Sadly this place just announced that it closed before I even had a chance to try it. I heard it was very good so I will give it 4 stars.
Desiree D.
Place rating: 4 Atlanta, GA
Pizza was great!!! The prices unfortunately has not been updated because at the store it’s $ 1.50 more than what it says on here but other than this is a really cute pizza shop and the pizza taste really good
Laurie B.
Place rating: 2 North Port, FL
The pizza is pretty good but the business hours are completely unreliable. I have been there on 4 separate occasions when the listed business hours say it should be open and the doors are locked and lights are off. They are also terrible about answering the phone. I try to support local businesses, but it is hard to do when they are never open!
A W.
Place rating: 3 Lithia, FL
Staff is friendly, location is convenient, delivery is fast and the order is always correct. The food is ok, nothing exceptional. The only complaint I will point out is that they over charge for any adjustments you may want to make to menu items. Also prices on the menu may not reflect the current prices.
Becky C.
Place rating: 1 Lakewood, OH
The pizza was a let down, had no flavor. My pre-teen BOYS wouldn’t even eat it. They were out of wings and were less than stellar when it came to customer service. I understand it’s fishhawk ranch so there aren’t many choices but they should at least put in a little effort. we ended up throwing away over half the pizza. What a waste of food and money. We told them«for here» and that we would be dining outside. But they never brought out our pizza or even bothered to tell us it was ready.
Charlene W.
Place rating: 5 Pompano Beach, FL
Pizza is awesome definitely love the eggplant parm!!! Don’t miss the white pizza mmmmmmm best Pizza I’ve had in Florida
Sylvia M.
Place rating: 4 Lithia, FL
We are big fans of park square pizza. Very awesome New York style slices. We order from here the most out of all the neighborhood options for pizza. The service is great too. Great to sit in have a draft beer or awesome to take home after the kids play on Park Square.
James P.
Place rating: 4 Apollo Beach, FL
Good pizza — not as good as Fishhawk Pizza, but still quite good. Nice little location right inside Park Square, with the classic pizza-place vibe oozing out of it. TVs with sports, a couple arcade games, and a big guy behind the counter making the pizzas. Great prices, too — a large on Tuesdays is $ 10, and beer is $ 5 a pitcher. Sure they’ve only got Bud Light and Mich Ultra, but who are you, some kind of Rockefeller, drinking Dogfish Head 120IPA at $ 35 a pitcher? Have a good time with some good pizza here.
Charlene W.
Place rating: 5 Lithia, FL
The pizza has great flavor and is consistent. Awesome wings and Eggplant Parm too! Lovely family owned business who does so much for the community. There aren’t many NY quality pizza places in the area so if you’re comparing the ridiculous idea of «crust flavor», go to hungry howies or papa johns because you clearly don’t know squat about pizza.
Don G.
Place rating: 5 Lithia, FL
We get pizza here a couple times a month and it’s always very good. I really like the crust. Very good prices for beer as well. It’s nice to have good pizza right here at Park Square.
Jay P.
Place rating: 5 Brooksville, FL
The pizza and wings combo was great! The pizza was a welcomed NY style with fresh ingredients. The wings were standard fair with a good taste. Delivery took around 45 mins but was worth the wait.
Robin W.
Place rating: 1 Maryville, TN
I had the pizza delivered and the time was good it got here fairly quick, that was the good part now on to the bad stuff. Pizza REALLY is all about the dough and sauce for me. Lets start with the dough there no taste although I did like the crispy crust but it was still tasteless. Now on to the main clincher… The sauce and it was just as bad as the dough. There was so little sauce that it barely covered the dough. I dont think it would have helped though ketchup has more flavor. If the sauce is bad the whole thing is a bust. I will NOT be back to this place cant even give me one for free.
Tony C.
Place rating: 5 Lithia, FL
Unbelievable Service. Only been in about ten times but it’s always a great experience. Very attentive staff and quite well trained for such a small outfit. Excellent prices for a local pizza shop. Another huge plus is the fact that the owners are involved in the community.
Mario C.
Place rating: 4 Lithia, Tampa Bay, FL
Great NY style pizza right in fish hawk. Can’t go wrong w/this place. The owners are very friendly.
Edgar P.
Place rating: 4 Lithia, FL
Good garlic knots. Tasty pizza
Bina J.
Place rating: 5 Tampa, FL
Not just pizza! Try their everything else. But seriously, their pizza is AUTHENTICNY style pizza. So good, it takes me back in time.
Jay M.
Place rating: 5 Lithia, FL
So wonderful to have a real NY Pizza place in Fishhawk’s Park Square. Menu is great. Prices are great. Staff and owners are wonderful.