The line could be faster. The selection is amazing but I wish there searching methods were available and better. Movies were close to alphabetical but video games especially lower console were scattered. It’s very interesting what they choose to value and why they don’t. Disc will need cleaned seems odd they dont offer to do it or do it when they buy a game being sold to them. It’s got sticky substance on the bottom of the disc. Great selection. Descent time. Less than happy with the state of the store and its merchandise.
Carly C.
Place rating: 4 Indianapolis, IN
I really like this place! They not only sell new releases, but they sell games as old as Atari. They also sell movies and electronics, and I’ve been able to find some pretty hard to find gems from time to time. Their selection is lacking with certain consoles, but it’s still worth stopping in. They also sell Nintendo plushies and video game/movie action figures, which is pretty awesome. I come in here all the time just to see the new additions!
Sydney B.
Place rating: 3 Greenwood, IN
I’m commenting only as a buyer — people who trade in games and other things may have had different experiences — but this is what I’ve experienced. Their selection is limited due to it being a resale place, but even their large collection lacks some really basic movies! I always come in here looking for three things: Star Trek, Godzilla, and a Disney movie names Heavyweights. With the exception of the last one, they should be easy to find, but I have never seen a single TOS movie go through here, nor the 50’s-70’s Godzilla movies. The newest Pokemon games aren’t to be found in here either, which is reasonable again because of the fact that they’re new and no one has traded them in yet. That doesn’t stop it from being a little disappointing. Even so, they do have a really nice selection of old old old game cartridges for just about every old platform. Staff can vary on their knowledge and their customer service as a whole.
Becca B.
Place rating: 4 Indianapolis, IN
I live this place. They had the Criterion Collection Rushmore for 5 bucks! And it was like new. So awesome. Plus i’ve gotten a lot of video games for around ten dollars each & a Phantom Planet DVD for five dollars. I’ve never traded anything, though, so I can’t comment on that.
T. M. G.
Place rating: 4 Indianapolis, IN
I love this place. Sell your old DVDs, video games, video game consoles, DVD players, TVs– just about anything related to music, movies, or video games. I sold a bunch of stuff for store credit a while back(they will give you cash too), and I haven’t paid anything out-of-pocket for a DVD since. If you are like me and loved going to the local DVD rental spot before the Redbox/Netflix apocalypse Disc Replay might be the next best thing. Almost every movie is under $ 5, so a little store credit goes a long way. If you pick something up that you don’t like just sell it back and get something new. I bought the Godfather trilogy– the Coppola Restoration version– for less than $ 15, Killer Clowns from Outer Space for $ 4, The Royal Tenenbaums– the Criterion Collection version– for under $ 10, almost every Darren Aronofsky film for under $ 4 each, and a ton of other excellent films that are hard to find in big box or electronics stores. The cases might be a little beat up, but all of the DVDs work perfectly.
Rachael W.
Place rating: 4 Indianapolis, IN
Tons of movies for $ 5 or less. They also have video games, but I could care less about that. I’ve been in this store twice now and have always walked out with a stack of movies. Godfather trilogy for $ 13 or Killer Klowns form Outer Space for $ 4?! Their latest promo is buy 5 get the 6th free and you can mix and match. The employees are friendly and helpful. The store is small, but everything is really well organized. The stock is alphabetized; dvds, blue ray, games, cds, and tv series. They sell gaming consoles, accessories, and a few flat screens. Another added bonus, they buy here and you can take the cash or a higher in-store credit.
Ronald B.
Place rating: 5 Indianapolis, IN
Cheap good condition games, DVDs, and blu ray. Sell your stuff for not very much money. But buy stuff cheap. Love this place. Also sells CDs.