Grecco’s Pizza is standard run-of-the-mill pizza for a small town. Don’t expect anything fancy. You can get your pizza carryout or eat on location, which is more of a cafeteria experience, and not like a pizzeria. You’re eating in a mini-mall and that’s what it feels like. That’s fine for lunch with the family, but don’t take your date here. I’ve always thought the prices were kind of high for what you get.
Dustin P.
Place rating: 1 Mitchell, IN
Just had my first experience of grecco’s since they reopened this year. I will say it’s not the worst place I ate at, but it is definitely not the best. First off they cut their pizza into squars, which just makes eating the middle pieces a mess. On the outer cuts there was hardly any toppings on them. Pretty much just dough. Barely any sauce on the pizza. The bread sticks were nothing special, just alot of dough. And we ordered marinara sauce which is just spaghetti sauce. I would not recommend this place to anyone.
Jesse H.
Place rating: 5 Louisville, KY
We come up here every Christmas for the Christmas in the village and this is a must stop! I say it is the best pizza in Indiana!