Baking My Heart Out

Huntington, United States

5

9 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-896-3754
Website:
www.bakingmyheartout.com
Address:
Huntington, NY 11743
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1.8 miHuntington
2.4 miGreenlawn
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Bike Parking
No

Today

Today –
Local time (Huntington) 10:52 AM Wednesday, June 25, 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Description

Specialties

Baking My Heart Out specializes in designing custom made cakes and cupcakes for any occasion. From birthdays, baby showers, sweet sixteens, bridal showers and weddings, Baking My Heart Out will exceed your expectations. Baking My Heart Out is devoted to providing its customers with fresh and amazing looking cakes. These creatively fun & elegant cakes will taste heavenly.

Each cake I bake is unique and I put my heart into each design providing my clients with something special for whatever the occasion. Whether your guests are asking for a second slice or taking pictures of your custom designed cake, I am confident it will be a hit!

Meet the Business Owner

Agata S.

Business Owner

My love for baking began long time ago in my home in a small village in eastern Poland. Watching my mom and grandma bustle around the kitchen, smelling fresh baked cookies, pies and homemade donuts definitely pointed me into the right direction. For years I was helping my mom preparing all the desserts for each holiday. But it wasn’t only on holidays when she treated us with something delicious. My brothers and I were lucky kids growing up because there was always something yummy baking in the oven. We were waiting impatiently to try cookies while they were still warm. My house was filled with mouth watering aromas of goodies every Sunday!

Where else can you get such a great baking lessons if not from your mother? Not only was she a teacher at school, but she had taught me many things at our home as well. Being a good student definitely paid off. Today I have the love for baking as my mom has had for years. I use her recipes, techniques and baking tips almost every day.

Related places

You might also like:
1
ft
La Pirata Kitchen
1
mi
Alfredo’s Bakery
90 New York Ave
1
mi
Duck Island Bread Company
201 E Main St Ste C
1.2
mi
Cupcake Gourmet
46-I Gerard St
1.2
mi
Crumbs Bake Shop
11 Wall St
1.2
mi
Fiorello Dolce
57 Wall St

Vicinity

Near this location:
1
ft
Stroller Strides
Heckscher Park and the Huntington Jewish Ctr
1
ft
Modern Divinities & Rabbi Brian
1
ft
Jane K Dye, RN
Health Coach at Precedo Inc
1
ft
Hip-Mama Hula Hoops
1
ft
Whitehall Home Improvements
1
ft
Lori Avra
Coldwell Banker 1206 E Jericho Turnpike

9 reviews of Baking My Heart Out

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Paramus, NJ
Agata is as sweet as can be and very accommodating. Her cake designs are phenomenal and taste delicious!
Place rating: 5
North Babylon, NY
I ordered a cake from Agata for my sister in law baby shower and it was a hit. The cake was not only beautiful but tasted yummy as well. The mommy to be loved it and was in tears. Thanks so much Agata, you are now my go to baker.
Place rating: 5
Northport, NY
I have had the pleasure of knowing some of the world’s best pastry chefs and bakers, and the pleasure of eating their food too. But when it comes to custom cakes, NO ONE is better than Agata! She is phenomenal! Not only does she make the most creative and artistic looking cakes, they are also UNBELIEVABLY delicious.
So far my experience with Agata is that she can make any cake you want. I first came across her work after doing a Google search looking for someone who could bake me a Ferrero Rocher cake. I wanted it to be exactly like the chocolate, with the Nutella center and the crunchy wafer layer. NO BAKER I visited in person was able to do that. When I contacted Agata I expected her to say no too since so many people had. But I was positively surprised when she said she could do it. And not only did she do it, she did it PERFECTLY! Ever since then she has been my go-​to person for cakes. And I have recommended her to everyone I know and they all love her! She is very affordable too!!!
I feel so lucky to have found her. She even delivers the cake to our home because we are in Northport, just a few minutes away from Huntington Village where she is located.
So if you need a cake, any cake, no matter how complex in shape, size, flavor or theme, Agata is your girl! Baking My Heart Out is by far the best cake bakery I have ever seen, even in Paris, Manhattan, and every famous city’s bakery in between.
Place rating: 5
JAMAICA, NY
I can’t say enough about Agata and her wonderful cakes! She recently created the most amazing cake for my sisters 30th surprise party which was a Great Gatsby theme. Her cake was this gorgeous gold, black and white confection with sparkles and bling! The fondant was so seamlessly done, I couldn’t even tell where it began!
When you get such a BEAUTY of a cake, you rarely expect it to taste as good as it looks… well you’d be wrong! My entire (very Italian) family was RAVING about the cannoli cake! (I know, cannoli, shocking) But it was legiteimately one of the MOST delicious cakes I’ve ever had.
If you need something tasty and beautiful for your next party– go to Agata! She’s amazing and we’ll definitely be back for more!
Thanks again Agata– you really made my sisters birthday a true hit!
Place rating: 5
Westbury, NY
Another celebration, another one of Agata’s creations. Not only are her cakes works of art, but they are absolutely delicious. Completely defies the idea that a cake either looks good or tastes good. She has made cakes for some milestone birthdays in my family and cupcakes as well. Agata does an amazing job of bringing your cake idea to life. Can’t say enough, eat one of her creations and see for yourself.
Place rating: 5
Roslyn, NY
Agata’s creations are not only a work of art, but they are also yummy. She has made three cakes for my children for their bday parties and one is lovelier and yummier than the next. Cannot imagine a bday party without her beautiful creations:)
Thank you
Place rating: 5
Huntington, NY
Best damn cakes and cupcakes on Long Island period.
Beautiful and fun looking cakes that are moist and delicious.
I’ve eaten several of their cakes and haven’t found a bakery anywhere that matches their favors.
Professional service, and cake styles you will never forget.
Place rating: 5
Flushing, NY
I ordered a cake for my cousin’s bridal shower and it was absolutely beautiful. All the women at the bridal shower loved the sugar dress that was on the cake which made it very girly. I have also ordered cupcakes from Agata. I love that she is able to incorporate my idea into a design that turns out to be beautiful and better than I expected.
Place rating: 5
BAYSIDE, NY
Agata makes the most beautiful and best tasting cakes in all of Long Island. She designed a cake for my friends wedding shower that was so amazing. The orchids she made looked so real people didn’t think they were edible. The cake was amazing and she made each tier a different flavor for the brides favorite cakes. I’ve also had her decorated cookies and they were so beautiful I didn’t want to eat them but they tasted so good.