Cugino’s Pizza

We’ve ordered from here numerous times. The subs and pizzas are always on point. Fuck the chains order here instead. I will admit the wait can be longer (especially on the weekends) but its definitely worth waiting for.

After relocating back to Lawrence after a several year absence, I was happy that an added benefit of that move was being near Cugino’s again. I had fond memories and they weren’t just nostalgia. Fantastic pizza with housemade sauce, generous toppings and a menu with variety. When I’m not in the pizza mood, an oven baked sub satisfies. The side items are ok, nothing imaginative about them. But that’s perfectly fine with me. Love having a great neighborhood pizza place nearby!

Great pizza and best meatball sub in town!!! Not often you get such a variety from a pizza shop. I’d order them over a chain pizza company since they use fresh ingredients and you don’t have somebody careless making pizza. They take care in how the pizza is made and wouldn’t hesitate to remake something again unlike other places that would send it out because some kid doesn’t care about the customer.

Figured I’d try this little place because it was close to my house and I needed a satisfying pie one evening. We were packing, moving, and needed food. Got onto their website and found a special for a 2-​topping for $ 10. Done! Called and asked them about the online special and the kid said they weren’t running that special, but they would give me another special for $ 13. I asked if I could have the advertised special for $ 10 and he said no, absolutely not. For real? He said they can’t change their website and they don’t honor it. Wow. So, I called another pizza place instead and gave them my money.

Just visited for the first time since the new ownership. The calzone was a total disappintment. The edges weren’t even baked together. You could unfold it literally. Also each end, about the last 15% or so on either end was all bread. No filling. Total disappointment. I don’t expect I’ll be back. You can get 2 more fillings at Napolis for $ 2 less. I expect I will try them instead. Their reviews look good. It’s a shame.

I was in town visiting from Ohio and decided to try Cugino’s. I was looking at their menu online and was excited to see that they had quite the variety of entrees, pizza, and sides. I ordered a small ½ pepperoni and ½ cheese pizza, individual side of mashed potatoes, baked beans, and potato salad. The order was set for carry out.
20 minutes after I submitted and already paid for my order online a gentlemen from the pizza shop called me to tell me that they were out of baked beans, and potato salad, so I had to order something else since I already paid. He also stated that he just «received,» my order and it was going to be an additional 20 – 35 minutes for take out.
All in all, my pizza was delicious and I will definitely order it again when I’m in town. The sides were kind of bland and lacked Flavor… But I guess you can expect that from a pizza place?
The service was slow, and unorganized, the staff was very unprofessional while talking to their friends using curse words.
The price of the food was reasonable.
If you don’t care about professional service or non pizza entrees this place is for you. Otherwise, you might want to steer clear.

I wish I found out about these guys sooner, they live literally 5 minutes away from me. I am honestly never going to order from pizza hut, domino’s etc again. Their prices are really good and they have deals to go with it. But lets talk about their pizza though, their sauce is so rich in flavor, the cheese actually melts in your mouth and they are REALLY generous with the amount of meat they put on the pizza. Small family owned stores like these need to get more attention. Good tasting food helps put you in a better state of mind, and if you want a pizza, I recommend these guys.

Best Pizza I ever had no one else comes close. The around the world is awesome perfect hand tossed crust, sauce and an abundance of toppings. Pizzas are consistent every time is as good as the last.

The place is an awful example of a non-​chain pizza option. I ordered Cugino’s once and my car died. Of course, I had to call back and cancel the order and they were extremely unhappy. The next time I ordered, they demanded that I
Pay before I picked up my pizza because they couldn’t afford to have me «trick them again» by not picking up the pizza. When I reminded them that the last time was out of my control, they said too bad and that they wouldn’t make the pizza for me until I paid for it… they must not be doing too well, if my $ 15 order was really going to break their bank. After paying for the pizza, the product was actually worse than the awful customer service. A sweet sauce with little taste was only the icing on the cake for an overall terrible experience. I live somewhat close to the place and I would rather drive to Ohio then give that place another chance.

Still going strong. It has apparently changed owners a couple times since my last review. But everything still holds from my previous review. Carry out or delivery, no dine-​in. Generous toppings. Sauce is not acidic.
The standard crust is thin style, with a nice crispyness on the bottom, and the top of the crust soft. The edge or border of the crust is about one inch wide, and is much thicker, making like a wall to hold in the toppings.
There is a deepdish/​thick option for an upcharge.
Sizes are 10″, 12″, 14″, 16″, 18″, 20″, 30″. Yes, thirty inch diameter.
I stopped here on my way home around dinner time, and I ended up eating ¾ths of the pizza by the time I got home.
No lunch service. Note the hours, they don’t open until 4 during the week, 2pm on Sat. Web site says they’re open on Sunday, but the flyer says closed on Sunday.

Good pizza. Good svc.

we tried this pizza place when we first moved to Indy 5 years ago and it was below par and we recently tried it again and I was very impressed with them this time. The have new owners and they really care about the quality of food they are serving. They chop up all of their veggies fresh everyday and no canned mushrooms at all. we will definitely be coming back again for this great pizza

The pizza has changed yet again at Cugino’s, but now it is really good! They have started using better toppings and the presentation of the pizza is more of a higher quality. The bread sticks are always good. They are a nice pizza shop in my neighborhood.

I adore this place. Close to my apt, always quick — food is without fail always fantastic. Everything always tastes fresh and hot — and everyone I speak to on the phone is always super nice.
They have tons of coupons and deals available, I definitely recommend for everyone to try.
Quick and easy place — meant for delivery/​pick up. Definitely my favorite pizza place.