Sully’s Irish Pub

Excellent all-​around experience! Our party of four sat at the bar for a couple of drinks before dinner. Bartender was very helpful and explained the beer selection. When it was time to eat, he continued serving us at our table. The food and service was excellent! Our dinners came out hot, on-​time, and all at the same time. I had the Lake Erie perch. Breading was light and crispy and the fish was extremely fresh! This was our first visit, but we will definitely be returning!

The food is very good most of the time, however the wait staff has a lot to be desired, (attitude) Waitress told us the special for the evening was perch! So I ordered it then they delivered a meatball sub to the table, rather then returning it, I decided to try it, will not be ordering the sub again,

This was my first time at Sully’s what a great place! The atmosphere was great not extremely loud so you could enjoy conversation between your table. The food was very good. We got the sampler app and the Reuben both I recommend. Cold beer, great food and comfortable atmosphere I can say I’ll be returning again soon.

The service at Sully’s is second to none! Jackie, Drya, and Barb make sure you’re taken care of and they are fun and personable! I’m looking forward to joining Sully’s on St. Patty’s Day!

Great atmosphere, good food and service. Menu is diverse with many good offerings. We would definitely go back here.

Had a burger with side salad and Sully’s own red ale. All were pretty good but not great. What was great were the corned beef egg rolls! Recommended. My wife also had the similar corned beef sammich and said it was very good. Sully’s is pretty busy. You have to seat yourself but I can’t imagine how that will go when they are really busy.

Good food in a nice atmosphere. The Guinness cheese dip is out of this world. I wish there were more vegetarian options, but I do enjoy eating here every time I’m in Medina.

Used to be very good food — atmosphere still good but food has been slipping the past few years even as prices increase. Mussels were cold when brought out, many cracked shells and unopened bivalves. Gritty. Onion soup was good and beer choices are still great so go to it for a bar but skip for meal.

my mom and aunts seem to like this place and i was always intrigued. of course, my aunts also like the browns and they’ve been a hopeless cause since i was 11 years old.
the good:
the restaurant looks nice
pretzel bites
service was ok
everything else was completely «meh». why do restaurants put a long filet of fried fish onto a round hamburger bun? the sandwich tasted ok but was a complete mess. it fell apart in my hands, turned into a lump of mush and was near impossible to even pick up by stabbing with a fork. also, battered fries, ugh. i should have stuck with the chips that come with the sandwich.
Danielle said her BBQ pork sandwich was also just barely ok.
$ 45 (after tip) for 2 sandwiches, sodas and an appetizer is way too expensive.
so, i’ve got that out of the way. i should have had a shot or two. they were priced pretty good at $ 3 dollars.

Food hasn’t been overwhelmingly good & service has been suspect at times. Some items seem like they might be frozen & not fresh. Back room seems like separate world from main dining area.

This is not a review of the brick and mortar restaurant. This is a review on the festival service they provided at the Ohio Celtic Festival. The Festival opened at 5:00 pm, we ordered at 5:15 and was told some of the items were still being prepared. That was fine except they had all of the order tickets laying out and gave customers a retrieval ticket with numbers. We ordered fries, potato pancakes with cheese sauce and a burger. There were multiple people that ordered after us that received these items individually before us. The potato pancakes and cheese were cold by the time they gave them to us even though initially that’s what we were waiting on to heat up. I finally got my burger 35 mins later. The burger was mediocre. I would be willing to eat at the restaurant before I write them off, but will probably avoid them at anymore festivals.

Went with a group of four. All but myself got what we ordered after waiting nearly 30 minutes to get our food. Ordered the chicken pot pie. They brought out sheppard’s pie. When it came out I immediately knew it was wrong. I asked the person who brought it if it was the chicken pot pie and she says, «yes it is.» Really? Told the server and shes said, «sorry, all i heard was pie.» Well you offer more than one dish with pie in the name. Maybe you should have me clarify. She says, «you can keep the sheppard’s pie and I will get you the pot pie but i will warn you that it takes a long time to make.» I simply got it go. They didn’t charge for it. Secondly, we were never asked if we wanted additional beverages after the first round came out. Maybe not a bad restaurant, just a discombobulated waitress. The consensus of the party was that the food was just mediocre and that we’d likely not go back.

Best Pretzel bites anywhere. Awesome Cheese Dip. We love the atmosphere and have never had a bad meal. My husband’s favorite is the Meatloaf.

They need to give up cooking and stick to beer. I ordered crab cakes and the meal was greasy. Also they need irish music not a dj giving away junk. and can you ban little kids after 7 pm?

Had a great dinner. My husband and I both had the pork barbecue sandwich. It was messy, but so delicious. We were very pleased with the meal. My daughter had the bacon cheeseburger. She did not enjoy the spices they put in the handmade burger, but my husband and I both tried it and loved it.
Our server was so friendly and very accommodating. We were very happy with this restaurant during our trip.

I was here the other week visiting friends in the area and we had an awesome time. We arrived earlier when it was pretty quiet and stayed into the night as the place got busier. I really liked that even when the performer came on the music wasn’t deafening. I hate having to shout across a table and being drowned out by music. That definitely didn’t happen here. The noise level was just right.
Our server (Katie, I think?) was awesome and quick to bring refills even when it was busy. The food was alright and arrived fairly quickly.
If you’re here, try Sully’s Irish Red! It’s strong and tasty.

Sullys is a warm and wonderful family place. Their corned beef makes my Irish heart sing. The service and atmosphere represents everything good about Irish hospitality. Definitely worth a visit…, again, and again, and again, and again. You will never tire of it!

Had the corned beef sandwich. Delicious. Love the pub. Good beer selections. Probably best tasting corned beef I’ve had since my favorite place «Goodmans» in Old Brooklyn closed. Nice job Sully’s!

A Medina resident, we often spend time at Sully’s. Although careful to stick with sandwiches and burgers, which are usually safe, one of my all time favorites was the beef stew. Generous portion, with big chunks of tender beef and potatoes with carrots in a thick rich gravy. Hugely disappointed when I ordered yesterday and found they now add peas, rutabaga and corn. Corn in Irish beef stew !? in fact there were more peas and corn than meat and potatoes. What pieces of beef where in there were meager and only a few small pieces of potatoe. The gravy was also pretty bland. NEVER order this dish.

Great Irish feel. He actually gets really great Rebel music singers. I would stay longer and have more pints for sure had I not have to drive back up to Clevo. Great for a day drive. Servers have been from good to aweful. Depends on who ya get. They do have daily/​happy hr specials but on the last visit I actually had to bring them up on my phone and show her what they were. Some people like to save a buck, ya know.