Panatieri’s Pizza and Pasta

Tortellini pizza was great but the white ricotta tasted extremely odd. Waitress was standoffish but she still continued to refill our drinks. I would have appreciated a better attitude as I did my best to cheer her up by thanking her countless times.

Very disappointed in the quality and taste of the pizza. The service is the only reason for two stars. Very soggy Brooklyn crust and no flavor in the sauce. The pizza should be the star!!!

Horrible. Using this restaurant for years. Saw it go down. Soggy pizza. Horrible pasta dishes thrown together. Worse yet promises as to delivery time 20 – 30 minutes late then cold slop. Will not use this restaurant again. There are many others that that are 100% better.

Grumpy delivery men if it’s not the young guys. Over an hour late, and after a small tip they «change their delivery area.» Not worth the stop, considering the area is packed full of good pizza places.

Panatieri’s is awesome!!! Their house dressing, which you buy to take home, is delicious! In a strip mall so it doesn’t look like much but this place is a gem. We found it a few years ago on our way to visit family and now it’s our go-​to stop. Kids love it too. Lots if varieties of pizzas as well as the usuals. Pasta and chicken parm fantastic. Warm garlic rolls also delicious. Price is right. Can’t beat it. Staff very accommodating and polite. Can’t lose with Panatieri’s.

The young man at the register assured me my order was correct but when i got home it was completely different. I was pretty ticked off after a long days work and driving home to disappointment. I sure didn’t feel like driving all the way back. I called and «Joe» sincerely apologized. He went out of his way to make it right. He had the order delivered ASAP (past their delivery distance) and threw in 2 large delicious canolis! Excellent management decision. I felt a lot better and will definitely return after seeing him right the mistake. BTW the food was very good!

So, I have to be one of Panatieri’s best customers. I’ve been to at least 6 of their locations and go pretty regularly. In my opinion, the Martinsville location is their best location. Warren is pretty good, as well. I was really high on the Flemington location until our most recent visit. We stopped in here on a Sunday around lunch time. The restaurant was pretty empty — a couple of people eating.
They had a decent slice pie selection but they did not have their Cheesesteak pizza which was definitely disappointing. There was a guy making a pizza working the register and my wife and I placed our order with him. We then grabbed a table. Another group came in after we had ordered, placed their order and sat down. Their pizza was delivered to their table. I found that to be strange.
The guy working the front then asked us what we had ordered. I guess he had forgotten our order; I’m a pretty forgiving guy so no big deal. A few minutes later, the waitress came over and asked us what we had ordered. We placed our order a 3^rd time. I actually couldn’t believe it. At this point, I was not pleased. She had said they were really busy which I found surprising because there was hardly any one in the restaurant.
After we placed the exact same order for the 3^rd time, our pizza was then brought out. It was good. I’m a huge fan of the pizza here (see my previous review). There’s a lot of good pizza places in Flemington and I’m not sure if I’d come back here after our most recent visit.

Our family’s go-​to spot in Flemington for speciality slices. They have a pretty diverse and solid selection. For plain pies or sandwiches, look elsewhere.

Our dinner on this visit was not what we had experienced in the past. Different chef in the kitchen? We have always enjoyed this restaurant in the past. Perhaps an off night. Service was good. Salads very, very small. Main course was also very small, enough, just surprisingly small. Something changed.

There are a few locations around NJ, but quality, price and service vary greatly. The Branchburg location is a little shady and higher priced on specials.
This location has good food and service. Tuesday night pizza special is a great deal, most of the food is priced OK in general.
This place and Alfonoso’s are good pizza spots, though I haven’t tried every place in the area yet.

Don’t go there! Food made me sick. Couldn’t eat anything for days!

Very good food. Slow service. But, i guess they are will to wait for good food. Food is expensive.

Wow, I enjoy the Brooklyn style pizza.

Good food. Lunch took an 1 hour and 20 minutes to get delivered. Unhappy with that part.

Having lived in the area for about a year and a half now, I must say I am very impressed. From their pizza and pasta to their service and delivery, they never disappoint. The food is always delivered within the estimated timeframe provided and it always arrives hot and fresh. We’ve tried almost every pizzeria in the area and have concluded that this is by bar the best!

Dissappointing experience visiting Panetieris for the first time in a few years. My family of four was in for an impromptu Sunday dinner out, and ordered appetizers, entrees and a cheese steak. The sandwich order was botched and clumsily handled by the waitstaff, cook and the manager on site for the evening. Our table watched the laughable exchange between the waitress and cook as she repeatedly returned the sandwich to complete the orders’ addition of hot peppers and grilled onions. The cook even joked that he was distracted by a sporting event on tv. This was in full view and earshot of our table. When the sandwich finally arrived well behind the rest of the tables orders it was cold, with raw onions tossed on the top rather than the grilled onions ordered. We could have sent it back, but the rest of the table was already a third of the way through dinner by then.
At the end of the meal we asked that the sandwich, which only had about three bites taken, be removed from the bill. The waitress assured us it already had been. But it wasn’t (rather, a five dollar discount had been given). I brought this to the manager’s attention, and she conveyed that the five dollar versus the full cost deduction was her decision because more than one bite had been consumed. At no point did she apologize for the miscommunication by the server, or the visible exchange as the sandwich was repeatedly returned to the kitchen. A ‘sorry’ and a smile would have gone a long way in demonstrating customer care. I won’t return; there are plenty of other Italian/​pizza joints in town properly staffed to handle the inevitable errors that can happen, and keep customers rather than lose them.

I was really upset by their service which is why I am giving them 1 stars. Pizza is not bad, but I can’t say anything about their entrees since I didn’t even have the privilege to be served. It is self seating for dine-​in and in a typical restaurant, you are greeted by a server and asked for a drink order. My friend and I sat IN FRONT of the waiter station and didn’t even get eye contact. We had entered the restaurant at the same time as another couple and I sat and watched as they were given menus (I had to reach over to the waiter station and grab a menu from there) and had a drink order taken. Then I watched as the two waiters working WALK PAST my table to fulfill orders and drink orders. OK. 5 mins go by. No one making eye contact. 5 mins go by, chit chat among the waiters in the wait station. 4 mins go by and they go to the other tables (mind you, there were about 5 other tables filled around us… split amongst 2 waiters…) So, I just had to leave. The look of shock that no one attended my table was pretty much feigned and I had completely lost my respect for them. Congratulations Panatieri’s, if this review gave stars out on mediocre service, you would have gotten 5 stars. If you want really good sized portions and really good italian entress, I suggest going to
down the road past the circle. Their wait staff were professional and attentive. comparing prices you also get a better atmosphere AND more food AND it’s BYOB AND someone who will take your order.
just saying.

When we first moved to this area 9 years ago, we asked around for the most recommended pizza places. This continues to be our favorite overall. It was called «Frank’s» and we continue to call it so. :-)
This Panatieri’s is awesome! From their pizzas, pasta dishes, salads, subs, chicken, we’ve never had a bad meal. I especially love their cheesesteak and meatball parm subs. They’ve also catered a couple of our parties and did an excellent job.
Joe is fabulous as is the rest of his staff. It does get busy, especially on Friday nights and Saturdays, so plan accordingly.

Really great food! I got a chicken dish with Marsala, spinach and mushrooms… so delicious. Not oversalted. And my boyfriend got a chicken cheesesteak, he said it was a little dry but that’s what you get for getting chicken! We really enjoyed our meal and our waitress brought us some zeppoles (bad spelling?) for dessert! For free. Very awesome, great food.

I think this is the best pizzeria in the flemington area. A plain pie is pretty simple and they got it right. Out of all of their locations, flemington hands down is the best of them all. I have tried some of their dinner dishes which were pretty good for a pizzeria.
Overall I do think they are expensive but if I am in the mood for pizza, this is the place I go if I am in flemington. Give it a try.