Romito’s Pizza West

I ordered pizza here for my Super Bowl party a day before the party. I went to pick it up and my pizza wasn’t even ready. I told them the day before that I’ll pick the pizza up at 6pm. I got to romitos place 10 minutes before 6p and I have to wait for almost half an hour for the pizza that I ordered a day before the super bowl! The bad part about my pizza is wasn’t cook right, the middle is uncooked! We ended up slicing it individually and put it back in «our» oven for half an hour! So disappointed and they rated this place 4 star? What a joke! Sorry but I’m not happy about the wait and uncooked pizza!

Went in looking for a grinder, no luck. Was going to order a sub, but cook suggested they were known for pizza. Ordered 3 item, result was awesome. Great crust and sauce, hand-​cut green peppers, cheese just right. NOT your chain store; pizza done very well. You won’t be disappointed.

I asked the guy over the phone about the pizza and the food he said it’s great I ordered i end up ordering a pizza it was a disgusting the whole pizza was under cooked, the wings were under cooked and very expensive do not recommend this place at all

I come to Independence for business every few months. I have tried several local pizza joints and have been unimpressed. Being from Chicago, I may be a bit picky when it comes to pizza. However, this place has the best pizza in town for sure. It is one of the best pizzas I have had outside of Chicago, even beating pizza places in NY. The person who answered the phone reminded me of Eor from Whinnie the Pooh but was polite. You can only order hand tossed but is tasty. The delivery was quick. This place is a must!

The pizza was delicious. We ordered double cheese, pepperoni and half mushrooms and half green olives. I enjoyed every bite. We ordered garlic cheese bread sticks. They came with real cheese and a meat dipping sauce. Very tasty! The meat sauce was a pasta sauce and we were eating it plain it was sooooo good.

Last night in Cleveland and needed something quick and easy without having to leave the hotel. Ordered large pizza with half pepperoni. Sauce and toppings were delicious, but the crust was a little too pillowy for my taste. Still great price and flavor for what I ordered. Next time I’m in Cleveland I’ll order from them again.

This by far was one of the worst pizzas we have ever had! Crust was very thick (sheet pizza) and doughy, not done. Hardly any sauce. We got part of the pan with pepperoni and it dripped off on our hands with grease.
We were staying at a local hotel for a baseball tournament and got the menu from the front desk.
Needless to say, we would never order from them again.

This place is hands down the best pizza in the Cleveland area. The owners are super friendly and the service is quick.

Good food, great variety, quick and good value. Pizza is great fresh or cold the next morning.

The best pizza that I have had in the Cleveland area. Not cheap BUT so worth it Freshest ingredients and lots of them. Great crust, especially when crispy. Delicious when hot and the next day after a night in the frig — — to die for.
Bob, N. Royalton

The great thing? The Pizza. The worst? Customer service. Immediate Blacklist. Wow…

love love this place! Great PIZZA! I even love the crust! I get the small for lunch.
The people are friendly the service is fast! I love the old cash register it adds to the place. A must try if you love pizza and even if you don’t!

Romito’s is my family’s go-​to place for party pizza. It’s not my favorite pizza, but it’s quick, convenient, and crowd-​pleasing. We’ve always had good service there, too.
I’ve had their pizza many, many times. In general the crust is thick and doughy (which may or may not be your thing), and there is a lot of cheese. I wouldn’t go so far as to say they’re stingy with the toppings, but I wouldn’t say they’re generous either. They use canned mushrooms, not fresh. I have not been impressed with their salads (mostly iceberg with a few toppings sprinkled in), but their homemade Italian dressing is very good.
They do have coupons on their website and in the local circulars, so look out for those before you go.

This is pretty good pizza, but it is not what I really like. I have eaten the pizza here several times. The crust is a little on the soft side, bordering on soggy. I think they use provel cheese, which is stringy and chewy. Personally, I prefer cheese with more flavor, rather than a mound of cheese.

Best pizza in the area — hands down! Although I do like the sheet pizzas better then the smaller — something about the crust!
Great service and on time deliveries! My family has ordered pizza here for at least 20 years!

Ok I wanted to give this a 2.5 but since there was no .5, I rounded down. What is everyone raving about? This is average AT BEST. Pizza Hut is way better to give you a culinary yardstick and we were buzzed! so my old college roommate’s cooking would have tasted like Wolfgang Puck. Very average, and the wings are AWFUL. Plain wings with hardly any sauce coating them and no blue cheese, carrots or celery.

Very good pizza. we were on our way back to Chicago from the OBX. We stayed over in Independence. Chicago has great pizza everywhere. We didn’t expect much, but were pleasantly
suprised. We ordered two full sheets. Pizza was very good. Bakery style crust not salty at all and great service from the people there.

Pizza is my favorite cheat-​day food, so I have sampled my fair share of pies. The only pizza that rivals Romitos is Giardonos in Chicago. Everything that goes into a pizza at Romitos is made from scratch in-​house. They hand-​shred their cheese off the block, make the sauce, cook the bacon, etc. The shop is locally owned as well, by a hard-​working independence family with four young children. The mouth-​watering, heavily-​topped pizza is baked fresh-​to-​order and will certainly fill your belly without draining your wallet. Romitos is one of the best parts about living in Independence!

We’ve lived now in various cities (Cleveland, Virginia Beach, Atlanta, New England) and travel quite a bit. Romito’s is by far our favorite pizza. The dough is perfect. The topping are superb. We would order sheets (insanely cheap) when we had friends and family over. Odd how I would always «accidentally» overorder which meant we had Romito’s for days after.
One of the best tests for the perfect pizza is how it tastes the second day. And Romito’s not only has the best day-​of pizza, but the reheat beats all other pizzas as well.
Can’t wait to be back in Cleveland to take the kids.

First off– my food gets 3-​stars (Pepperoni Lunch Slice was small and mediocre. If you want more people to go there for Slices they need to be gigantic and loaded & way too greasy Medium cheese to-go)-However I know I ordered the wrong thing. This is your Local Pizza Parlor staple, family owned and you can feel the love. The Italian dishes looked great. Grab a sheet pizza with some toppings your set, and they are under $ 20! Rock on Romitos!