Presto’s Pizza

Great friendly service! Pizza is reasonably priced, and tasty! Definitely recommend!

DONT EVER ORDER HERE ANYTHING! Save yourself money and your own mental health.
Was visiting a friend, whose house is down the street, literally 3 minutes of walking. We still ordered delivery because of bad weather and exhaustion after a day of exploring the city.
Ordered small house pizza with extra cheese. It was supposed to be something like $ 10.50. First of all, it was delivered almost 1.5 hour later. Walking distance and they still were so terribly late. The policy on their site is 60 minutes tops. We HAD TO CALL TWICE to make sure they got the address right and everything.
Second, customer service is unvelieavable! When called, they deal with you like you’re some 90 year old lady who keeps bothering for no apparent reason. They even hang up on you!
Third, THE ORDER WAS WRONG! It was a large, 18 inches pizza. The crust was soft like it was frozen first and then cooked. Cheese was practically tasting like plastic. There was a hair on top of everything. Gross!
Delivery guy didn’t apologise for being late. When I gave him $ 20 and was waiting for change, he closed the door in front of me, got in the car and drove away. I understand he was maybe thinking we ordered large pizza with extra, but even with that, $ 3 tips for being late and rude is inexcusable. HE CLOSED THE DOOR IN MY FACE. I consider this as stealing money.
We immediately called the place to complain and were told that now we have in store credit and will not get reimbursement. Apparently, the guy on the phone didn’t hear that it’s supposed to be a small pizza. Again, he hung up on me.
The bottom line is what a terrible place! We threw out most of the pizza because of the poor quality and because it was just too much for two people. Man of the phone was so rude– I don’t understand how they are still in business.
Never again! Maybe they have something that tastes well and/​or my experience was just an accident, but altogether it was a spoiled evening.

first time ordering today bc it was highly recommended. customer service is great called with minor complaint, manager handled it swiftly & quickly without any regrets!
ordered sausage & peppers pie, margarita pie, cheese pie, & garlic cheese bread
delicious ! if you like fresh brick oven tasting pizza order here :)
food came within 30min (even though website said 45 – 60 min)

starving one Sunday, my boyfriend and I stopped here to grab some grub.
I did love the quaint rustic Italian feel to the restaurant however, I wasn’t as impressed with the food. While I see the reviews are mostly positive I feel as is maybe I went on an off day for the place.
Upon entering, we were a few steps from the counter. To me the pizza did not look fresh so I only ordered a cheese slice. My boyfriend who was equally starving ordered a pepperoni and sausage slice. There was only one garlic knot that and I happen to have a soft spot in my heart for all garlic knots so we ordered the last one. I will say that it bothered me that there was only one out and there were none that were coming out. This goes back to my hope and thought that I visited on an off day.
Our stay was quick. We ate our pizza and left. i can’t say that I will be returning any time soon. However, for an emergency food stop, it wasn’t horrible just not that best I’ve had.

Prestos Pizza is a rarity these days. Good, hearty food and reasonable prices. Besides the personal pizzas which are made to your liking, they offer a great cheeseburger or a tuna sandwich for those who want something else. My favorite is the Margherita pizza or Grilled Chicken over Penne Pasta in a Vodka Sauce.
Simple desserts are available including Cheese Cake.
It’s a small comfortable neighborhood place. They offer delivery and I’ve never waited more than thirty minutes.

I mapquested this while passing through and asked for something not on the menu. It was pizza fries, which is french fries with mozzarella cheese and red gravy. Now it was the BEST I have ever tasted. And I have a lot of these in my time. Just for those that don’t know, anyone that can make you something NOT on the menu and make it the BEST you have ever had… now that’s a REAL good place.

First, I would like to point out that I’m visiting from California so I’m used to Round Table, California Pizza Kitchen and Papa Murphy’s. When I first walked in, I could tell that it would be a bit of a tight fit but we (party of 6) were able to fit comfortably and have room to move around. The man behind the counter whom I presume is the owner was friendly and helpful. He rolled the dough right in front of us and and the pizzas were cooked in a traditional brick oven. You can tell he takes pride in what he does and wants to assure that he meets every customers needs. I could tell however that he was getting a bit flustered because in addition to making our pizza, two more guests walked in and the phone was ringing off the hook (he was alone). About 15 minutes later, his delivery driver arrived at began to take over some of the duties which was nice to witness.
Now for the PIZZA: Exactly what I expected from East Coast Pizza. Huge. Greasy. Full of flavor.

Love their pizza and everything they make! So close to home and such great prices. Delivery or pickup invert quick!

Don’t order their delivery. Second time it took over an hour and a half from when the pizza was ordered to get 3 miles away. Unexcusable. Attitude of the delivery guy was — «enjoy your pizza», not «sorry I couldnt get here 30 minutes earlier…»

We love the bacon ranch rio and honey mustard chicken is our go to pizza. I also agree that the chicken wings are delicious, super crunchy. The pizza can be pricey but it’s specialty pies and the average slice is double the size of some other pizzerias. We are no longer in their delivery area but they make a special exception for us when they’re not too busy.
**We’ve branched out and tried other pies — also loving the Vodka pizza and chicken marsala pizza**

Gross, I ordered the chicken marsala with penne pasta. The wait was about 30 minutes. Finally, our food arrived and mine smelled weird. I have had chicken marsala dozens of times and its one of my favorite dish but I could not explain what it was that I was eating. The pasta, chicken and mushrooms were swimming in what I could assume was supposed to be marsala wine because it was bitter.

Think Bacon Ranch Rio Pizza sounds disgusting? Well, think again, buddy. Cause it’s «sent from the heavens”*
Also, the puttanesca, sicilian and baked ziti pizzas are also pretty darn good.
* me three hours before I wrote this review.

I ordered the chicken and broccoli pizza online through their website. While it took an hour and it didn’t include the plates, silverware, and red pepper flakes I requested, the pizza itself was good. Had a lot of broccoli and chicken, but the pizza crust was disappointing. Could simply be a victim of the time elapsed during the delivery period.

I was looking for a brick oven pizza restaurant and found this place. Yes, they have a pizza oven framed with bricks, but inside of the bricks there was a gas oven. Thank you for the trick.
Pizza was not terrible, but it’s below average as there are so many better pizza places in Fort Lee.

The dough is frozen, vegetables are frozen, and the meats & cheese are low quality. Everything is stored in the smelly basement downstairs. I don’t know how this place is still in business.

First and foremost the description of the pizza here is so misleading and borderline «false advertisement». This is NOT coal fired pizza or brick oven pizza. Major disappointment when that’s what you’re looking for. The pizza is decent but I wouldn’t dine here again when there are so many excellent pizzerias nearby.

I’m stating as it is. The worst fried calamari I’ve ever had. It’s rubbery and overcooked, the breading is stale, flavorless and flaccid. They probably didnt bother thawing the frozen squid before frying. The pizza dough is overworked and chewy with no air bubbles that creates a light and delicious thin crust. Non of the signature brick oven characteristics you should get. The tomato base is tasteless like it came straight out of the can. First and last time I’m ever going there.

This is a great neighborhood Pizza place. Between the flavor and texture, the pizza is second to non. My favorite pizzas are ‘Margherita’, ‘Lasagna’ and ‘Chicken Marsala’. I make a point to stop by Presto’s when I am in the area. Mina, the owner, is almost always there to greet and serve with a smile.
Bathroom is always clean too.

Pizza here is way over priced for the average quality food.
I ate here several times just because I’m in the neighborhood.
I would not recommend this place.

Ordered a pie of margherita & BBQ chicken. The pies were huge & were visually aesthetic (particularly the BBQ chicken). Both pies were decent, but nothing amazing. We also ordered some garlic knots which were large too & decent.
The staff is very friendly. The place is small and could barely fit our party of 5. The price, for what you get, isn’t bad at all.