Pizza In Paradise

The pizza. Is so good. But the wait is soooo long! But the pizza is worth the wait!
We ordered an XL cheese pizza, the kalua pork /​pineapple pizza, a meatball sandwich, and spaghetti w/​marinara sauce. The pizzas were FABULOUS. The pork was homemade and tasted like it. Perfect with the pineapple!
The crust was also perfect pizza crust. A little chewy, a little crunch on the outside. Yum!
The pasta was ok. I wouldn’t order it again. The meatball sandwich was also delicious. It’s made flatbread style with the same dough as the pizza.
Bottom line: Great food, very reasonable prices, very friendly owner, but be prepared to wait. Also, it’s in a sort of industrial area near the airport, so it’s a bit out of the way. Still worth the visit.
Recommended!

We had pizza on our last night before flying home. The pizza was very good and the 12″ was enough for two. The owner was very friendly and attentive. He gave us a short lesson in how to pronounce Kahului correctly.

Worst Time Ever! It was crazy cuz we were with our little daughter…
Waiting & waiting & waiting.
Guess what?! I’m from Philadelphia where there’s a pizza joint on every other corner…
Since when is it OK to be NO WHERE AROUND for like an hour?!,. & then see us about to leave n usher ur only staff ~ some young kid~ out with SOMETHING we ordered to appease us?!
It was just very low quality. Dainty,… Like
Not a fun feeling sort of place…
No wonder not ONE ORDER CAME IN BY WALK-​in or telephone ‘the’ entire time!!! You want pasta?,… Waikapu pasta place! You want pizza~ Costco or Shaka Pizza!
Don’t bother. Don’t say I didn’t warn ya!

Little hole in the wall pizza place, close to the airport. Fantastic pizza and very kind staff! She was concerned about the quality of one of the pizzas (which was fabulous by the way!) so offered us a free pizza (we declined) but made us free cinnamon sticks. :)
We ordered 2 large pizza and a salad; more than enough to feed 7 hungry adults! Thank you! :)

We’ve been waiting for an hour and a half, and we still haven’t gotten our food. Even if this pizza were to be the best pizza I’ve ever had, it’s not worth this long of a wait. We were also the only patrons in the whole store, so it’s not like they were slammed or anything.

Funky place on the front of an industrial park building. We were the only customers on a Friday night just before 9:00. Wife had the pepperoni pizza, I had the Portuguese (linguisa, onions, and mushrooms). The pizzas had a thin, crispy crust, with a flavorful tomato sauce and a fair amount of toppings and cheese. Very tasty. Will definitely try it again.

I’ve been coming here for years! This establishment has done a lot for the kids in our community plus the food is great!

Recommended by our hotel for a good pizza place near by… But it was not good. Was really hoping I’d like this place was in the mood for pizza. Service was slow, part of town was old. Texmex pizza did not taste good. tasted like there was cinnamon in the sauce. antipasta salad was ok but served it warm would be so much better if the salad was chilled. soda didn’t taste good either :(

I was offered some pizza from a party, 5 pizzas from pizza in Paradise.
Short and bitter
the pizzas were burnt little cheese and meat. no flavor detected from a sauce 3 full pizzas left over.
I did not purchase, nor choose the styles of pizza I was only a consumer

This small pizza joint was DEEEELICIOUS!
After a hot stride through the Maui swap meet we tried a Maui Revealed suggestion– so worth it! Great flavorful pizza! We had a sausage pepperoni and a ham pineapple. We Devoured those suckers! Nice thin crust. Not gooey, not burnt. The owners are very nice. Two thumbs up !!

Had 2 pies
Overall wasn’t totally what we expected. Long wait considering we were the only patrons. Felt like I wanted to leave.

It’s a small mom and pop pizza place. Contrary to other reviews we got our pizza right on time within 20 min after ordering. Pizza was quite large and delicious. I totally loved it.

Family owned and operated they are very personable. I went in with my family once and decided to have a pizza there and also take one home for dinner later and I let them know that. They were good about it and only cooked the first pizza so we could eat it right away then put the 2^nd one in later so it could still be warm when we took it home. The lady also have my kids chips before we left as a gift and came to talk stories with us. Great family environment. They could definitely use an interior uplift and clean up but all in all good pizza, great family!

AWESOME homemade pizza!
Fresh dough, perfect blend of cheeses and great selection is toppings !
The pasta in paradise is also a winner !
You HAVE to try the Popeye pizza! Best pizza I’ve ever had.
Since everything is made to order and using the freshest ingredients give them time. Order at least 30 min prior to pickup if you are taking out.
Always my go to for pizza

Pizza is ok. Nothing special. We tried 3. Nothing gross, nothing outstanding. We had the Portuguese, a marguerita, and a veggie. We also had a couple of salads. The Greek and the regular green salad. They were basically the same except for the dressings which are store bought. The kalamata olives are actually canned black olives. If you’re here on vacation, I wouldn’t make a special trip to eat here.
Service was fine. Seemed to be a mom and her son. We watched him roll and spin the dough, so at least the pizza crust wasn’t pre made. Not super friendly. We saw a lot of to go orders, very little sit down traffic.
Wouldn’t be bad if you want a pizza to take to the beach. Just nothing to write home about.

We ate here right before getting on the airplane. There is parking on the side. There are a few tables outside and inside an old warehouse. The owner and his staff are so friendly. They have pizza and other pastas. We wished we ate here before our last hours, because the portions were so large we had leftovers. The pizza is so delicious: thin crust, fresh ingredients, delicious sauce — it was one of the best pizzas I have eaten in my life (and I used to live in St. Louis and Italy).
The owner is a veteran and we talked story so much his wife told him to start cooking our pizza! Free refills on sodas.
We will return.
Update: we returned. Pizza is so hot, that I burnt the the top of my mouth. Delicious. Had the mama’s spaghetti and meatballs — huge portion. The only con I can think of is that I never found the ladies’ room; then men’s room is outside.

Pizza In Paradise has fantastic lunch specials. Great food and service. Highly recommend! The owners are super people and aim to please. Job well done!