Butter Cream Cupcakery

Fort Collins, United States

4.2

Open now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 970-225-1040
Website:
www.buttercreamcupcakery.com
Address:
3663 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO, 80525
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
540 ftHorsetooth Station
620 ftHorsetooth & Mason
850 ftHorsetooth & MAX
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes

Today

Today 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Fort Collins) 1:45 PM Tuesday, June 24, 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Tuesday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Wednesday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Thursday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Friday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Saturday 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Sunday –

Related places

Explore similar places:
1
mi
La Creperie
2722 S College Ave
1.3
mi
Redtail Coffee
4915 Fossil Blvd
1.4
mi
Fiona’s Deli
1001 E Harmony Rd
1.4
mi
Great Harvest Bread Co
2601 S Lemay Ave Unit 1
2.1
mi
Tortillas Las Cuatro Americas
1669 S College Ave
2.4
mi
Eileen’s Colossal Cookies
2614 S Timberline Rd Ste 107

Vicinity

Near this location:
1
ft
Asian Grill Express
3663 S College Ave Ste 12
1
ft
Pet City
3663 S College Ave Ste 10
140
ft
Nice Nails
3675 S College Ave Ste 16A
160
ft
Tat 2 Undo
3675 S College Ave
260
ft
Red Wing Shoe Store
3645 S College Ave
260
ft
Red Wing Shoes
3645 S College Ave

20 reviews of Butter Cream Cupcakery

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Denver, CO
Stopped in a got mini cupcakes, one of each flavor. I was not a fan of the neapolitan, most of the others were okay, but I absolutely loved the red velvet and the chocolate cupcake with the chocolate chip icing!
Place rating: 5
Fort Collins, CO
I really like the variety. The staff are very friendly. I recommend for that every once in a while occasion
Place rating: 4
Fort Collins, CO
I tried many of their cupcakes and they were alright. I gave them 4 starts for their red velvet cupcake, It is da bomb!!! That’s the only one I order now.
Place rating: 4
Laramie, WY
Stopped in on a Sunday for a birthday treat. Fairly limited selection, but I suppose that’s normal. Had the «yummy» cupcake; poppyseed cupcake filled with raspberry jam and topped with a lemon cream cheese icing. Super good. Other patron in the party had the red velvet cupcake, which is always wonderful.
Place rating: 4
Loveland, CO
LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Their cupcakes are amazing!!! My kiddos and I stop by every once in a while for a sweet pick me up. The only issue I’ve ever had here is with red velvet– the cake was dry, but I am from the south and red velvet is a pretentious desert that requires at least a 2 layer slice.
Our favorite flavors are chocolate & vanilla, peanut butter and hands down the vanilla bean! Now that I am writing this review I am thinking about how soon I can stop by for a few minis — Keep making amazing cupcakes and I will keep randomly stopping by!
Place rating: 5
South Pasadena, CA
Success! Mission accomplished. Let me explain.
You might find it a bit strange that I have written a review all the way from California. However, my girlfriend has visited Colorado to do some volunteer work during her spring break (she is also a Cali native). Not only has she sacrificed her spring break for a greater calling, her birthday happened to fall in spring break week as well. Feeling a bit down, Robin & Ryan was able to get dozens of cupcakes sent out to a neighboring city (where she is doing service) to brighten up her special day. I wish I was able to taste these delicious treats, however, I received very positive feedback from my girlfriend and everyone who indulged in the mini cupcakes. Great people, great cupcakes, and great service! Will most definitely make a stop if I ever make it to Colorado. Red Velvet is on point! (so I hear.)
Place rating: 5
Manhattan, NY
AHHHHMAZING!!!
Vanilla Bean and Almond Joy are the best cupcakes I’ve ever had. Plus, the customer service is outstanding.
I consider myself a cupcake aficionado having made travel plans around locations where Sprinkles Cupcakes (the ones I compared all to) can be found! Now I can buy even better ones in Colorado (they beat Cupcake Girls too) — I’ll never leave the state again.
Place rating: 5
Windsor, CO
I LOVE this place! I’m not usually a fan of baked goods I don’t make myself, but Buttercream Cupcakery is the exception. Their cupcakes are fantastic! My favorites are Salty Caramel, Almond Joy, Blueberry Pancake and the classic Chocolate on Vanilla. The staff is always welcoming and clearly excited to be working for the shop. The owner often hooks me up with free mini cupcakes and is a real pleasure to chat with!
Place rating: 4
Denver, CO
I really enjoyed my mini vanilla bean cupcake here. Great frosting to cupcake ratio. It’s really bright in there though; not very cozy. Still, if I needed cupcakes for any reason in Fort Collins, I’d head right back to this place!
Place rating: 4
Fort Collins, CO
I LOVE THEIR CUPCAKES! You can never be disappointed with them! They are always moist, flavorful, and have a pretty good balance between frosting and cake. I wish they had more flavors available each day though. They have their classics (vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, etc) and one special flavor each day.
My favorite flavor is their chocolate cupcake with Guinness frosting. The frosting definitely has that yummy beer flavor, and I can’t really find it anywhere else. This flavor doesn’t come out very often since it’s one of their special flavors.
One problem I had with this location is their hours. I used to always crave their cupcakes after work, but I finished RIGHT when they closed. Good thing they have their Old Town location where they are opened later!
Place rating: 4
Lone Tree, CO
Have stopped in here several times over the last couple of years. Good cupcakes. Not as good as Posh in Parker, but much closer when you are in Ft. Collins. Sometimes the variety could be a bit better. I guess I tend to be there at the end of the day.
Place rating: 4
Columbia, MD
The cute décor with clean, clear windows full of yummy looking cupcakes can make every girl stop by and wanting to check out. So do I. :P
The one I had is one of their Daily Flavors, Chocolate Dipped Strawberry. Mr. Big, of course, had his favorite red velvet. The cake is smooth and not too sweet with natural flavor. I really like their strawberry icing which also adds a little refreshing fruity taste to balance out the cream.
See more with pictures at:
Place rating: 5
Kailua, HI
Love!!!
Having recently moved from New York back to Colorado, I have developed an addiction to cupcakes (Thanks to the likes of Magnolia) Butter Cream helps satisfy my addiction :)
They have a wonderful selection of flavors, including their regulars and their specials, and come in both mini and standard size. The cupcakes a wonderfully fresh, moist, and most importantly delicious! The Frosting is strong, yet not overpowering and tasty.
After taking them to a family dinner once, it’s not basically required that I do so all the time now, yay for Butter Cream! Go there now, you’ll be happy you did! :)
Place rating: 5
Lewisville, TX
This place sells buttercream shots for a dollar! How awesome is that?
The name rocks it and the product was perfect!
I picked up several dozen minis for a business account and of course I ordered my own cupcake to sample! It was simply perfect! I didn’t know what to choose so I asked the person helping me to suggest and she said salted caramel sells out first and it sounded good to me. Moist with a lovely center and buttercream icing that rivals the best I’ve ever had!
This is a cupcake made by somebody who cares about the flavor and freshness!
Place rating: 2
Fort Collins, CO
The only reason I gave it a 2 star was the people, they were quite friendly. My gripe is simply this, 3 dollars for a regular sized cupcake. It wasn’t bad at all, just not worth 3 dollars. You could go to king soopers and buy cupcake mix and do it yourself, unless you happen to be a lazy ass like myself, even then I could not, would not pay three bucks for a cupcake! I would not, not recommended it, just be forewarned.
Place rating: 2
Fort Collins, CO
I’ve had their cupcakes a few times and most of the time the cakes have been over baked and dry. Also their frosting to cake ratio is questionable. I have never had a cupcake from them that was amazing, it’s always just a cupcake, nothing to write home about.
If you are need a cupcake they will do if you want a really great cupcake go somewhere else.
Place rating: 3
Ames, IA
Buy one get one free coupon in local Fort Collins streetmosphere guide book! Found at most businesses.
Place rating: 5
Arthur, IL
Delicious cupcakes and an adorable atmosphere! I definitely recommend this cupcakery. I want to go back tomorrow to try tomorrow’s flavors! :)
Place rating: 4
Carmel, CA
Daily flavors
Monday — pumpkin
Tuesday — pb and j
Wed — almond joy
Thurs — salted caramel
Fri — chic dipped strawberry
Sat — yummy
Place rating: 5
Denver, CO
Love, love love Buttercream! They have the best cupcakes I have eaten in my quest for the perfect cupcake. They have beat out other bakeries in Chicago, New York, Denver and Hawaii. The cupcakes are made daily with fresh ingredients and as such, you need to be prepared to eat them right then and there (I have had many a cupcake in the parking lot or driving back to work which is a mere five minutes away).
The pink lemonade is my favorite followed by the Dubliner and Red Velvet. Truly you can’t go wrong with any of the flavors. The icing is consistantly smooth, creamy and not overly sweet which is my favorite part and one that I eat like an ice cream cone.