Reagan’s Finger Lakes Canoe & Kayak Livery

I rented a paddle b board from these folks over the summer. They are by far the cheapest place to rent them in the finger lakes. There are not many other options but the alternatives are incredibly expensive, so much so you would almost be better off just buying one!
They have nice entry level boards in good shape. And if you are renting them long enough they will drop them off and pick them up. Easy to get to on the west side of Seneca Lake.
Make sure to reserve it in advance though since they rent them out quickly in peak times.

Great with correspondence and pricing. I didn’t use this business only because the location wasn’t near my hotel and where on the lake I was specifically going. However upon emailing asking questions about prices and location Doug immediately emailed me back and was very clear, informative and kind. I would definitely recommend this boat rental business.

The lady who runs this place is so sour, she must have take the Soviet Style Customer Service 200 hour training course. Her attitude was as uncongenial as Dick Cheney with a bad case of hemorrhoids. We were about to plop down $ 140 for two standup paddle boards, one double canoe, and one single kayak; however, her noxious demeanour was so off-​putting that we packed up and went to another kayak rental facility. Do not patronise this horrid establishment. Negative stars.

Very easily rented 2 kayaks, they were delivered before we got to our rental. Picked up when we asked them to be. They were very easy to work with and the kayaks were in great shape

Very easy rentals. Their price was 25 $ for a single person kayak and 35 $ for a tandem, for a whole day. (You have to finish by 7:30ish, though. We arrived later, so we only ended up borrowing boats for 2.5 hours, but it was enough for us.) They drove down to a public dock, and we followed them in our car. When we were done, we drove the life jackets and paddles back up, leaving the kayaks at the dock.

Easy to set up rental of paddle boards. Delivery was on time and included all necessary condition. Amazingly fun time using the paddle boards. Pick up after time was easy and Diane was so helpful. We will def be using again next year. Thank you again!!!

Very friendly laid back people. Accommodating and reasonable. I recommend Doug and Diane highly. If you are making it to the Finger Lakes time on the lake in a kayak, canoe or Stand Up Paddle Board is required. Call these guys!

Reagan’s delivered right on time as promised. Equipment in excellent shape. Friendly and courteous. Affordable fun. We rented 2 tandem Old Town kayaks on Keuka. Since they deliver all over there’s no pressure to have them back at a specific time. Highly recommended!
–Scott, Skaneateles, NY

Love it! For a very decent price, my boyfriend and I rented a canoe for the afternoon to take out on Seneca Lake. We called ahead to check availability and within an hour were on the lake. I drive a Honda Fit (obviously not capable of hauling a canoe), so the owner loaded up the canoe on their pick-​up and led us to a public launch just up the road. When we were done, we called them and they came back to the launch to pick the canoe back up. Super easy and convenient!

Was really excited to find Reagan’s a few months before my vacation on canandaigua for renting stand up paddle boards. The guy on the phone reserved me three boards and said they could deliver even though I was 50 short of their delivery minimum, no problem. The day before my rental, they called to tell me they only had two, one was broken and did not try to offer any substitute. I asked to call her back in a bit so we could try and find a third elsewhere. I called back an hour later and the woman told me «I didn’t hear from you so I rented them to someone else, I’m not going to turn down business.» She also said «you didn’t meet our delivery minimum anyway», which again, had already been addressed.
If Reagan’s is so concerned about losing business in a one hour window, perhaps they should change to a procedure of taking deposits for reservations, which I would be more than willing to do if it would mean they actually honor my reservation.
Customer service was a zero.

We were vacationing by east side of Seneca lake on a wimp and wanted to go kayaking. The only kayak rental on Watkins Glenn was by the marina. They charge by the hour ($ 40 if I remember correctly) and does not allow boats to be transported to other lake. Since the owner was strict and unable to accommodate our needs we decided to look for something else.
With help from visitor center we found Reagna’s and drove to the west of Seneca Lake on Rte 14. The location was easy to find with large signs and indicators. When we arrived, there are numerous kayaks, canoes and paddleboards all neatly stacked on the shelves in the spacious backyard /​garage area. The place appears clean, tidy and organized. They are fully stocked with additional life jackets and paddles. The person running the business appeared laid back and friendly. It was in early afternoon, and we were charged $ 35 for a double kayak for the rest of the day, with the possibility of returning the kayak next morning if we miss the 5pm cutoff time. The rental includes life vests, paddles, and the boat. We were asked which type of the paddle we preferred, and upcoming considering the ease of transportation we were given the portable paddles, which were easily assembled and taken apart. We were allowed to transport the kayak to our destination of the Lake Lamoka. The guy helped us load the kayak on our SUV and supplied with additional rope fixture to ensure safe transport.
They also deliver your rentals to your cottage if you call ahead. They usually collect all the rental at 5pm, but allow them to be returned onsite if you can’t make the 5pm.
What I like about Reagan’s so much is the laid back attitude, ease of rental, and the professional courtesy they extended to customers about safety and convenience. The price certainly add the icing to the cake. It is simply a pleasure not to pay an arm and a leg for a leisure kayaking trip on the lake. The double kayak we rented was good and in working condition; every thing worked and was adjustable. I know I’d definitely rent from Reagan’s again, and I highly recommend it.