Temptation Cupcake

Service was prompt and friendly, pricing very reasonable.
The iced sugar cookie didn’t even make it to the city limits. The cookie was chewy and the frosting was a soft light butter cream cheese.
Macarons had quite a bit of flavor, the key lime being my favorite.
Of the 6 flavors I bought — thin mint, blueberry lemon, caramel cream, cinnamon & sugar, chocolate raspberry and chocolate dipped strawberry — the blueberry lemon was by far my favorite, even eaten the day AFTER purchase. Lots of flavor without the lemon overpowering.
Location is a bit of a challenge to get in and out since it’s on the corner of a busy intersection, but worth it. I will be back.

Disappointing cupcakes.
All that I’ve tried here were just sugar sweet, flavors were dull, everything tasted too similar. Their chocolate lacks any richness, it’s bland really. Cake is too light for my liking, fluffy rather than the slightly dense and moist cake I prefer. Frosting here is too light, and when flavored they don’t mix enough flavor into it. Even Kimberley’s Bakeshoppe brand found at Smith’s and Walmart are better than these. They have the denser cake and frosting, more moist, rich flavors for around only $ 1 each.
My advice to them, be bolder, crank your flavors up a notch. Don’t be afraid of moist, rich, decadence. It’s what we crave.

I’m moving back to Salt Lake City soon, and so I made a list of places in Logan that I want to review before I leave. Some I haven’t been to and some I’ve been to and just neglected to review in a timely manner. Temptation Cupcake fell into the latter category. My first experience with them was over a year ago, and it was memorable because our cupcakes were BAD. Not like, moldy, but just not delicious in the way that you expect a cupcake to be.
I girded my loins and returned to Temptation a few days ago, hoping that, against all odds, the first visit had been a fluke and their cupcakes actually WERE edible. As my two star rating suggests, this was sadly not the case. I ordered a chocolate ganache cupcake. The color was right, but it wasn’t any more chocolate-​y than a piece of Wonderbread. There was no flavor, other than that of the too-​sweet ganache frosting. My friend ordered chocolate peanut butter and had a similar experience, though he reported that his frosting was actually pretty good.
The store is cute and, visually, so are the cupcakes. Sad that they don’t deliver in the way that just about any other cupcake shop in Utah is able to.

I have been back twice to Temptation Cupcake since it has been under new ownership. The girl at the counter was very friendly, answered all my questions about the new ownership. She went through all the flavors even though I got there at the tail end of her telling another customer. I will definitely be coming back.