Nina’s Pizza and Pasta in New Hyde Park, NY

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:	+1 516-616-5378
Address:	PC Richards Shopping Center 725 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, NY, 11040
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:	0.5 miNew Hyde Park 0.9 miStewart Manor 1.2 miFloral Park
Categories:	Pizza Italian

Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations	No
Delivery	Yes
Take-out	Yes
Accepts Credit Cards	Yes
Good For	Lunch
Parking	Private Lot
Bike Parking	Yes
Wheelchair Accessible	Yes
Good for Kids	Yes

Good for Groups	Yes
Attire	Casual
Noise Level	Average
Alcohol	Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating	No
Wi-Fi	Free
Has TV	Yes
Waiter Service	Yes
Caters	Yes

Today

Today	11:00 am – 10:00 pm Closed now
Local time (New Hyde Park)	2:27 AM Saturday, November 30, 2024

Business hours

Monday	11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday	11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday	11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday	11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Friday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Sunday	11:00 am – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Home of the low-fat Personal Pie, thin crust and available with any topping made fresh for you. We also offer a full menu of delicious Italian heros, pasta and entrees.

History

Established in 1996.

Nina’s pizza and pasta has been a staple in the community for over 18 years. Customers have enjoyed our classic Italian cuisine as well as our delicious pizza for many years. Although we have changed ownership, we have continued Nina’s tradition by keeping the same cooks, ingredients and recipes.

Meet the Business Owner

Angelo G.

Business Owner

As family friends of Nina and Phil, me and my sister Josephine were given the opportunity to continue the tradition of great classic Italian cuisine. We kept the same cooks, recipes and ingredients in order to continue the legacy.

Related places

Explore similar places:

Gino’s Pizza of New Hyde Park

1113 Jericho Tpke

Joe’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

25601 Hillside Ave

Domino’s Pizza

1017 Jericho Tpke

Papa John’s Pizza

909 Hillside Ave

Malekan Restaurant

25601 Hillside Ave

Gino’s Trattoria and Pizzeria of New Hyde Park

1113 Jericho Tpke

Vicinity

Near this location:

Pinnacle Home Stagers

Sears Portrait Studio

Lake Success Shoppin

easy2set

Long Island Women’s Health Care Group

1575 Hillside Ave Ste LL2

Ridder’s Pond Park

Marcus Ave and Meadow Farm Road

Claudia McGuinness CPA PC

18 reviews of Nina’s Pizza and Pasta

No registration required

Albert K.

Place rating: 4
Long Island, NY

I was super hungry before a haircut at Manny’s next door and I knew I needed a Grandma slice ASAP. Nina’s to the rescue! The Grandma was wonderful, the melted fresh mozzarella was really chewy, stretchy, and had that fresh made milky taste — it was delicious!
The Unilocal 5% check-in is useful I guess for big orders. Very clean place, friendly people, defn stop by if you’re in the area!
Recommended: Grandma Slice

Makayla V.

Place rating: 5
Astoria, NY

after finding this place and loving the food i some how convinced my boss to have them cater for my coworkers birthday party we were having at the office lol i love getting my way omg and they have so much stuff on the cater menu compared to other resturants anyway we ordered a full tray of the lasagna, baked ziti salad and chicken parm my boss and co workers loved the food and my boss saved money because the prices were SUPER reasonable. i better get employee of the month for this LOL

Sara A.

Place rating: 5
New York, NY

Pizza was deliciously fresh. Lots of options here, including whole wheat crust. Small but cozy and the staff is very friendly and courteous!

Haley S.

Place rating: 5
Floral Park, NY

Placed a pick up order here the other night just for steamed broccoli. I’m sure their pizza is great, but I’m prepping for my first bodybuilding show and couldn’t indulge! However, the service was quick and the staff was friendly. I unlocked a 5% off Unilocal deal and the owner gave me 10% instead, which was very generous. I will definitely be back!

Jerry M.

Place rating: 5
Northport, NY

I recommend the Nina’s Salad Pizza Pie. The Avocado, Balsamic glaze and Gorgonzola are a great combo. 1 pie feeds our family of 4, sometimes with a slice for lunch the next day.

Tayana C.

Place rating: 5
Boston, MA

I don’t care what anyone says, there’s nothing like New York pizza. I don’t know if it’s that dirty water or years of mastering the techniques, a slice in NYC doesn’t compare to anything else & this place delivers.
They’re reasonably priced, have delicious food & are nice. I’ve never been to a pizza place where someone brought me my slice. Now, that’s what I call service! It’s a small place but you can tell they know their regulars.
The pizza dough was the perfect consistency, the sauce was very flavorful & the mozzarella was stringy. And we all know it’s the only acceptable way to serve mozzarella.
I ended up there purely by accident when we drove past the place we were originally intended to go to and thought it would be too much trouble trying to find it, so we decided on Nina’s at the last minute. I’m glad we did.

Cym A.

Place rating: 1
Queens Village, NY

Food not the same since new owners took over. I heard that the cook left. It is no where near as good as when Nina had the place. They also raised their prices and made the portions smaller. The owners not so friendly. Sorry to see this place go downhill.

K.V. G.

Place rating: 5
Flushing, NY

Love it here. Never a bad meal. Had a chicken parmigiana hero that was perfect. Staff is always friendly. Just moved in to the area and I’m very happy I found this place.

Louis A.

Place rating: 1
Rego Park, NY

How can this restaurant receive more than 1star. I ordered from them yesterday ordered lentil soup probably from a can and maybe 10 oz of soup, with chic Marsala and pene tomato sauce. The chic was sour meaning going bad and the pasta was like mashed potatoes very well over done. I am sick and tired of getting ripped off from these restaurants serving terrible food and call them selfs a restaurant. I can understand if the way a dish is prepared not to my liking but to serve bad food is unacceptable.

Lauren S.

Place rating: 1
Uniondale, NY

I think this place changed owners or something the food is not the same.

Jessica N.

Place rating: 5
Long Island City, NY

What a great experience! Three girlfriends, my toddler and I stopped by for lunch on a Sunday afternoon and we’re definitely impressed. We ordered some appetizers (Calamari & mozzarella sticks) and our drinks and they came out super fast. I noticed they had lunch specials as well that looked great & low priced, but we opted for full entrees (I knew I wanted to take some home for later). I had the tortellini in a rose cream sauce with shallots and peas & it was soooo yummy. The place is under new ownership & management and the nice woman who bought it came over and had a chat with us and informed us to look out for exciting changes. Can’t wait to come back here!

Doug m.

Place rating: 2
Bayside, NY

Really don’t understand the high reviews here. I’ve tried this place twice about 2 years apart. First time the chicken cutlet was so tough I was sawing it vigorously with a butter knife. The girl working there noticed and said it’s usually pretty good and offered to replace it. I was on a time crunch.
Second time I ordered a pasta dish for take out. Got the pasta, but there’s hardly any sauce! The staff seemed disinterested and it reflects in the cooking. What a shame.

John O.

Place rating: 5
Manhattan, NY

Been coming here with my grandparents since I was a kid. Their house salad dressing is the best I’ve ever had.

Shoesoffnrun R.

Place rating: 4
New Hyde Park, NY

Love it here! Their sandwiches are amazing! The regular food is good to, but not as great as the sandwiches.

Diana b.

Place rating: 5
Floral Park, NY

Neighborhood gem! Family owned and operated, Nina’s is great food at a very reasonable price. Great for take out and delivery. They have a dining area which is perfect for a very casually dressed date/meal.
Best Lasagna, Veal Parm, and SHRIMP FRANCESE!!!

Jason S.

Place rating: 5
Manhattan, NY

This place is awesome, i mean seriously awesome. My roommate and I always get takeout from Nina’s and it is never been anything less than great. While my roommate is a regular pizza only guy, I’ve gotten most everything from there in the past year.
High Points:
Regular Pizza
Whole Wheat Personal Pizza
Penne Ala Vodka
Chicken Roll
Lows:
Garlic Knots
Delivery
I can’t knock off any stars for either though, because Garlic Knots were way too greasy for me, while my roommate loves them. To each his own. Lastly, delivery took over an hour for the Giants/Packers game last week, but it was due to my address and how hard it can be to find.
All in all, 5 out of 5 stars and has been for a while. Seriously, try the fat-free cheese whole wheat pie, who knew eating «healthy» (barely) could taste so good!

Sonny G.

Place rating: 4
Malba, Queens, NY

My parents always order food from here whether it be for dinner or for catering, and when my grandma’s stove broke last Christmas eve she ordered all Christmas food from Nina’s. Everybody was satisfyed. We love the Eggplant Rollitini, Penne vodka, and parmigana style foods. Don’t let the tiny sized, extremely plain décor fool you; the food is great!

Dave C.