Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

This was my first trip to Anthony’s. A couple of work peeps and I decided to try it at lunch on a beautiful December day. We pre-​ordered the pizza before we left work to maximize the time we had for our lunchbreak. That was a great idea because it was ready when we got there! We sat outside and the server delivered one of the largest pizza’s I’ve ever seen. The crust… oh my… it was SO delicious! My friends aren’t exactly adventurous in their pizza toppings and only allowed us to have mushrooms and artichoke’s but that really was enough. There were plenty of pieces of our topping choices and the pizza, did I mention it was huge? It was yummy and we will be back soon!

We ordered our pizza at 8 pm, called at 9 and they said they lost our order and it would be right out. Called at 10 and they said the driver was out to deliver the pizza. 11 now and no answer and no pizza. Wish we would have known they weren’t coming so we could have made other plans for dinner.

I love this place, it is my favorite pizza along with the Marquis theatre pizza in denver.

Wish I could rate them as zero stars … Just stay away and chose a pizza place like Ricci’s

It been to this location before and was ok with it. This last experience was bad. Lunch rush, I get it but it’s pizza slices and I didn’t ask for anything special. People who came after us were getting their food before us. Did I get pushed back because I asked for food to go? No reason my slice with pepperoni should have come after anyone else’s. Just really bummed by my experience and will prob not go back to this location.

I was initially put off by the fact that this is a chain, but after someone suggesting it I bit the bullet and got a plain pie well done. So glad I did as this is legit NY pizza. The prices are slightly higher than what I would expect, but so glad the search for good NY style pizza is over.
They keep the pizza warm by actually laying it on top of the pizza oven. I immediately stop going anywhere that places pizza for pickup off to the side. =)

Very Good NY Style Pizza and Garlic Bread with cheese! Very Friendly and Prompt Delivery.

They won me back today (truth be told, we went back awhile ago since the pizza is so good). I went to order online at 11am this morning and the automatic quote online was 1:45; I figured it’s probably really busy on the Friday before Halloween. I called hoping for a better time frame, but knowing I might need to call another place. When I called, they quoted 12:30−12:45 (not terrible considering). The three pizzas got here around 11:45am. My coworkers were so happy and the pizzas were, as always, delicious.

What really makes my day is when an establishment can make you feel like you have always been a part of the business.
It’s been a long time since I have visited this location since I moved out of the area. After flubbing on a recipe at home, we decided to order pizza on short notice. I ordered three pepperoni slices, one sausage slice, one cheese slice, and one cheese with pepper & onion slice. Since its made to order, of course, there’s a bit of a wait but nothing too crazy so I busied myself with browsing through the Westword while they prepared my order.
Once I got my order, the guy let me know that the three peps were together in one box. I walked out to the truck, got in, & opened the top box to check the pizza and realized I did not have the sausage sliced I ordered. I loaded the boxes up and went back in.
The manager (I need to get his name) happened to be at the register and saw me coming so he asked what was messed up as I approached. I let him know that the sausage slice was not included to which he replied, «the sausage is not in here so give her two». I took a sit to wait for the slices and the manager called my name. When I got to the counter, he asked if I wanted a salad, also, since they had too many or made one by mistake for a previous order and, thus, had one to give away.
As I walked out with seven pizza slices & salad, the manager called me by name and wished me well. For me, that was a great end to a long day.
To top it all off, when I got home and bit into the cheese pizza with fresh onions & peppers atop the slice, I almost fell on my kitchen floor from my knees buckling after that flavor & texture shock. Oh… My…Universe!!! The pizza was so hot & melty and the veggies were so fresh & crisp.
Anthony’s continues to get it right. I’m so glad it’s right up the street.
Back to enjoying my pizza.
Thanks, Anthony’s!!!

This place used to be decent. But our last experience left us with an impression to not come to this location again. The service here was bad at best, while we were there, not only did they mess up our order and they messed up three other people’s orders. Granted, it looked like they were training a new person but the girl who seem to be the manager wasn’t managing anything.

Literally the WORST customer service I have ever encountered from ANY kind of business. Took almost 2 hours to get our pizza, which was cold (pretty sure I wouldn’t be impressed if it was warm either). Manager (Brandon) was incredibly rude and conveniently had no way to ever-​at-​all get in touch with the owner. Convenient. This is after a young girl argued with me about the time I made my order (uhhh, cell phone history doesn’t lie!), lied about being the manager herself and hung up on me. He didn’t seem to mind that. Also, the app sucks. Can’t believe I just had this experience. Never been so mad as to write a review. Stay away!

I don’t know how this place gets bad reviews.
This place is awesome. One of the best places in denver to get
a real NY style slice or pie !

Best thin crust pizzas. Made hot n yummy. We tried small pizza with two veggie toppings, it was good n filling for two of us.

Decent thin crust pizza. Salad was fresh and satisfactory. Good value: small salad and a slice for about 8 bucks.

I’ve ordered delivery twice, and both times have been horrible.
The first time I tried ordering online, since it seems like it would be a lot simpler, apparently not. I had to wait almost an hour and a half for someone to call me and tell me my order was never prepared.
The second time I called to place a delivery, I got a call an hour later that there was a «problem with my order» and I had to wait another 20 min to get my food.
I’m starting to wonder if they even start making your pizza when you first order it.
It’s a bummer because I love Anthony’s pizza :(
But this location sucks!

pizza slice was huge, but too much crust for my taste! it was hot and fresh, took a little time to prepare, but the freshness warranted that. Staff was very friendly. Decently priced, puts it about equal as a lunch stop as grabbing a $ 5 footlong for me. I finished my 2 slices and could have definitely had room for some more.

We never have an issues with these guys and their pizza is bomb! Get the cheesy garlic bread, get a large pepperoni or meatball and tip the dudes!
Delivery was on time too and dinning in isn’t a bad idea either.

If you’re hungry, Anthony’s Pizza should be on your radar. Their slices are traditional New York sized and pliable. Definitely delicious. I usually stick with cheese or pepperoni to keep it simple.

Absolutely awful place. Waited for 5+ actual minutes until an employee came up from the back. Employee was mostly nice, but the restaurant is so filthy and disgusting I couldn’t bring myself to eat. There were fly’s and insects all over the toppings and in the sauce bucket, trash everywhere, and everything was sticky, oily and not cleaned. I could see several health code violations from the dining area.
I am not the sensitive type either, it wasn’t just a little dirty… it was gross.

These slices are HUGE!
Came a few weekends ago and got the slice, salad, and drink combo. The salad was surprisingly very good! Usually when ingredients of a salad are so fresh I don’t even use dressing. Well, here at Anthony’s I didn’t touch the dressing. The lettuce, vegetables, and cheese were all super fresh and tasty! This was really unexpected considering what a pizza place typically offers for salads.
The slice of cheese was gigantic! For that alone I’ll be back, lol. They’ve got TVs in this place as well. I recommend this place for anyone. It’s small though so might not be best for large groups.