible! I ordered a pizza at 350pm was told 45min at 5pm I called wondering where my food was… Talked to multiple people several times and by 530pm still no food kept being told the delivery person left the building. Finely after 7calls when I said forget it this is ridiculous the guy on the phone said «well that’s just fucking great.»
This is the worst service I have seen in a long time and that’s saying a lot this day in age!

I should have known when I looked at the online menu and multiple specialty pizza’s had cheddar cheese as one of the ingredients that this was going to be bad. Who puts cheddar cheese on a pizza? Yuck!
We ordered late on a weekday evening and were told 35 minutes for delivery (keep in mind we were feeling lazy and wanted delivery even though it’s within walking distance). Extreme Pizza closed at 9 pm and at 9 pm we had no pizza. We attempted to call multiple times both before and after 9 pm and no one answered. We were concerned that we had already paid for the pizza on the phone and had not had our pizza delivered nor a phone call stating it was on its way. Alas, at 9:05 pm our pizza arrived.
The pizza was subpar at best, and that’s being generous. The sausage tasted funky and old and overall it was a disappointing pizza. A frozen pizza would have been better.
Extreme Pizza may be in my neighborhood but I’m only willing to sacrifice so much for convenience. I will stick with Patxi’s or venture outside my neighborhood for better pizza in the future.

This place used to be great for delivery. I haven’t ordered from them for like a year as I had moved out of the delivery area, but definitely won’t be again. What a disappointment today.
I live 1.5 miles from them now, and was still willing to go with the 45 – 60 min wait. It took an hour and half, and when the pizza arrived it was barely warm. The driver was really apologetic, and offered me a free XL pizza the next time — but I’m not interested when there are so many places that can actually deliver on time and taste better. We heated this one up, and it wasn’t better than some Pizza Hut or Dominos crap.
After calling and being on hold for almost 8 mins, I finally was able to speak with someone who offered me a «discount». Um, no… I insisted on refund since this pizza went straight into the trash.

Ordered a pizza delivery. Called to check on the delivery a hour later and the guy said the pizza was on its way but the driver had to go into Denver and it was taking a while. I live about a mile and a half from the location I’m not sure why I was the last stop but the pizza showed up cold. It was good after I warmed it up. Maybe next time I’ll just pick it up and not be lazy.

So I moved to my new place today it’s about noon time my new fridge is empty I am getting a little hungry, and the hard working movers are probably starving…
So I ordered couple of pies from extreme pizza, 35 min later the pies are here, nothing amazing just regular pizza but exactly what we needed to get my move done ! I will try this place again soon I think this pizza place has lots of potential.

This was my second choice as the place I wanted to go to was closed on Mondays. My first thought was this is a quaint little pizza parlor! I liked that variety of the menu, and the creativity if some if the different types of pizza they offered.
Then there was the service… I stood there for about 5 minutes waiting for my order to be taken. The guys behind the counter made eye contact, but offered no greeting of any kind. No «I’ll be right with you» our anything of that nature.
It only got worse from here. So got my order placed (with minimal customer service interaction i.e. these are our specials) and then proceeded to round two of the waiting game. This must’ve been the high stakes round because 25 MINUTES LATER I finally got the sandwich I ordered. I wonder if they had to chase, pluck, and kill the chicken beforehand. That would explain why it took so ridiculously long.
In the meantime, I’m watching whole pizzas come out and be served to people who arrived after me BEFORE I got my sandwich. Which was actually good, just not worth the total lack of service. Don’t go here unless you have at least an hour for lunch!

straight terrible. If you’re from the east coast: New York, Jersey, Philly, etc don’t bother, you will be super disappointed.
Also the people who have reviewed this as good, tasty pizza, what are you stupid my dog wouldn’t even eat it. It’s worst than a Tony’s frozen pizza from King Soopers. I feel so robbed, $ 25 for the shittiest pizza n wings.

We have gone to Extreme Pizza over the years while closing out the Cherry Creek Arts Festival. This is our go-​to restaurant on the last day of the festival each year.
I will begin by saying that these folks make some amazing pizza! It’s always piping hot when brought out, and the ingredients are fresh and tasty. Kudos on having a good product that you serve to your customers!
Now, that aside. Here are some areas for improvement:
— The restaurant in general seems to have a dirty, unkempt appearance the times we have been in.
— During our last visit, the men’s restroom was filthy. There were tissues all over the ground and no paper towels.
— The food did take a while to arrive, and we had to ask for napkins, silverware, Parmesan cheese, and pepper.
There was only one employee working this past Sunday, which may account for some of these problems.
In general, it just seems like there isn’t a lot of pride of ownership. This is a shame, because I genuinely feel like they have a great product in their food. In my opinion, management needs to spend a little more time there making sure the presentation of the restaurant is clean, and up to par so customers feel welcome and comfortable.
I want to reiterate that we continue to dine with Extreme Pizza because the food is great. We will be sure to be back. I just wanted to provide some constructive criticism so they can improve their overall product!

Extreme pizza should probably be called «just pizza.» That’s exactly what you’re gonna get here — nothing amazing, nothing horrible, it’s just pizza.
We got our slices in under 6 minutes, but then again, we were the only ones there. Which was odd, it being a Saturday at noon. I guess there aren’t long lines for just pizza.
So if you’re in the area and need a quick eat, try the pepperoni and jallepeno. They use fresh ones so there’s some kick to it.
Over and out extreme.

I’ve ordered from here few times online. Pizza tastes great, good choices and generous topping.
Delivery is not super fast, but still good.

Tasty pizza, lots of choice and generous topping.
I ordered for delivery online. They read my special instruction and got me crushed pepper. Happy~ Great choice for a movie night at home.
Delivery takes a bit too long. But my pizza and wings come nice and hot, so no big deal.

Reading some of the other reviews on Unilocal about this place, I was wondering if I was reviewing the same place. This pizza is EXTREME-​ly bad.
They overcharged me the first time I ordered, and when I called them back they fixed it. But they didn’t offer anything other than a casual apology for overcharging me $ 15. Almost as if they do this regularly and only fix it when the customer catches the error.
The pizza was pathetic and horrible. I’d rather have a good quality frozen pie. We also made the mistake of ordering the wings. Bad idea. They were clearly frozen for some time before being cooked. Again, I would’ve been better off getting frozen chicken wings from the grocery store. We ordered buffalo wings, but what we got had no sauce on them whatsoever.
I suggest that the owners of this place take a visit to a good pizza place in town. IE Fat Sully’s, Enzo’s, Udis, etc and take notes. At least to get a taste of what good pizza tastes like.
EXTREMELY BAD PIZZA! FROZEN WINGS! AMATEUR HOUR!
Don’t waste your money unless you like crappy food. This meal was an insult to my pallet.

Grrr. Good menu but the delivery is ridiculous every time.
Every time I order it is the same thing. The menu looks good, so many options both traditional and gluten free. I think: remember how good the gluten free is? Then I wait, and I want, and I wait. Something is always wrong with the delivery.
This time it was that I ordered on LivingSocial and while my receipt had my address correct, Extreme Pizza defaulted to an address I used years ago. The last few times they just brought the wrong pizza or were missing something.
So if you are patient– yes its good pizza and a break from the regular menu options. If you are starving, try somewhere more reliable.

I went in here hungry and left full… but depressed.
Maybe I should explain?
Groupon had a NOW! deal for EXTREME PIZZA (I feel like I need to write it in all caps to get the point of the name across) $ 6 for an individual pizza and a drink. I can get down with that! So I went last weekend for lunch and figured the Cherry Creek area would me a mad house with other last minute shoppers out there looking for New Years Eve garb (wait, I think I was the only one) but the opposite was true. The area was dead and when my GPS lead me to Extreme’s location, I was a bit baffled. It’s in an office building but on the lower level so you have to walk down stairs that being said, you can barely see the place from street view.
So I walked in and there I was… the only person there around lunch time… on a Saturday… in Cherry Creek. Which then I started thinking «Why am I the only one here?» and «Are they even open??» Turns out they were open and somewhat happy to see someone come in. The inside is interesting, it looks like a sushi bar turned pizza bar and you go up and order than sit at the bar or the tables (no booths).
I must say they have a pretty sweet selection of pizzas – vegetarian and carnivore friendly! After standing there for what seemed like eternity, I ordered the Green with Envy, a pesto based pizza topped with tomato, basil and feta. It took about 10 minutes to make and I was happy with the pizza, it packed a lot of flavor and wasn’t oily or too heavy. Plus it was an individual pizza so I didn’t feel too guilty for snarfing every last bite down.
Even though it was a solid meal for cheap, the actual restaurant and lack of clientele just left me depressed. They have awesome pizza concoctions so I would love to see them succeed and hope they do something to get more people in there (props to them for using Groupon). Also, double props to them for having a «Order Online» option for those of us pressed for time.