Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar

I love ice cream, and no flavor more than rum raisin. So when the shop owner suggested to me the frozen pudding, which sounded like some bizarre New England amalgamation of rum raisin and tutti-​frutti, I was hesitant. I shouldn’t have been – it was absolutely delicious. My fiancée had a black raspberry with chunks of brownie swirled into it that was just as good. Their chocolates looked amazing as well, but those will have to wait until a repeat visit.

Great selection of candy, and the ice cream is really good! My favorite part is the chocolate, so many different kinds and they’re all sooo good!

When you’re fronting harborside seating in Edgartown, you don’t necessarily have to scoop the best ice cream in town.
That said, my double stacks of peach featured a healthy sampling of fruit, but a bit too much crystallization to warrant a return trip amidst a sea of options.
Two scoops in sugar or cake cone nears $ 5 after tax. The swarms of kids raiding the candy half of this parlor, throwing bows and stomping toes? Absolutely free.
Cash only.

Good ice cream but Ben and bills is much better. They are very friendly but there are better options.

Even though I had already consumed a pint of ice cream that day, I caved. Moose tracks called my name! The fudge in that ice cream was divine! Also the candy there is pretty cheap all things considered.

We were recommended to check out this ice cream shop by one of our waiters at dinner. He said that the ice cream is just as delightful, and that you get to eat it without the hour long wait that Mad Martha’s had. This being my first night on the vineyard, I decided to take some local advice, and choose the road less taken.
The Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar is super small inside, but a precious little building. It makes me wonder what this building used to be back in the day… because it’s located right on the docks.
There are shelves of candy in jars, where your sugar loving friends can make mixed bags out of their favorite novelties.
On the other side of the store are the ice cream servers. The store has about 20 different ice creams, and they are more than happy to let you taste them. I tried the peppermint stick, as well as the chocolate peanut butter. Both were delightful, but the first choice won. The serving size was average, which my waistline will appreciate, and the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. $ 4.50 for a small ice cream, about $ 5.00 for a large.
The building is small, a bit crowded, and doesn’t really have a system of who orders, but everyone is pleasant because they are getting their sweetie :)
Enjoy, avoid the lines, eat drink and be merry!