Slices & Ices

I’ve been here several times since my first review and I’ve always been pleased. They have some specialty slices that I have not yet tried, but I’ve had the pepperoni and white slices and those have been good.

Tonight we were in the mood for pizza so we called slices and ices at 4:45 pm we were told it would be 40 minutes so we paid by credit card. Almost 2 hours pass without any communication. When the driver arrived and was asking for money, we explained we paid by credit card. The woman turned her head sideways as if we were talking to the family dog. To add insult to injury they didn’t even have the right order. She said well it’s busy you can just give me cash. Needles to say we told them to take the food back and we would go somewhere else.

The affordable price on the regular pie is awesome… And the regular pies are pretty decent. With that in mind I ordered the Sicilian… Worst idea ever. Stick to the regular pie. The Sicilian is $ 14 and not worth it.

Great pizza for a great price. How can you beat $ 8 for a full pie. It’s a no frills pizza place, but the sauce is really good and I personally recommend the sesame seed crust. Garlic knots were okay nothing fancy. And the location is convenient. They also have delivery, and have delivered in all sorts of crazy weather. Bottom line. Good pizza and inexpensive.

Never ordering pizza from them again wasn’t happy we got our order right an they forgot the garlic knots then we recalled them an they said they will bring it to us but then yet anotha guy brong us might of been the manager an very Nasty approaching to us saying we should not order from them anymore. how rude an we order lots from slices an ices to an to turn us down they can stick the pizza an keep it very unhappy

I wish I could give this place less than a star. Went in to order a basic cheese pie. Waited over 40 mins and still no pie. Ok I work in restaurants and have for many years. I will be the first to understand when a place is busy. But when you have one person waiting IN your business and you have 15 – 20 pizzas coming out for pick up and the people are still not there 20 mins later. Wouldn’t you think hey let’s give this cheese pie to the guy that’s actually there waiting? I mean guest i house got service first. That’s how I have always done it.
I would not bother going to this place pay a little more and go somewhere else. There are plenty of other pizza places in the area.

This place is outstanding. It’s a good slice for a buck bro, you can’t go wrong. I haven’t tried any of their other offerings, like soup or whatever, but the pizza is definitely above average. Plus it is great to see a business thriving on Railroad Avenue.
Overall I highly recommend this place. Like I said you can’t go wrong here.

Pizza is decent, I like the sesame seed crust.
Mozz sticks are not great, but aren’t terrible.
Service is pretty good.
It’s a pizza place with good prices. Mostly to go service. They say they deliver, but it is not always available.

Worst delivery service in the history of the pizza business. Good pizza kids love it but they need to hire better help

This is decent, quick, pizza; right near the Ronkonkoma train station (across the street from parking, next to the sports bar) in case you’d like to grab something to go or can’t wait until you get home. The interior is small (only about 8 stools with a counter along one wall and the front window — no tables) but it’s cleaner than other joints I’ve been in. The fact that they sell soda in cans (no fountain), yet there is no recycling bin for them to be deposited hurts my inner tree-​hugging self.
The bathroom is also clean, but a personal red-​flag went up when their soap dispenser was empty, replaced with a hand-​soap bottle — mostly filled with water. C’mon. This is a place where 99% of patrons will be eating with their hands — some people like to actually clean them before using said-​fingtensils to shove food down their gullets. Buy a big bottle of hand-​soap to refill if you’re going to use these. This skeeves me out big time, since I wonder if this is also how the employees wash their hands after using the toilet. The paper hand-​towel dispenser was likewise present, but abandoned in favor of the ubiquitous brown roll of paper propped above the sink. The devil’s in the details, folks. BUT, if you’re about to head into NYC on the train, you’ll be touching much worse than bathroom microbes soon enough, so maybe just go ahead and lick them fingers clean. Maybe it’ll help that weak-​a$$ modernized immune system in the long run! /​EndRant
I had a pepperoni wheel and spinach wheel for lunch. They were pretty tasty, I’ll admit. Though I think the dough on my spinach wheel could’ve seen the inside of the oven a little longer. The sauce (had to be requested, was not asked if I wanted it) likewise could’ve been a little warmer — it was popped in the microwave for a few seconds in its plastic cup. The pizza shops I worked in always kept a pot of it warming and would ladle out a scoop for when people needed it.
As stated earlier, this is a decent choice if you can’t wait — though in the future, I will.
(And no, hours after eating, I have NOT gotten sick from eating here so I guess that’s a plus)

Quick and Cheap Delivery:
Their pizza’s aren’t oily or dry, I loved the cheese pizza with sesame seed crust — which was offered at no extra charge. Their prices are reasonable. However I feel that the pizzas could do with a little more herbs/​seasoning.
The zepolli were a little flat and rubbery, tasted like they were a day old or had been sitting too long.
The garlic knots, despite having a decent garlic outer had a dry and doughy interior.
Their specialty seems to lie in their pizzas rather than their other menu items but overall a good meal!