Vinny’s New York Pizza & Italian Grill

After reading Vinny’s nasty comment I would again say change your page to reflect that you are closed on Sundays… that is just good manners!!!
In response to the Vinny’s post… I believe if you look at this Unilocal listing which you clearly are since you are looking at this review you can see another source of the poor information. I would hardly call it immature to review a restaurant badly when they don’t keep up with digital information. Too bad you don’t understand this!

I successfully used the 35 for 25 deal here. Great free garlic knots and delicious pizza. A good spot if you’re in the mood for some casual dining and also my new go to pie joint.

This is one of those great family owned Italian joints with really good food, fair prices and simple, no nonsense décor. We have eaten at Vinny’s for many lunches and dinners and it’s consistently good.
Great pizza, always has the right cook on the crust. While his red sauce is outstanding, I highly recommend the white pizza and I always add fresh tomatoes, basil and extra garlic. Insanely good. Eggplant parmesan is a favorite of my wife along with the Spinach and Feta with penne pasta.
If you’re a fan of subs, Vinny makes great subs and if you’re thinking about a salad, the Greek Artichoke salad is one of my favorites.
Good food, fair prices and friendly service. Vinny’s New York is a great spot to get your Italian fix.

I love Vinny’s! We had been looking for a good pizzeria for a long time and we came across this place.
Great service. Great free garlic rolls. Nice pizza. I have not tried the other items on the menu yet.
Highly recommended

Food was delicious and fresh. Service was great. Concur with all positive comments. House salad was fresh and dressing made from scratch. Appetizer rolls are addictive. Be careful! Well done, mr. vinny!

Went on a Saturday, service was great so was the food. Restaurant was not busy so everything came out pretty fast. The courtesy garlic bread was delicious. The white pizza was also very good.
DO NOT PURCHASE THE PROMO VOUCHER ON Unilocal… I purchased it and could not use it in store. No one there had any knowledge of it. The owner was kind enough to give us a discount for the confusion but we still had to pay out of pocket I am currently in the process of trying to get my money back for the voucher.

If you’re from Jersey or New York, this is the place to go! My mouth waters as I write this review. The pizza is to die for & the garlic rolls that are served free while you wait are delicious as well. Service is excellent. The restaurant is always very clean & the atmosphere is cozy. They do have a patio if you prefer to eat outside & a few TVs inside also. Wines are also delish. Love their sweet red, but I forget the name right now. Their sauce is phenomenal, their mozzarella has great flavor. Prices reasonable! Don’t miss this one!!! We have never been disappointed. Menu variety is great also! Haven’ had the pasta, but saw the portions are large. Husband had the ravioli & it was also delish!

I come here often & I’m never disappointed. The prices are extremely reasonable & if you have the taste for Italian you’ll get the taste & feel here. Great for business lunches & family dinners.

Authentic home made tasting Italian food. The «vinny’s special» pizza is great. They have the best Alfredo sauce I’ve had and their chicken parmigiana and eggplant parmigiana are delicious!
We eat here about once a week

Fried calamari appetizer was excellent. Perfectly cooked and fresh texture and not overly salty. House salad I ordered with meal was $ 3 ok price since portion was small. Spinach stuffed shells had equal amount of spinach and ricotta cheese inside with marinara sauce on top. Chicken parmigiana tasted great and was good portion and also came with spaghetti and marinara sauce. Garlic rolls were complimentary and very good. Total price for all this and 2 soft drinks was $ 45 including tax. Service was prompt.

We were promptly greeted by a friendly server and soon had drinks and delicious garlic rolls sitting in front of us. We met some friends so there was a variety of food that was shared amongst us. Pizza, chicken parmesan, lasagna, and spaghetti were all delicious and to-​go boxes had to packed up due to the almost overflowing plates. I highly recommend Vinny’s for your Italian dining fix.

Just used my scoutmob deal here and I have to say me and my family were very satisfied along with STUFFED. Everyone enjoyed it and we didn’t seem to encounter the 18% gratuity addition like others (we still gave 20%) and the service was good. The pizza was yummy and the Caesar salad was also very good. Even before my mom tried the pizza she was already telling herself she was coming back. I could even go as far as say the pizza was better than some I tried in ny last month granted they were cheap slices from tourist areas. I find the owner comments quite funny because to me he shows his confidence in his business as he should because I enjoyed my experience. Duluth doesn’t have that many great pizza options so I do recommend this restaurant especially if you have scoutmob. It’s worth it!

Came here last night for a casual, low-​key Vday dinner, and am happy to report we encountered only a very brief wait (prob 5 mins), even without a reservation!
I was RAVENOUS because we’d essentially skipped lunch, and so was super grateful for the free buttery garlic rolls to tide us over until the rest of the food arrived.
The house salad is large enough to split between two people if you both are longing for some veggies alongside the otherwise rather heavy pasta entrees. I really enjoyed the delightfully herby vinaigrette that came with the salad.
Props, too, for the Pasta Diavolo. That was my entrée this time around (with fettucine as my pasta of choice), and the tomato-​based sauce had just enough sweetness, though not enough spice, for my taste. But I do admit that that’s probably a good thing – you can actually taste what you are eating, instead of just having your mouth on fire! I bet it would be even better with shrimp.

I’ve dined in here 5 – 10 times and taken out food 10 – 15 times. I really don’t think you can get better Italian food in the area for the price. Luciano’s is more of a nicer, sit-​down only place so I don’t place them in the same category. This place has great pizza and I recommend it very highly.

This is an absolute «MUST TRY». The food is very good. The portions are perfect. I got a soup and salad and was full for the rest of the day. I took a bite of husband’s chicken marsala and it was great! The marsala sauce was a little thin than the recipe calls for, but the flavor was on point. The service was also good. Our glasses were kept full and the dishes were taken away right when we were done. Some have said the price is high, but in my opinion, these prices are indeed reflective of the quality of service and food you get. I don’t think you can go wrong with this place. Kudos to the owner (s). This place has it!

The service here is always great and efficient. It is a well priced option for dinner, with a nice assortment of beers and I suspect a nice assortment of seemingly well priced wines. I don’t know why (maybe the oven??) but I honestly think the Midtown location hits NY style right on the nose, where as this one is a little off, but still one of, if not the best option in Gwinnett.
I like the booths, I like the two or three TVs around the dining room to loosely watch a game during the meal, and I love the garlic knot bread service to start the meal. You see a nice a mix of all ages, from kids coming out of HS sports games, to young families, to big families in this joint.
I come here two to three times a year and it is consistent.

The garlic rolls are to die for! If you aren’t a fan of much garlic, these are NOT the rolls for you. I ordered the pizza daily lunch special, 2 slices and a salad for $ 6. I guess one shouldn’t expect too much for that price. It was ok. The pizza was a little too salty but served its purpose. The salad wasn’t the best either. Great customer service. I’ll give it another chance since I work nearby.

We decided to get a pizza to go and 2 slices of cheesecake. The pizza was just OK (granted, we let it get a little cold) and the cheesecake left much to be desired. It was a bit too mushy and there wasn’t a contrast in the consistency of the cheesecake and the crust (I happen to like my crust a bit crunchy).
I would go back for pasta, but I’ll definitely pass on the pizza and the cheesecake.

Think again if your wanting Italian. This review is based on the pasta dishes and sandwiches. Not sure about the pizza, but the rest of the food tastes like it came out of a can.
We had a table of four, and no one said they would go back after. The salads were the best part of the meal. The entrees left a lot to be desired.
The service was good, no problems there. That’s why they didn’t get a 1 star.

I’ll try to be as unbiased as possible in this review, however I am appalled by how the owner of this establishment chooses to respond to customers. I don’t have a «the customers is always right» mentality. Some people can be demanding a-​holes and it’s your right as a business owner to defend your business. But I don’t think it’s necessary to personally attack anyone for having a bad experience at your establishment.
Atmosphere: We came during lunch on a Sunday afternoon and were the only patrons there. Restaurant was sparingly decorated with tables and booths.
Food: We ordered a supreme style pizza and chicken Alfredo. Garlic butter rolls came out while we waiting for our food. Rolls were hard and the butter didn’t have a good flavor to it. It was pretty bland, which seems to be an ongoing theme. Pizza came out and it looked fine. Toppings were a little scarce. I wasn’t a big fan of the sauce or the crust. Sauce lacked flavor and the crust could have used a good crunch. It was doughy. My boyfriend, who never saw a chicken Alfredo he didn’t finish, didn’t bother to take home half his plate. I took a bite and agreed the Alfredo sauce was too thin and lacked any flavor whatsoever.
Service: It was ok. I remember us having to look around for our server at the end of our meal to get the check even if we were still the only patrons there.
Overall, I’m really disappointed that I just couldn’t like the food here. We literally live down the street and it would have been great to support a local pizza joint. However, combine bad food with an owner who harasses reviewers online, we’ll be taking our business elsewhere.
In response to Vincent: You guys were once upon a time since I am usually only in town on the weekends due to school. If not, then my mistake for forgetting the exact date.