Benny Sorrentino’s

Harrisonburg, United States

4.3

Open now

18 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 540-432-6400
Website:
www.bennysva.com
Address:
64 S Mason St, Harrisonburg, VA, 22801
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1 miISAT Bus Shelter
1 miPhys/Chem Bus Stop
1.2 miFestival bus stop
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Hipster
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
No
Dogs Allowed
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:30 am – 11:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Harrisonburg) 8:51 PM Wednesday, July 2, 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:30 am – 11:00 pm
Tuesday 10:30 am – 11:00 pm
Wednesday 10:30 am – 11:00 pm
Thursday 10:30 am – 11:00 pm
Friday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Saturday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Sunday 10:30 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Located downtown Harrisonburg, we offer ready to serve, over-​sized slices of New York-​style pizza served late-​night. Convenient Parking and Location, come by and check out our rotating monthly specials!

«Best Pizza in Harrisonburg» — 2015 JMU Breeze

Related places

Explore similar places:
1
mi
Pizza Hut
78 S Carlton St
1
mi
Papa John’s Pizza
702 E Market St
1
mi
Little Caesars Pizza
52 S Carlton St
1
mi
The Golden Pony
181 N Main St
1
mi
Pizza Hut
373 N Mason St
1
mi
Ciro’s Lasagna House
778 E Market St

Vicinity

Near this location:
80
ft
Shenandoah Joe
64 S Mason St Ste 100
110
ft
Arepera Las Chamas
50 S Mason St
110
ft
Rocktown Bicycles
50 S Mason St
190
ft
Urban Exchange
238 E Water St
190
ft
Wharton Aldhizer & Weaver
100 S Mason St
200
ft
The Sole Source
237 E Market St

18 reviews of Benny Sorrentino’s

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Coatesville, PA
From Philadelphia Pennsylvania area and I must say this is some of the best pizza I’ve had and a cool ideal will be coming back when I’m in the area
Place rating: 4
Tyngsboro, MA
Excellent pizza and very polite staff. Had an hour wait for a large pepperoni ($ 35), but it was delicious and enormous. One slice is the size of a small pizza.
Place rating: 3
Luray, VA
pizza was just ok. the toppings were good but there’s something about the crust that I didn’t like. you definitely get plenty for your $ 5 though. finished mine in 2 sittings. for all the hype though I was expecting it to taste a little better.
Place rating: 4
LOTHIAN, MD
Really deserves 4.5 stars. Came here based on prior reviews and was not disappointed. Giant slices of pizza in the NYC style, fairly priced, with excellent taste. The topnotch ingredients (great cheese) make all the difference… only thing keeping it from earning 5 stars is that it’s so hard to overcome not having the NYC water to enhance the crust.
Place rating: 5
Broadway, VA
Pizza is amazing and it’s huge! I love coming here especially when I’m on a budget :) will continue coming here for a long time
Place rating: 4
Fairfax, VA
Really good pizza! I’m not sure why people say it’s expensive for one slice because it’s one HUGE slice. They have monthly specials and this month they have the Mac n cheese and buffalo chicken.
I got the buffalo chicken and it was so delicious. The buffalo sauce was fantastic. My friend got the Mac n cheese and she really enjoyed it.
The one thing I would say is there wasn’t enough of the ingredients on top and it could use some cleaning on the tables. Other than that, who doesn’t love giant slices of pizzas?!
Place rating: 4
Cincinnati, OH
Pizza as big as your head? I’m in. Once piece needs two paper plates– and it’s amazing. Only a few options but they do it right and that’s what counts!
Add Benny’s to the list of reasons I want to move to H’burg!
Place rating: 5
Elkton, VA
Great fresh tasting pizza that’s sure to fill you up, The pizzas cover your whole plate!
Place rating: 4
Panama City, FL
The pizza’s are huge! Probably 3 feet in diameter. They are thin crust, so you can eat one slice, but that’s about it. The pizza’s good, but a little bit overpriced in my opinion: $ 5 a slice. I would definitely come again, but for the novelty of the place, not necessarily because of the price or taste of the pizza, not that it isn’t good. The ambiance of the place is pretty cool too. Very urban.
Place rating: 5
Harrisonburg, VA
Pizza is delicious but it’s simply too big, could not fit the box through my door at home, and had to eat outside in the pouring rain. 10⁄10 would get rained on again. Also, drink selection on fleek
Place rating: 5
Ashburn, VA
Amazing. Literally. Cheap but oh my goodness… I went back with my friends 2 or 3 times. I will keep coming back. It’s great and fun.
Place rating: 4
Annandale, VA
I thought the pizza tasted great. Although the slice is pretty big, there’s not much height to it. One slice is satisfactory and two will be filling.
Place rating: 4
Keezletown, VA
The huge pizza would be great for parties. Our children really got a kick out of the size of their slice. The décor is interesting we liked it. The taste of pizza wasn’t anything to write home about, but the novelty of the size was worth going for. We will go back occasionally.
Place rating: 4
Harrisonburg, VA
Oh my freakin’ god that’s good pizza. I mean it’s a basic pizza that has been super-​sized.
if you want arugula and sprouts from China or fresh goats milk cheese that was milked by a Ukrainian farmer named Ivan Imistoly, on the fjords of Denmark… in August… at 3p.m. then go to Bella Luna or one of the other foo foo pizza places if you are hungry and want a decent slice from a decent place at a decent price then go to the Big B (Benny’s)
I give it 4 stars because if you are going to have a slice that big you should cut your sausage length wise for better coverage… other than that, Great Pizza!
Place rating: 3
Charlottesville, VA
The pizza is sooooo good and so cheap. Some of the specials are super big hits and some of them (like broccoli cheddar) are total misses. It sucks that theres no veggie stable special because they pretty much always have pepperoni.
I also don’t like that their method of to-​go slices is sticking their arms up a paper bag and flattening it out when the gloves only go up to their wrists. I don’t need arm hair on my pizza.
They also only have about 3 parking spaces.
Place rating: 5
Harrisonburg, VA
I heard lots of good things about Benny’s over the past couple of months but tried it for the first time last night when some friends brought some over. I couldn’t stop eating it. Firstly, they are huge and a feast for the eyes. While I would have liked a little more sausage as topping, first glance was love. The crust was super thin, chewy, and uniform… Very difficult to do for a pizza that big. I gotta stop by sometime and see how they do it. The cheeses were spot on, flavorful and stringy. Over all they make a freakin huge delicious pie that you just gotta try. I think I’m going to go eat some leftovers right now!
Place rating: 5
Mount Sidney, VA
The pizza is great! For the price you get a 14″ slice and a 28″ round pizza. Great pizza.
Place rating: 5
Harrisonburg, VA
Really delicious gigantic slices of foldable, freshly baked pizza. $ 4 for a 14″ slice of cheese pizza that will fill you up for real. Worth the wait if there’s a line. Friendly staff, good ingredients, great décor. Hope this place is here to stay.