Pappy’s Corner Pub

Went to Pappys the other night where my boyfriend and I eat the fish dinner there often and was very disappointed. Usually the fish is good and filling! The 3 TINY sticks we got weren’t what we expected and was quite a let down from our local pub.

Now that Pappy’s is owned by Jeff Milller (40 yr restauranteur in FTC) This is by far my favorite nieghborhood restaaurant and bar. The american food menu is great and the meals I have tried are fantastic. The happy hour specials are at a great price and the special daily promotions are awesome. This is my local restaurant! You should try it yourself.

We went to Pappy’s with my brother and his wife. They said they had only been here on Sundays. He said they have a killer steak special before the games start. So, we tried dinner here. The staff was super friendly and attentive. We all ordered something different. It all looked great. I had their fish and chips. I am weird and prefer cocktail sauce instead of tartar sauce. The waitress went to see if they had any. They didn’t, so she made some fresh. I thought that was going beyond for a customer. Everyone agreed our meals were fantastic. The atmosphere was nice also. We would definitely suggest this place.

We come every week to watch supercross and they always have a table ready for us and we get great service!

Had the Greek Salad. It had no dressing, was incredibly small, the feta cheese was dry, and the olives were so salty I could barely eat any of them. My girlfriend had the Chicken Caesar Salad. They grilled the romaine which was was cut in half, not washed properly (there was physically visible dirt and the stems were in place), and it was unappealing. The service however was quite friendly, which is why it gets two stars.

This has become my wife and I’s favorite local hangout. Its within a few blocks from our house, so that certainly helps. We really had not gone there much in the last few years as, frankly, we were not that impressed previously. This changed when a friend of ours was hired as a server there. Obviously, when we go in and she is working we get great service, but the overall service has been pretty good beyond her. The staff is pretty friendly and this place has a good, neighborhood feel. Its not a bar filled with College Students as so many places here in FoCo are. It has a large deck with nice views of the mountains to the west or the neighborhood to the east. We have not had a bad meal here yet. Mostly standard bar fare but all of it tasty. Live music on Fridays and Saturday’s, usually a solo acoustic player or small band. Its a great place to meet friends and have a few libations!

I wandered over here after having dinner across the street. It is an older people’s bar. But it was a good sized space, had a live band that was good and there was shuffle board.
I didn’t eat anything so can’t speak on the food, but the drinks were reasonably priced.
This is a good spot to do a chill evening with your significant other or get some friends to come with you and bring the party. The venue can take it.

Cool little «neighborhood bar». My wife and I go there every now and then since it’s close by and they have a lot of live music. It’s a good, comfortable place to hang out.

Awesome pub with a great variety of food and beverage. Underrated with the current 3 star rating!

Small neighborhood friendly pub, nothing really special. Beers are cheap though, that’s always a plus. Didn’t try any of the food here.

The happy hour bar crowd is a good judge of a popular place. If it’s getting crowded at 3pm chances are they have a decent amount of business the rest of the time. Pappy’s Corner Pub is a bar and restaurant that is clearly one of those places.
Atmosphere: The outside of this bar isn’t very inviting due to its office building appearance. There’s also confusion in an Irish pub looking too clean and this place is way too clean. A big part of an Irish pubs appeal is its rustic charm, and Pappy’s is somewhat lacking in this department. The restaurant and bar is large, open, bright, with a mix of booths and wooden tables (high-​top & regular-​sized) scattered across a white tile floor.
Service: The service was good but nothing over the top. There were several servers on duty taking care of their designated areas and two bartenders keeping the drinks flowing. All in all we had no complaints in the service department.
Drinks: A very average stocked bar with a few micros and domestics on tap.. With $ 2.50 domestic drafts, $ 3.50 micro drafts and $ 3 wells during happy hour, we had no complaints regardless of selection.
Food: The food is the redeeming quality for this pub with items like fish n chips, burgers, sandwiches and salads on the menu. Being served the typical pub food without the typical saturation of grease was refreshing. They have a nice selection of side items, but we have to recommend the fries — they were amazing.

It’s football season and they are bringing out the CHEESE CURDS. Yum!
Also this place is under new ownership. They have changed up a few things, new fries, new fish (cod now!) on the fish and chips.
Seems like the majority of the staff is the same (which is good.)

I have lived in the neighborhood for a few years now and the hubby and I finally made it to Pappy’s Corner Pup on a random Wednesday night. The dining area was clean, spacious, and welcoming. We had the option of dining in or out on the patio. The patio was huge, but the fact that it was 97 degrees outside, made us stay inside.
Our server was super nice and took great care of us. She checked in regularly keeping taps on us and our drinks. The food was just ok. Small menu, typical pup/​bar fare, nothing special. My Philly cheese-​steak was a bit on the dry side. My husband loved the fish and chips though!
I love that Pappy’s is in our neighborhood. The Beer specials and the patio may have us going back during the summer! Overall Pappy’s is very average.

«Meh» is the perfect explanation for Pappys. There is nothing special about Pappys that makes this restaurant stand out. The food is not great. I got the fish and chips and the fish was very dry. Their «homemade tarter sauce» does not taste homemade. They have a nice patio that is fun to sit out on and have a drink. Their drinks are pricey except during happy hour.
If you go just order drinks. The food is not great and it is not worth the price.

Nothing wrong with it, just boring. Food seemed a little high priced, but it’s your run-​of-​the-​mill strip mall bar & grill. It’s clean, the staff is nice but just do bare minimum. Not a very good beer selection. On the upside it has free shuffleboard. If I were 40 and looking for a quiet happy hour or Friday night I’d come here.

«How about Pappy’s» is a common question in my house. It’s down the street, convenient, tasty and friendly. Unfortunately it’s been a bit hit or miss recently.
Hits: Any waitress we’ve had here was amazing — Ah-​may-​ZING! Right on top of things like drinks, checking up on us, and speedy with the bill.
Misses: I’ve had a couple beers on tap that seemed to have a bit of a chemical or even soapy taste to them, so I’ve switched to water or bottled bevs. One waiter walked past us at least 10 times before I ended up asking him for a menu. But then sat in front of the POS for a while and we ended up just walking out.
I’m sure they schedule the best servers for Sunday and Mondays but being ignored on a Saturday night left a sour taste in my mouth — and this time it wasn’t the pint glass. I’ll be back only with a coupon and if our favorite waitresses are there. I’ll tip ‘em even bigger!

For the longest time I didn’t even know this place existed until I got a coupon in the mail for it. It is nestled in the corner of the shopping center at Horsetooth and Sheilds and you wouldn’t even know it was there if you were just driving by. It has taken me several months to make it over there, but with my buy one, get one free coupon in hand, I finally gave Pappy’s a try. After all, I am always looking for a easy going place to get some beer and grub that isn’t all the way in Old Town.
Now, Pappy’s is selling itself on being a neighborhood bar where you can come hang out, get some food and beer, and maybe watch a game on the the tv, all while being able to hang out with your friends. So maybe I shouldn’t have been surprised when we walked in and saw a «Please Seat Yourself Sign», but I was. I have eaten at several pub where you were still seated by a waitress. Never being there before, my husband and I wondered around for a bit trying to figure out the layout and the best place to sit. After making a complete trip around the restaurant and bar, all the while being closely followed by a waitress with menus, we finally settled on a booth in the bar area (we almost sat in the normal dinning area, but it looked like a large birthday crowd was about to gather there). My husband and I could see out of the corners of our eyes the waitress hand off the menus to another waitress acting annoyed that it took us so long to figure out where to sit only for us not to sit in her section. Sorry, but we had never been there before and we were told to seat ourselves! If you wanted us to sit in a certain place, you should have seated us yourself. The second waitress then came by and coldly gave us our menus with no «hi» or «how are you?» to greet us.
We were finally saved from the standoffish and bitchy waitresses by a third, much friendlier waiter that actually cared about the fact that we were there. I already knew I wanted to try the fish and chips, since I try them everywhere I go and kind of consider my self a connoisseur of fish and chips. My husband went with the pub club. Both of our dishes were alright. Overall, the food was just too greasy (both the fries and the fish). It was like the cook didn’t shake off the oil and let any of it blot off. Besides that the taste was fine, but nothing too special.
There were some positive points about the inside, though. It was crisp, clean, and brightly lit (but on the other hand, not very «pub» like). There was a really neat fish tank in the bar that I also enjoyed looking at while I ate (there was a HUGE puffer fish in it which was super rad). Also, even though they had sports playing on the tv’s with the sound overhead, it wasn’t so loud that my husband and I couldn’t have a normal conversation. And this was with us even sitting in the bar section! I always hate it when the sports are blasting and you can’t hear a single other thing.
At the end, the nice waiter brought us our bill and was even nice enough to show us that he factored in our coupon making the pub club free. He was also very pleasant when we asked for boxes and then when he dropped them off. Like I said before, he seemed to actually care that we were there, unlike the other waitresses.
So, I guess we had a pretty mixed experience: weird seating arrangements, some standoffish waitresses, okay food, but one very nice waiter. Will I go back? Probably, but only if I have another coupon.