Cake That!

Manahawkin, United States

5

Open now

15 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 609-713-9125
Website:
www.cakethatnewjersey.com
Address:
657 E Bay Ave Unit 2, Manahawkin, NJ, 08050
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free

Today

Today 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Manahawkin) 10:05 AM Saturday, June 21, 2025

Business hours

Monday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm
Tuesday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm
Wednesday 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
Thursday 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
Friday 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
Saturday 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
Sunday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Gourmet Cupcakes, Specialty Cakes, Weddings, Parties, Catering, Gluten Free or Vegan Cupcakes, Coffee Bar at our shop also!

Related places

You might also like:
740
ft
Big Apple Bakery
595 E Bay Ave
2.6
mi
Dunkin’ Donuts
601 State Highway 12 N
4
mi
How You Brewin
8 Long Beach Blvd
4.2
mi
Surfside Coffee House
1901 Long Beach Blvd
4.2
mi
Baked on the Beach
2101 Long Beach Blvd
4.3
mi
Ferrara’s Italian Bakery
2900 Long Beach Blvd

Vicinity

Near this location:
10
ft
Uniformity
657 E Bay Ave Ste 12
140
ft
Bob’s Carpet Service
657 E Bay Ave
150
ft
La Bamba
657 E Bay Ave
220
ft
The Schwee Tea
657 E Bay Ave
400
ft
Woodhaven Lumber & Millwork
725 E Bay Ave
400
ft
Woodhaven the Kitchen Showplace
725 E Bay Ave

15 reviews of Cake That!

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Cape May, NJ
Found this bakery thru Unilocal!Cute place and cupcakes were delicious! Tried salted caramel, pnuit butter & chocolate, double chocolate! Delicious, fresh, not only a good solid cake but frostings were awesome! Will be back when back in the area !
Place rating: 5
Newport News, VA
Almost every Sunday I go here and pick up cupcakes for my husband and a few of his co workers. Their cupcakes are ridiculously delicious. I like them better than a lot of the places back home in VA. The staff are always pretty cool. I would definitely recommend them to everyone.
Place rating: 5
Lubbock, TX
Now these are some damn-​good cupcakes.
We visited the Cake That! in Manahawkin after hearing it won Cupcake Wars. I was all about this, given I spent all that morning watching the show.
We tried the French Toast and the Dirt cupcakes and it was obvious that these were a winner! The French Toast was a bit mapley and the right amount of sugar. It was something unlike any other cupcake I’ve tried, and quite delicious. The Dirt cupcake was rich and chocolatey, topped with a sour gummy worm on top. The chocolate was dark and not overpowering — it left a bit of the cocoa bitterness in there, making it a nice change compared to the average, super-​decadent chocolate cupcake.
Prices are fair for the deliciousness, and best enjoyed with hot coffee! They also seemed to offer a good discount when purchasing several cupcakes at once. Plus, stroll through the connected shops to experience the area. You’ll like it!
Place rating: 5
Lacey Township, NJ
Simply put, best cupcakes in the area. Always consistently good, and have some unique flavors! Coffee is always solid too!
Place rating: 5
Barnegat Township, NJ
Yummiest cupcakes in the area! Great owners and workers as well! If you haven’t tried their cupcakes or donuts other other yummy treats, this is a MUST STOP when you are here. Check it out! Love love LOVE this place!
Place rating: 5
New York, NY
I have had a lot of cake in my day and this was not only a beautiful masterpiece, it tasted unbelievable. The buttercream frosting was the perfect amount of sweet paired with a wonderfully flavored cake that was moist and soft. By far the best tasting specialty cake I have ever had. I am usually not a huge fan of fondant but it tasted so good I was picking the fondant off and eating it. I am a very particular person and sent many pictures with directions of what I wanted the cake to look like and it turned out perfect! They did exactly what I wanted exceeding my expectations even. Everyone was very kind and patient! Thank you again Cake That!
Place rating: 5
Barnegat Township, NJ
I needed a thank you token for the faculty at my son’s school– decided to go with a variety dozen and let Cake That surprise me. While picking up my order I ordered a coconut cupcake for myself just for the heck of it. …WHOA… This is heaven in a bite. The teachers are still talking about them! How can something made from flour and sugar and eggs taste so divine? Cake That, I am lucky to have you 10 minutes from my house when you could be in Hollywood or NYC. And you should be.
Place rating: 5
Lawrence Township, NJ
If I have one weakness in this world, it’s my sweet tooth. That’s why when I saw this location on a drive off of LBI, I just had to stop in. I wasn’t in there long, but I was there just long enough to know that the staff members are as sweet as the items they sell, and the chocolate peanut butter cup sandwich (donut) was absolutely delicious! It was a bit large for just me, so I took 1⁄3 and gave the rest to my brother, but it was definitely worth every penny. (I believe the total was $ 2.09).
The storefront was small, but does have 6 seats inside and shares outdoor seating right in front of the location. Definitely stop by if you’re in the area!
Place rating: 5
Beach Haven, NJ
Cake That knocked it out of the park again! After an issue with a bakery close to my home (that «lost» my custom cake order that I had paid in full at time of appointment), Cake That stepped up and made my custom cake with a week’s notice. They made it better than I had envisioned!
It was a 2 layer cake, bottom layer was vanilla sprinkle and the ramp was chocolate. It tasted as fantastic as it looked! My Nephews didn’t even want to cut it since it looked so awesome!
I can’t than Olivia & the girls at Cake That enough for their fantastic work, professionalism & over all care. They love what they do and it shows! This is the ONLY place to get cakes and cupcakes that people will love & talk about long after your party/​event is over!
Place rating: 5
Egg Harbor Township, NJ
Less than 8 weeks before my wedding, I had a major disagreement with my baker from another bakery and ended up calling Cake That in a panicked attempt to order a wedding cake. Jess made time to meet with me that weekend and has been amazing every since! We ordered ten dozen cupcakes and a topper cake for our wedding and I couldn’t be happier with the service and quality at Cake That! The display was beautiful and the guest raved about the taste. The owner (Jess) was so friendly and helpful! I honestly have only the BEST things to say about Cake That!
Place rating: 5
Newark, NJ
I like to say I’m a cupcake pro. Cake that is by far THE best cupcakes EVER! I go all over NJ In search of the best cupcakes and no one even comes close. Every cupcake is better than the last! I can’t even say I have a favorite because all of them are my favorite! I highly recommend cake that!
Place rating: 5
Hoboken, NJ
Sweet treat to find this bakery in Manahawkin, NJ. I visited not knowing the owner had been featured on Food Network’s cup cake wars and now I understand why. Moist and delicious, flavors are balanced. I’ll be back next time I’m in town.
Place rating: 5
Tuckerton, NJ
By far the best cupcakes I’ve ever had. Hands down. The store was super clean and the employee who served us was attentive and very courteous. We just met the owner and her daughter yesterday and we loved them too! There’s really nothing not to like about Cake That!
Place rating: 5
Marlton, NJ
I loved this place! I have driven by many times but never stopped. Then I saw the two bakers on Cupcake Wars and figured I had to eventually make time.
I had a red, white and blueberry cupcake and a key lime pie cupcake. Probably some of the best I ever had. They were not too sweet, too heavy, and super light and fluffy. There are also gluten free options. I highly suggest trying this place and supporting this small business.
One cupcake was $ 2.50… that’s pretty inexpensive to me considering the quality and that two of the bakers made it to the Food Network.
Place rating: 5
Clifton Heights, PA
I have been here twice and great cupcakes. This time i got banana split — awesome, also the snickerdoodle was great, the only one I didnt enjoy was the sweet carmel pretzel, too sweet for me. Also great was strawberry cheese cake… Small store great cupcakes…