A Slice Of Brooklyn

I’ve only ever gotten take out from this location. Their pizza is made deliciously. The flavor and choice of seasonings are fantastic. Extra cheese is best for my preferences, unless you like your pizza slightly on the less cheesy side. I believe that this is one of the top 2 best pizza places in the New Holland area. Seems to be extremely empty inside which is quite weird. Takeout window is a huge plus!

I’m only writing this based on their cheesesteak, which I only ordered because someone else commented that they are exceptional.
Unfortunately, there is nothing special about this cheesesteak. They don’t even use Cheese Whiz. They use nacho cheese sauce, so they should update their menu because cheese whiz is a trademark brand name.
The steak was finely chopped like diced peppers, and had a pepper flavor to it. It didn’t really have much more flavor than that, it was pretty bland. There was a decent amount of steak on it. The nacho cheese was not mixed with the steak, but was applied to the bottom middle of the roll. You get some bites without cheese, and some bites with globs of nacho cheese.
The roll was very good, but did not make up for their poor selection of meat and cheese.
I’m sure I’ll venture back sometime and try something else (if I have cash, see credit card minimum), but it won’t be the cheesesteak.
I also waited for 3 minutes on hold when calling in for a pickup order.
Restaurant also has a $ 10 credit card minimum which forced me to buy a bottled drink I did not want. I don’t goto restaurants who have credit card minimum’s since I often do not have cash with me.

It’s a shame they can’t get their act together. On three separate occasions they have screwed up our order but we have continued to go back because of how close they are to our house & the option for delivery. Last night, however, was the final straw.
First, we waited an 1 & ½ hours for our food from the time we placed our order. When the guy finally arrived, he told us he «got lost» even though he had literally just been here the week before. He did have a car full of friends when he got here, so it may have been a social run before the food was delivered.
Then he delivered the wrong items — we ordered 2 paninis & a pizza. He gave us a calzone instead of a pizza & left. My husband called in & told them what happened & he left to take the calzone back & get the pizza we had ordered. When he arrived, no one knew what to do about it — there was no manager on site to discuss it with & the staff made no offer of apology or to give us money back or a free drink, whatever — no effort to make it right. & the girl that was working told us that the driver left the shop alone, confirming our earlier thoughts that he was out picking up his friends instead of doing his job.
I decided to call in today to speak with the manager to discuss the issues & I was told that they don’t have one in today (on a Friday, one of their busiest days?!) & when I asked when they would be in, I was told Tuesday mornings & Sunday mornings. I’m sorry, do people order pizza in the morning?
My food was overcooked & cold til I got to eat it. We placed the order at 5pm, my kids finally got to eat their pizza at almost 7pm. I expect to wait longer for delivery, but at least get the order right! A little customer service goes a long way and the food really isn’t that great to put up with this headache.

One of the keys to success in the pizza business is to consistently make each bite a delicious one and these Brooklyn natives do just that! Their wings are pretty stellar too… Great service every time I visit!

Nice job on the pizza. Like to stop by for lunch on the days there’s a little extra time around the noon hour. Snappy wifi and great service. Sometimes we get take out. Gonna have to try the delivery, that’ll be a treat.

Their pizza is good although fairly typical for the area but I’m personally a fan of their cheesesteaks — they’re huge, yummy and not too greasy. They recently added a full range of ice creams, an outside deck and a window to order from if you don’t want to go inside. May have to give it a try one of these hot evenings!