Orange Leaf

What kind of self-​respecting frozen yogurt place doesn’t have natural yogurt flavored frozen yogurt…

Orange Leaf is a chain so the interior and offerings are very standard. None of the froyo’s were runny or too icy, which is good. The taste and texture of the froyos were like other Orange Leafs: good but not anything amazing. There were a normal amount of toppings and the fruit looked pretty good/​fresh.
They share the parking lot with the other stores/​restaurants in the plaza. You shouldn’t have a problem finding a spot unless you want one right in front of the door.
The thing that sets this Orange Leaf apart is the service. The owner and employees are all so friendly here! You feel much more welcomed and it makes for a great experience.

I was not impressed with this place. Cramped, yogurt melted by the time I got to the register (thanks to the mom and her three kids in front of us, all of whom spent forever trying out every single flavor and lollygagging for ten minutes at the toppings bar), and only one register was open (even though there were two registers and there were cashiers at both, one was just standing at his register doing nothing and not taking customers). The toppings were geared towards fruit and gummy bears and other tart stuff… Not much in the way of chocolate candy toppings. Yogurt didn’t seem as flavorful as the other places I’ve been (and as someone who worked at I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt for two years as a teenager, I know my stuff). I’ll stick with the local independent places, like Pearings and Indy Swirl.

All the candy toppings make me want to eat them by the handful! They also offer fresh fruit as toppings and that makes me happy :) It can be a little pricey so be careful how much you fill your cup. Overall, great little place!

Stopped in today for some birthday froyo with the wife. I don’t usually do orange leaf, but it was the closest option while shopping.
We walked in and I had to get an employee from behind the counter to give us samples. A common problem when the place is empty, but they were packed. Not a huge deal, but it’s nice when they are out offering samples.
We made our choices, filled out cups, and went outside to eat. While sitting at a table, a man in an orange leave shirt asked how it was. I told him «good». He responded, «not great?» And inquired why. I told him about the above mentioned waiting to try samples. He, Scott, was the owner, and promised to fix that and make a great experience. It’s always nice to see an owner that cares.
Overall, I don’t really care for their flavors. Most are too sweet, pistachio tastes like nothing, and they only have 1 no sugar added flavor usually (today was vanilla). But, I have to hand it to Scott. He definitely cares about the experience and even took a picture of a family at request when he was outside.

For cryin’ out loud, this stuff is like crack to me.
Not that I REALLY know what crack is like, mind you… but I can’t see how it can be any more addicting than this stuff.
Nice selection of flavors, lots of toppings, and the place is always sparkling clean.
I knocked a point off because the staff seems to think everyone is a regular. On our first time in, we were a little lost, and only one person was working, so we had to wait a while before we could figure out the process. After the first time, though, you’re golden.

Typical run of the mill yogurt place

16 flavors of yogurt and you put your own toppings on there! I’m n heaven

Inside décor is filled with popping orange and white furniture. A staff member gave out free samples of whatever flavor I wanted to try. I tried Peanut Butter (good but sweet), Rasberry (light but not as tart as I wanted), and pineapple — which I thought would be sweet but was surprisingly tart! Forty nine cents an ounce which is a little more expensive than Yogurtland in LA but still better than Pinkberry.

Fun place to go and enjoy a frozen yogurt. The yogurt is self serve and so are the toppings. You are charged per ounce in the cup you fill up. Ask for samples before you purchase. Seating is limited and it is very family friendly.

So many choices here, very bright and fun inside. The staff is usually pretty friendly and will let you sample whatever you would like. My favorite is the pineapple. There are around 15 – 20 different flavors and then you can put whatever topping you want.
It is frozen yogurt, but not like the old TCBY’s. If you are more traditional and just like plain vanilla ice cream like in the old days, give this a try. It certainly does grow on you.

Great flavors! I love the juicy bubbles. This location is fairly small, so seating is always limited.

Found out about this place through word-​of-​mouth and since it’s so close to our home, we’ve become «regulars». Love the concept of serve yourself yogurt and toppings. You choose from more than 10 flavors, add your own toppings of choice, then pay 45 cents/ounce…easy! They even have an iPhone app, so we can check to see what flavors they have each day. Friendly staff in a fun environment:)