Frosty Boy Drive-In

New Palestine, United States

4.6

Open now

16 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 317-861-5433
Address:
40 W Main St, New Palestine, IN, 46163
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wi-Fi
No

Today

Today 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Open now
Local time (New Palestine) 6:03 PM Thursday, July 3, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm

Vicinity

Near this location:
210
ft
El Jaripeo
38 W Main St
230
ft
Reality Break Nail Salon
48 W Main St
250
ft
Bahama Mama’s Tanning
48 W Main St
250
ft
Curves For Women
48 W Main St
250
ft
Bunten Cheryl
American Family Insurance 48 W Main St
310
ft
New Palestine Hardware
50 W Main St

16 reviews of Frosty Boy Drive-In

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Visited the Frosty Boy today for the first time. It was by far the best ice cream I’ve ever eaten. We will definitely return next season!
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
I love this particular Frosy Boy and have for several years. I drive from Indy to specifically get a crunch cone and whatever hits my fancy that day. As I was leaving the Frosty Boy today headed West on 52 I passed Mickey D’s amd was amazed they had one car there. When you can get Crinkle Fries and a Breaded Tenderloin or Corn Dog with a great malt or cone, why would you get the hum drum basic burger ftom the big chain? I will continue my pilgrimage from Indy or wherever for years to come for my favorite Frosty Boy small town pleasant and yummy drive in!
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Good ol’ Frosty Boy will not disappoint! Great little spot for a snack, meal or a dessert! I’ve only had the pleasure of trying the tenderloin and onion chips thus far but they were delicious! Gotta get back there to try some of their tasty, sweet treats!
Place rating: 5
New Palestine, IN
I’ve been going to Frosty Boy since the 1970’s. Best ice cream around. Burgers are good, fries are great, onion chips… On and on and on. You can’t miss with Frosty Boy in New Palestine.
Place rating: 3
Shelbyville, IN
Nice seasonal eat outside only drive in is a cool place to visit when you don’t want to get out of your car, lol. Prices are a bit high and servings are a bit small, but the taste is good.
Wish the burgers and fries were more super sized though, cause I usually have to order 2 meals to get full. But I’m a big eater, ha.
Besides hot food they are also an ice cream shop and have great ice cream items to choose from too.
Worth a try, stop by and give them a try!
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Food is good. Ice cream is great! Atmosphere is excellent! Always a summertime favorite.
Place rating: 4
New Palestine, IN
Frosty Boy is a local landmark for New Palestine, Indiana. It’s a fun spot for eating outside at the tables on a summer evening. I don’t give five stars, because I don’t find their food to be anything to write home about. McDonald’s food is better with a better value than Frosty Boy. However, the ice cream is great. I would say they don’t have too many unique items — perhaps flurries with lemon pie or the Oreo explosion or brownie supreme. The crunch crumbles or dipped cones are good on the soft serve. It’s a fun place to stop for an afternoon snack or dessert while passing through on 52 or the East side of Indy. Service is great — they hire mostly high schoolers who are super efficient and friendly. Great place for kids too — they have cheaper kids’ sized shakes and cones.
Place rating: 5
Fountaintown, IN
The only thing I hate about this place is when they close for the off season. :) My kids and I go all the time and love it!
Place rating: 4
New Palestine, IN
The ice cream here is awesome! You really can’t beat it. Their fries are amazing as well. Definitely worth the trip out to New Pal for lunch, dinner, or just ice cream!
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
My son and I come here often and they never disappoint. Today I got something other than ice cream and the tenderloin sandwich was average but good. Ice cream heavenly as always. Love this place!
Place rating: 4
Boise, ID
I love Frosty Boy! I always look forward to stopping there whenever I’m visiting my family in New Pal. If you’ve got somewhere to be, then hit the drive through. If not, then you can sit outside at the picnic tables and enjoy your tasty treat. If you’re in the mood for something a little different, then try their pineapple whip. It is YUUUUMEEEEE! Your four-​legged friend can have a treat too, so don’t forget to bring them along.
Place rating: 5
Tampa, FL
A quick, cheap, tasty shot of nostalgia. I live in Indianapolis (Irvington), and it’s totally worth it to drive out Brookville Rd. to New Pal to sit outside and eat something fried and/​or some ice cream. Employees and fellow patrons were all friendly.
Frosty Boy is kind of like a little bit of the State Fair that can happen all summer long. The only seating is outside picnic tables but you can also eat in your car.
Place rating: 5
Chapel Hill, NC
I’ve lived in several different states and been to a lot of ice cream shops, but I think Frosty Boy is the best, hands down.
Key: CRUNCH topping! It’s amazing, and I’ve never found it anywhere else. This delectable sweet crunchy nut & sprinkles topping on a chocolate cone is unbeatable.
And yes, their food is great too — burger & fries are usually what I go with.
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
I’ve been landing here one way or another since I was 5. They are one of the few places willing to try and make my marshmallow coke. If you’ve never had a marshmallow coke, trust me when I say PUT IT ON YOUR BUCKET LIST! They are also the only place in Indiana that still makes french fries in a very unique way! So, if you go here is the MUSTS:
Marshmallow coke
French fries w/​cheese is even better!
Chili Dog
And a peanut butter chocolate shake!
Place rating: 4
Greenwood, IN
The ice cream is very good! Will definitely take a trip here again!
Place rating: 4
Redwood City, CA
This place ROCKS! Since my teen years (Doesnt matter how long ago that was!!) It’s a MUST STOP for me & my family!
Peanut Butter Cup PLEASE!!! mmmmmmmmmmmMMMMM
The summer months are the most fun, but any time they are open — it’s a great time!
When the sun is beating down & you just cant stand the HEAT? Just pull into the Frosty Boy & have a special TREAT! haha
Now that I’m living in California I still crave it. I get text messages and photos from family whenever they are there — MEAN! haha
You can bet I stop in EVERY single time I’m home in Indy!
I HEART YOU, Frosty Boy! I HEART YOU!