Stevie’s New York Style Pizza

Such a great neighborhood pizza joint! My brother and few of my friends always talk about how good Stevie’s is. I was always so skeptical seeing how I had never heard of them, they are not a chain, and they just didn’t stick out to me in any special way. Well my husband and I decided to give it a try Super Bowl Sunday and we were pleasantly surprised. The prices were crazy good, the pizza was great pizza, your average delivery house crust, nice tangy sauce, stringy cheese, the sauces and mushrooms were flavorful and plenty, the wings were exactly what I like, big and crispy with just the right amount of medium sauce. I will most definitely be ordering from here again soon.

OMG! Why haven’t I been to Stevie’s before today?! I live in Arrowhead Ranch and grocery shop at Fry’s all the time.
It’s not like I didn’t know that Stevie’s wasn’t there!
But today was the day I decided I’m starving — and I need Italian! I’m going to Stevie’s!
I got there about 3:00 and Joe, the guy who «creates» the food, saw that I was using a walker, so he immediately came over and opened the door for me. What a gentleman!
It smelled like heaven inside, and while I was deciding what to eat I ordered an Appetizer Sampler — Yum!
I decided on a Calzone with 3 add-​ins: sausage, green pepper & onion. It came to the table an oooey, gooey cheesy, garlicy taste of heaven. It was so big, I only ate half of it.
Well, today was the first time I’ve eaten here, but it will definitely not be the last. There are so many menu offerings to try. I can’t wait to try a Stromboli, the cheese steak ‘sammich’, the stuffed shells, the eggplant parmigiana — — and of course the canoli!
I plan to become «a regular» at Stevie’s.
One more thing: Not only was Joe a very helpful, personable guy, but Beshe (I think that’s how she spells her name) was a very helpful server, too. She brought me boxes for my leftovers, and was very sweet.
I’m sorry, Steve, I didn’t mean to wait so long to come eat at your place — but I will be back!

I was here for the first time Friday and I was so impressed I even went back Saturday and Sunday. These guys know what there doing. Even at the busiest times they still care for there customers. Awesome job guys. Keep up the good work and food.

I, too, found myself in a situation similar to another poster on here. I am on a continual search for decent pizza in Phoenix. I’m a New York transplant who takes his pizza and bagels very seriously.
To paraphrase the other poster, «businesses that advertise authentic NY pizza make me suspicious». It’s a bold statement to make all the way out here in the desert but I gotta say, this place does a pretty good job at replicating the NYC slice. Also, and most importantly, they make zeppoles. God bless these guys for making those delicious balls of fried dough. God bless these guys!

I appreciate your apology and will remove this review. I know business and life can be stressful, but always remember to stay humble and loyal to your customers.

Our Holy Grail has always been to find decent pizza in AZ. We read a lot of places that say «New York Style» but it is far from it. Unilocal was a big help when we happened upon this listing, as it’s not in our neighborhood. The pictures sold us to give it a try.
The place was clean and had enough seats to comfortably sit for a «to go» type of pizza place. We noted to the staff that we were excited to try their pizza and come to find out that Joe is from our neck of the woods in New Jersey… so he knows what we’re looking for.
Our «usual» pie is pepperoni and meatball with mushrooms added to one half (my boyfriend’s half, not mine!). We were not disappointed. You could tell that it was good cheese and pepperoni because it was not swimming in oil. The crust was crispy and tasted good; you know it’s good if there is no crust left on the tray.
We will definitely be back; I want to try their Eggplant Rollatini (made in house) and my boyfriend wants to check out the chicken parm.
Tonight our search ended!!!

Excellent NY style pizza! Our go to pizza place! They also have the best cannolis out here!

Great calzones, check it out! The owner is really nice and offers quality service with quality food

Pizza was very greasy making the crust very soft. Service was average. Probably won’t be back. There is a really good pizza place just on the otherwise of 59^th ave.

Excellent pizza and salads. Love the garlic knots that come with the salads too. Always happy with our food. Best pizza in the area, and they deliver too!

AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME!
Pizza — AWESOME
Wings — Freaking Awesome
Greek Salad and Pasta — well, my dogs at those — didn’t like those very much.
Everything else is PERFECT! Even the driver was fantastic!
Great job you guys! Made me and my family really happy

Great food and the owner was very nice. We had extended family so we tried the pizza, calzone, spaghetti, rolls and salad. It was all very good. East Coast pizza. Big slices and the calzone was off the hook.

EXACTLY the flavor I wanted.
I have been yearning for real calzone for a couple of years now. Every one I’ve had has been so-​so; and then tonight, we tried Stevie’s.
Wow.
WOW.
Perfect mozzarella and ricotta balance, and the garlic/​olive oil combo made this a delight for the nose AND the tongue.
My husband had the sausage pizza, and he says it is «sausage pizza perfection.»
I’ll be honest; we’re pizza snobs. (Numerous dates in Manhattan will do that.) This place we’re definitely visiting again.

The owner obviously cares and the service shows it. The pie was A-​OK. While I was there someone showed up after ordering wrong and the owner took care f it. Pretty cool.

Just what I needed, located in a small strip mall near MWU. Reminds me of all the pizza shops back East, with the décor of typical NYC buildings, but most importantly, THE PIZZA! I was craving that crispy pizzeria type slices that are reminiscent of the East Coast and after a few places, I’ve finally found it here at Stevie’s!
Pizza slices were big, foldable, thin, and crispy with chewy/​soft crust — how an East coast slice should be. They honor MWU student discounts 10% off and gave me the lunch special 2 slices with 2 toppings and a drink for around $ 7, even around 8pm.
When I’m craving an east coast slice, I’ll be sure to be back!

Stevie’s is always very good! Best pizza on this side of town! Dough is super flavorful, sauce is great, quality cheese, ingredients are always fresh. I like the extras like fresh garlic on the garlic cheese bread. Everything we’ve had is always good! Never been disappointed.
Delivery times can be long but they always let you know when orderinf. Typically it’s about an hour but we’ve had shorter times than that. If you like New York style pizza do yourself a favor and try this place out!

I love the pizza here! After living in Arizona for the past few years, I’ve tried a variety of different places in addition to the standard chains of Pizza Hut/Domino’s and I have to say nothing really compares to Stevie’s! I love that they make a good, simple, delicious New York style pizza for an affordable price. They have the perfect balance of crust/​cheese/​sauce and every slice is delicious as the last. Everyone that I’ve had try their pizza has been converted into a fan. I’m definitely going to miss this pizza when I move back home. I hope they stay in business forever so I can come back every time I visit AZ!

One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a while, hands down! Found this place through Grubhub and I’m glad I did. Delivery took 45 minutes to hour but it was worth the wait. I ordered 2 pies, both at their «gigantic» size. One was just plain cheese and the other was a 1 topping which I got as pepperoni. The crust was amazing, it had that chew that most people look for in authentic NY pizza. The sauce was on point, not too much, just the right amount. And the cheese… the cheese was great. My wife and I both agree that we’ve found our pizza place since moving to Phoenix and it’s Stevie’s.

First timers tonight, food was absolutely fresh and delicious. Got the broccoli and chicken pasta, plus sausage and parmagian sandwich. Pasta came with salad and knots. Dressing for salad tasted pretty fresh. Can’t believe we didn’t come here long time ago :-)
Service was great too. Fast and courteous. Thank you!

Been here a few times before but after my last experience, this will probably be my go to pizza place from now on! Conveniently located across from Midwestern university, the hubby and I decided to order some appetizers and grab some slices. I love that they let you order cheese pizza by the slice and pick additional toppings. They even pop it back in the oven for you to get the cheese all gooey again, yum. We called in our order about 45 minutes to closing and the person on the phone (owner?) said they only had one slice left. We contemplated ordering a whole pizza but the owner said he didn’t mind baking a few more slices for us since it’d be less costly for us. When we got there he ended up giving us the whole pizza since it was so close to closing time and he would probably just end up tossing the rest! Talk about awesome customer service!
As for the pizza itself, we got the meatball, mushroom, onion and garlic toppings. We don’t eat pork so its nice to have another meat option on the menu since the meatballs are made of beef. The meatballs are thinly sliced and added to the pizza, kind of like gyro meat. We ordered the garlic knots and appetizer sampler with the mozzarella sticks, fried zucchini, and mushrooms. Loved the mozzarella sticks and zucchini, the batter it really light and not too oily. Didn’t care for the mushrooms, they tasted like they were previously canned. The garlic knots weren’t bad but they were more like buns and weren’t garlicky enough for us haha. Appies came with ranch and marinara.
Good prices and portions, excellent customer service. We’ll be back!