Joey’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice

Went to Joeys for the first one on Friday, I read the reviews and had some word of mouth referrals, so I decided to give it a chance.
I got 2 pies, one being a Joeys Choice. Both pies were delicious. I think this will become my new pizza place of choice.
I highly recommend Joeys. Can’t wait until the next pie.

First time here and I was really impressed. It’s not that impressive to look at, just a few booths and a takeout counter, but the pizza was amazing!
I went with a friend and we ordered the margherita and Greco specialities. We asked for mediums and ended up getting larges bc the waitress messed up, but she didn’t charge us, which was good. I was expecting the smaller size that are typical of wood fire places, but these were 16″ beauties. The Greco was my favorite. The quality was notable — plenty of good cheese, tons of garlic, olive oil coming through at the end and the saltiness of prosciutto balanced it all out. The margherita was really good too, but my friend ordered it with sauce instead of sliced tomatoes. The sauce was really good but I think I would’ve preferred the sliced tomatoes as the almost whole tomatoes were just a touch too much. The basil could’ve been stronger too, I didn’t taste too much of it. I also didn’t taste too much of a wood fire or smoke taste. Despite this, the pizza was really really good.
I also ordered a 4 meat pizza to go. It was loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage and meatballs for a great price. It probably would’ve cost a lot more at other places if I had all that meat.
This is my new favorite pizza and I’m bummed it’s in endicott and I can’t get it more often!

Best Pizza in Broome County. Lived in Sicily for three years and this is the closest pizza you can get that is like in the pizza from Sicily. Highly recommend.

They have specialty Italian sandwiches you can’t find anywhere else typically. Haven’t tried the pizza yet, but hear it’s very good.

I really wanted to like this place. They advertise a wood fired brick oven that gives their crust an amazing taste. I was excited for a delicious pizza!!! Instead, the crust was a little bit too thick for my tastes. The bottom was alright — but the inside (top) of the crust tasted undercooked and unappetizing — soggy, even. Yes, I know that this is the part that is covered with sauce, but it just tasted a lot more moist and undercooked than it should have been. Hence, the signature part of their pizza was the most disappointing.
Now, I have to give a disclaimer. I love New York Style pizza with a thin crispy crust. This is NOT that. It’s different. Feels «homemade». I’m sure that other people may like this style of pizza with a thicker crust, but it’s not my thing. So if you don’t mind a thicker style crust, you might enjoy their pizza. Their sauce also had chunks of tomato in it — was decent.
All in all, depending on your tastes, their pizza could be hit or miss.
Edit: Apparently from other reviews, the style of pizza in which they specialize is called «Greco».

This place is a staple in our town. Joey concentrates on QUALITY ingredients with mor attention to detail than the other places in Endicott that claim to be ‘Italian’. At Joeys you can count on that Italian cold cut sandwich your Nona or Uncle Vinnie would jam together for you with love. Not just a ‘sub’ or a salad with a bunch of bland iceberg lettuce or dry speedies thrown on it like neighboring places do, Joeys has a theme to the menu with custom sandwiches, salads, and gourmet pizza. The last time I ordered a custom pizza, the pizza chef who was a young lady, circled around with the other staff and cheered over how delicious the pie looked. I planned to share it with nobody!
Thanks Joeys, keep up the good work

Wasn’t impressed
Ordered pasta and pizza for the family for dinner
The pasta was forced down their throats and the pizza kept falling apart
Such a tragedy because we love brick oven…

Based on the greco pizza. Very worthy of a 5 star review. Piping hot and fresh right out of the oven. Lunchtime on a Wednesday. Relatively cheap also. Pizza was $ 13.

Joeys is a great little local restaurant to eat at. The staff is great and the owner is very friendly. It is my kids favorite pizza in town and I really love there wings and they fact that they come with fries. Very casual place and food is always fresh and comes out fast.

I really enjoy Joeys, they have a decent size menu which includes pizza, sandwiches and a variety of other things. The bread that they use for their sandwiches is always fresh and tasty. Even an ordinary turkey sandwich tastes amazing. They also have a catering company called De Gennaros which is great at well! We used them for my bridal shower and the food was great! We had sandwiches, pasta salad, tossed salad and their house chips which were all very flavorful.

Thin and crispy crust, reasonable prices, cozy and casual ambiance, and welcoming servers! Highly satisfied. One drawback was that the tomato sauce for pizza was too sweet for my taste. I hope they will serve tap beer in the future.

Let me just say I have been a loyal fan of Joey’s for many years. I love their food. However, this game with their menu MUST END! Based on a previous user’s comment, this has been going on far too long. I don’t how anyone at Joey’s could argue that this is a good business practice, and I don’t think anyone would say it would cause to them to think any better of Joey’s. What does it cost to print out new menus?
They won’t get my five stars until they rectify the situation.

Small seating area. Great takeout. Love the brick oven pizza and chicken wings. Fries are undercooked and limp. Reasonably priced.

one of the only wood fired oven pizza places in the greater binghamton area. the crust on this pizza is very good, unfortunately i’m not a fan of their tomato sauce. it’s too chunky for my tastes, but still, they put out a very good pie, AND their frozen custard and italian ice are the best in the area, check these guys out!

Hands down the best pizza and wings ever! The staff is awesome! Sign up for the rewards. You get 2 slices and a can soda for doing so! Very generous.

Joey’s has great food! BUT, for over a year they have been playing this game with their menu pricing. Most of the prices are wrong on both the printed menu and their website, and they aren’t upfront about this when you order. If you happen to catch it and ask, they’ll admit they need to print new menus. That’s fine, for a couple weeks, maybe a month. But to continue using the same menus after more than a year is just plain misleading.

This place is one of my favorite places ever! The pizza can NOT be beat. The crust is amazing, and it’s brick oven which pizza lovers know, is the best way to cook a pizza. The toppings are always plentiful and great. The cheese and sauce are to die for as well.
And just when you think it can’t get any better you walk outside and get a gelato and your mind gets blown! Their gelato’s are the best thing I have ever had in my entire life of being alive. I live for their gelato’s. When I lived in Binghamton we seriously went every other night. They have so many choices it’s unreal and they are usually all good!
This will continue to be one of my favorite places and I hope it stays open for many more years to come!

The ice is served through a little window on the side of the building, open until 10 most nights I believe. Close enough for us to walk, so we go often. The Italian ice is great and very inexpensive: a medium will get you A LOT for a couple of bucks. If they ever make a pear-​flavored Italian ice, I might just sleep out front.
The pizza is great too, and again, the prices are very reasonable. And they have fried ravioli here — what they call back in St. Louis «toasted ravioli» — which was exciting, because I never expected to see it in NY.

First off, good gelatto’s.
Second, that’s if they have the flavor you want. Which they are always running out of.
This is a great place to stop at on a bike ride on a hot night. Oh yea dont bother sitting at the picnic tables unless if you want to get covered in sugar from all the children who haven’t learned how to get italian ice into their mouths yet…

Great, original, pizza — fresh from a wood-​burning brick oven. I’ll usually get meatballs as a topping. The slices are large so two is more than enough for me. The sauce is sweet and delicious and full of texture. You’ve got to try it yourself to see what I mean.
Joey’s has other menu items too. I like to get a turkey sandwich. Now I know this sounds plain for an italian place, but it’s great! It comes on fresh bread (very tasty) with your choice of toppings. There’s a list of toppings to choose from. It comes with a side of chips. The hot subs are also fantastic. There are also 5 – 6 beers to choose from. The price is great too. The cold sandwich will run you $ 6, and the hot sandwich $ 7. I hear their italian ices are great too, but haven’t tried it for myself. A gem of little italy!