Justine’s Pizza

Fort Collins, United States

3.3

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 970-225-1950
Website:
www.justinespizza.com
Address:
140 E Boardwalk Dr, Fort Collins, CO, 80525
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
430 ftJFK & Boardwalk
0.3 miJFK & Horsetooth
0.3 miJFK & Troutman
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch, Dinner
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Quiet
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
No

Today

Today 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Fort Collins) 2:14 PM Tuesday, June 3, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 2:00 pm
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Saturday 4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Sunday 4:00 pm – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Here at Justine’s, our pizzas are made to order with the highest quality fresh ingredients. We have developed an outstanding reputation for serving top-​quality pizza with excellent service! Every batch of dough and sauce is made in the restaurant using the decades old recipe. All of our pizza ingredients and toppings are the best and freshest available!

From classic pizza toppings to the unique and specialty, we are sure to have something you’ll love. Be sure to try the Justine special, made from our delicious signature dough and sauce, cheese, beef, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, and onions! Not in the mood for pizza? We also have delicious calzones, poor boys, salads, and dessert.

Hosting a corporate lunch or fundraiser? Give us a call.

Come in today and try any of our variety of award winning pizzas!

History

Established in 1971.

Justine’s Pizza was established in Loveland, Colorado in 1971. Since then, we have opened 2 other locations in Northern Colorado (Fort Collins and Eaton)

Meet the Business Owner

Tom S.

Business Owner

Tom enjoys being able to serve the public at Justine’s Pizza where high quality food and outstanding customer service are the driving forces of the business.

Related places

You might also like:
1
mi
Domino’s Pizza
901 E Harmony Rd
1
mi
Papa Murphy’s
238 E Harmony Rd Unit D9
1
mi
Pizza Hut
4643 S Mason St
1.1
mi
CosmoNoms
1003 W Horsetooth Rd
1.2
mi
Cozzola’s Pizza-South
1112 Oakridge Dr Unit 114
1.4
mi
Little Caesars Pizza
1514 E Harmony Rd

Vicinity

Near this location:
1
ft
Wuerker Rich DDS
140 Boardwalk Dr
1
ft
Shannon At Rock Paper Scissors Salon
140 Boardwalk Unit O
1
ft
Westaff
140 Boardwalk Dr
1
ft
Huntington Learning Center
140 E Boardwalk Ste P
1
ft
LaMar’s Donuts & Coffee
140 E Boardwalk Dr
1
ft
Northern Colorado Laser & Skin
140 E Boardwalk Dr

20 reviews of Justine’s Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 1
Fort Collins, CO
Stopped by at 12:50 on a Thursday; they informed me that they had run out of pizza but could make another if I wanted one. Most pizzerias have a few pizzas to buy by the slice in their restaurants. This place had ZERO pizza for walk ins unless we «wanted them to make another». Yea bud, I would have wanted you to make another. I can’t comment on the taste of the pizza, because I never had the chance to eat it. There are too many amazing pizza places in Fort Collins to be this lazy. Not a single slice ready to eat existed in that store during the hours it was supposed to be open for business, and to clarify, they do have an area where by-​the-​slice pizzas are displayed and their special included two slices and a drink; so I’m not just ranting about a to-​go restaurant. Go somewhere else.
Place rating: 2
Orange, CA
Placed a to go order recently. The pizza wasn’t ready when it was promised. I waited 10 – 12 min for the pizza and left. When I opened the box, I couldn’t believe how underdone the pizza was. I can’t even believe it was in the oven for 10 min at the store. We had to put it in the oven to bake which was really annoying when there were hungry kids waiting. Overall, once it was baked, the pizza was delicious and the crust was perfect.
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
Ehhh it was ok nothing super amazing we ordered a large pizza with extra sauce couldn’t tell it it had extra then a family size salad… Um that salad could maybeeee feed two it was so small I had to ask is that a family size salad?!? He said it was… Don’t think we’ll be back there’s much better pizza out there!
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
I’ve gotten Justine’s Pizza for years and loved it but it was different this last time. Has it changed ingredients or ownership? Instead of the light fluffy crust it was a thin crust (not ordered), half of the crust was burnt and the extra tomatoes on top were not fresh as they usually are.
I will give another try but was disappointed this last trip
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
I don’t know if 3 stars fits my recommendation, because I won’t be getting pizza from here again. I ordered (online) a cheese pizza on super bowl. It was delivered fast and the pizza was hot, but it was pretty terrible tasting. Really, no flavor to be found. The crust was similar to cardboard and the cheese was tough, there was no stringy, gooey-​ness to it. The sauce was pasty and on the sweet side. A+ for fast delivery though.
Place rating: 1
New York, NY
Took 45 minutes to get our pizza, don’t come here because it takes so long I had to question the workers where our pizza was. Was not worth the wait at all unless you do enjoy waiting forever for an okay pizza and about 5 pick up orders got there pizzas before us.
We ordered a vegetarian pizza and the vegetables weren’t even cooked.
Place rating: 4
Fort Collins, CO
A fun, local place for good food and beer. My Son was very disappointed that there is no longer a juke box, but still likes the food.
Place rating: 2
Fort Collins, CO
I haven’t been here in a while so I was really surprised to find myself so disappointed. Had a lunch special, confused how pepperoni pizza can be dried out and greasy as well, couldn’t even finish the second slice. This was one of two places I really liked for NY pizza as I am a born and bred NYer myself. Will not go back anymore so I now have only one place left in this town to satisfy my craving. Today was like going to a Pizza Hut, which serves it purpose if you’ve had enough beer. Guess it is good they have beer here as well.
Another note, came in around 12:30. Don’t think the staff knows how to smile. Even kidded them and smiled and told them to smile as well. One guy turned around and walked away without responding. Classy. Other guy at least was polite but looked very bored with his job.
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
Might go 3 ½ stars, slightly better than average/good…not quite in very good category. Kind of pricey even with the $ 3 off for large pizza that I found online. Called & got good customer service over phone, girl said I didn’t need to print coupon (which, surprisingly in this day & age, some businesses still ask for!). Sometimes it’s worth paying extra to support local businesses, vs. Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, etc… Also very good/​nice customer service in restaurant when I came in to pick up pizzas, 4 year old son even said «she was nice» as we left. Would like to see more cheese, but liked thin crust & herbs on pizza (basil). Thought kids would complain about green flakes, byt didn’t…& I really liked it. Agree with most reviews regarding crust, crispy out, perfectly soft inside & pizza not greasy. Restaurant atmosphere nice, may eat there sometime!
Note to management or owner:
I read one review about rude service & closing early/​turning customers away… one of my BIGGEST pet peeves. If I ever get turned away or find a locked door prior to your posted closing time (other than giving an acceptable reason like death in the family), you will be losing more than one customer, I guarantee it!
Place rating: 5
Cheyenne, WY
I really loved the crust. Can’t wait to go again.
Place rating: 4
Fort Collins, CO
There is something to be said for simplicity, and Justine’s is the place for simple pizza. You will not have to choose what type of crust or sauce … just your toppings (or go with one of their «specials,» most of which are your good, basic, meaty combos with a little veg). Some may find this limiting, or not like the crust, or wish that topping x, y, or z were available — but sometimes I find when I’m hungry and just have a hankering for a good slice of pizza, I don’t really need to be faced with too many decisions. I recently ordered a Justine’s Special take-​out after a particularly long day at work, and it really hit the spot. Justine’s crust is a little thicker than I prefer, but is not overly doughy or bready. The sauce is well-​seasoned, and the pizza was just loaded with toppings … I enjoyed leftovers for both lunch and dinner the next couple of days. If you’re looking for a good, basic pizza executed well, Justine’s is your place.
Place rating: 5
Highlands Ranch, CO
LOVE that they offer sauerkraut as a topping. Excellent pizza. Not much more to say. Just try it.
Place rating: 4
Parker, CO
I had a personal cheez pie here which was tiny and my size and i loved it. I also loved their service, they have this very nice guy named andrew working there who knows what hes doing. I visit here everytime im in foco. :)
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
I’ve been here a couple of times and pizza-​wise, it’s average. So, food-​wise, it’s good, but there’s better pizza out there. It’s a fine place for a slice, but nothing really makes it stand out.
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
Decent pizza within walking distance to my condo. I’m not sure how I would classify it, kind of like really good frozen pizza. That sounds bad but it’s the best I can come up with and I think it’s pretty accurate. The pizza by the slice is more than 2 $ and it’s by no means a big slice. It had a nice atmostphere and the staff was cool.
Place rating: 3
Éclagnens, Switzerland
If you dig an 70/80’s vibe then you’ll love the wood benches, CD jukebox, and tasty pizza. Handmade dough and fresh toppings yield a crunchy, tasty pie. Beer available by the bottle.
Place rating: 4
Tacoma, WA
Hands down the best pizza place in town. You go in and place your order and though you may have to wait half an hour for the pizza to get made the ‘old fashioned’ way it is more than worth the wait. Surprisingly the pizza is not as greasy as you may typically associate with pizza and that is a huge plus and the veggies are fresh. They got a great tap for beer… I had New Belgium Sunflower and it was outstanding! Like I said there is a bit of a wait so families may get impatient but it is nothing like the small town pizzeria that is run by pot heads and you have to wait a hour for your good but greasy pizza to show up. They also have a juke box and there is plenty of songs to pick from, however if you go there during a busy time you can hardly hear anything that comes from the juke box and the volume is not very high so you may be wasting your dimes in that regard. Despite those minor issues there pizza is awesome and unlike any others in town.
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
The pizza was pretty good — or at least one half of it. The peperoni and beef side was a tasty, traditional pizza with good flavor. Their beef is seasoned well and has a nice Italian spice to it. The other side of shrimp and pineapple was not so good. I thought it would be an interesting and different combo that turned out to be way too salty. It was as if the canned shrimp had not been rinsed before going on before baking. We’re talking super salty.
While customer loyalty has helped Justine’s grow into a small Northern Colorado franchise, I think being loyal to the traditional pizza toppings is the best choice for a great pizza experience here.
Place rating: 5
Fort Collins, CO
This is definitely my favorite pizza place in town! It is a family ritual to have pizza every Sunday (Sunday-​Funday) and Justine’s is always my choice. They have the best crust– gooey and somehow crispy on the outside. Their sauce is amazing– tangy with just a hint of heat.
I cant say enough nice things about Justines! It is a must try for the true pizza lover!
Place rating: 4
Brighton, MA
This might be the best pizza I’ve ever had. Although I’ve never been into the restaurant, every time I visit my family in Fort Collins, my brother is destined to pick up a Justine’s pizza at least one night a week. This is a kid who lives on pizza. I always have to sample a sliver and before long slivers turn to slices because it is just THAT good. The crust is doughy and crunchy all at the same time, the sauce is flavorful but not overbearing, and the pepperoni is always perfectly crisp.
My only complaint is the variety of toppings. Although they have a few «special» toppings like jalapenos and shrimp, I’d like to see more veggie options like fresh tomatoes, spinach, broccoli and artichoke hearts. Those additions would bump Justine’s up to a full five stars!