Tried it because of the Buy one get one free coupon. Just got plain but it was very good and one of my favorite crusts. Will be back to try the specialty pies. Good service too.
Kary K.
Place rating: 3 Nassau County, NY
Hi. I like the coupon that you offer, buy a pie-get a pie. We tried it. The regular pie was decent but the Sicilian needs improvement! The crust was so dry. like a bagel. Need to load up on the olive oil for the crust. The sauce and cheese are not outstanding either. You’ll need to be «special» in order to make it in this town. Too much competition and other places that make delicious pizza.
B T.
Place rating: 4 Baldwin, NY
They claim that their crust on their pizza is the best and guess what? They are right! This is my first time here and I’m impressed! Nice hot slices, prices are competitive and service was good! Yup I will be back!
Michelle K.
Place rating: 5 Garden City, NY
They had a coupon that was buy one pie get one free. We decided to try them and my family had nothing but rave reviews. Pizza was excellent. We will definitely go back.
Christen B.
Place rating: 1 Old Westbury, NY
I work a few stores and it is a real shame this place should have reasonable prices and good pizza for a pizzeria across from the courthouse with lots of volume of customers. Its a high price and bad pizza. The employees are very nice but pizza isnt worth it. Its a shame. Hopefully they realize this and improve.
Chelsea D.
Place rating: 4 Queens, NY
Jonny’s Pizzeria has replaced Primo’s Original Pasta Pots. Stopped in for some slices with no expectations and were pleasantly surprised. It took a couple of minutes for someone to help us at the counter, but the man helping us(possibly the owner) was very friendly and walked us through the many specialty pies that were waiting to be eaten. I was impressed by the variety that was out. The menu is not up on their website yet, but if I recall, they had a little bit of everything: ranch chicken, chicken parm, grandma’s, meat lover’s, white cheese with spinach, and many more. Weirdly enough, there was no plain pepperoni pie out but I’m sure a slice could have been whipped up without a problem. We settled on the chicken parm, meat lover’s, spinach, and a plain slice. I believe it was under $ 20 for these and a drink. The slices were large and came out from the oven quickly. I was a big fan of the plain slice; it was thin and crispy, and not too greasy. The sauce was well seasoned and not too sweet. The spinach slice was covered in gooey gobs of ricotta and was not dry at all. It’s easy to let that happen without red sauce, but this slice was great. The meat lover’s slice had a little bit of everything on it — meat covered in more meat(pepperoni, meatball, and sausage). The chicken parm slice was also heavily loaded, but nicely balanced between meat, cheese, and sauce. Everything was good and I am looking forward to coming back to try more slices, the pasta, and the gelato that’s advertised on every table. My only real complaint is that our table was a bit dirty.