57 Napoli Pizza e Vino

This place is terrible. Don’t believe the guy outside that tells you best pizza in ny. We waited FOREVER for the worst pizza in ny. Terrible service on top of everything. Two big thumbs down.

Watery pizza from mozzarella not being drained with bland crust. Pizza raw in middle from cheese not being drained. Confused because reviews are wrong. Waiter even told us this happens a lot

After trying their sample pizza which was so kind coming from the owner we loved it. We go to get pizza every time we get a chance. Best pizza around the area. Friendly workers too, it’s under new management.

Great pizza! Amazing arugula salad with burrata. Free glass of wine, what can be better?!

This is my favorite pizza place in New York. Great variety without being overwhelming, and their pizza is spot on every time. I highly recommend this place. Try and you won’t be disappointed.

Went here on the recommendation from the concierge, Erin, at The Pierre.
My boyfriend *loves* pizza and he said this was the best pizza he has ever had. We walked in at 8pm and seated promptly. We ordered a New York style half cheese half pepperoni. Absolutely delicious.

On the second floor of a deli. Little confusing to locate but well worth your time. Pizza was good.

Great, fast service, pies Are larger than you think, quite tasty. Drinks are in cans, fresh

Der Mozzarella war spitze, echt leckere Italienische steinofen pizzen. service war nett. Das lokal sieht auch echt schnuckelig aus, mir war es aber leider ein wenig zu kalt, ist aber auch schon mein einziges Manko!
Was ich auch echt spitze fand, an der Straße kann man schon ein wenig Pizza probieren. hat uns überzeugt hier zu essen;)

Best pizza I have ever had! And I say that as someone who has lived in NY state all of her life. The crust is perfect; the cheese is fresh and delicious unlike the highly processed cheese you might find at other places. Friendly and fast service as well. This will be a regular destination for us.

I came on a Monday night. The panini was good that I had and was far bigger than what I needed. I’d come again.

The Caesar salad is not to be overlooked for the cheese lover it is loaded with Parmesan and wonderful. My daughter had the Alfredo and it was superb, we had pizza and it couldn’t have been better. Only thing they could improve was the beer was NOT cold. But our waitress did bring us an ice bucket to chill the beer.

We needed a last-​minute reservation last night for 7 adults, one toddler and a baby, at a place that everyone would like (we had some vegetarians and gluten-​free guests), a place that wasn’t too expensive, and somewhere close to the 59 /​Lex subway since one of the guests was 9 months pregnant. Luckily this place was perfect.
They sat us in our own corner in the back by the window and even though we had some guests arrive a little later, we never felt rushed. All of the pizzas we ordered were great (everyone loved the crust) and it was nice to have some Moretti beers on the side as well. Our gluten-​free guest ordered the gluten-​free penne pasta and he and the toddler devoured it.
The restaurant wasn’t too loud either so even though we were spread across a long table, everyone could hear one another making it easier for us to catch up. We’ll definitely keep this as an option when we have another big group in town to entertain :)

This place was amazing. Delicious wood fired pizza, good atmosphere and the prices were pretty fair. We split a large specialty pizza between the two of us and could not finish it. I loved the crust than how it was burnt a little bit. Good service too.

Best Caesar salad and fettuccine alfredo we’ve ever had… and we’re picky! Awesome pizza too. We even had a special request for cheese garlic bread that wasn’t on the menu, and that was great as well!

Excellent pizza, dessert and latte. I enjoy dinning with my sister here, occasionally when we’re in the area. The service is excellent and waitress is super friendly/​sweet. The thin crust pizza is highly recommended. The place is simple and quiet. I love coming here and will continue to come as long as there open for business. The prices are fair for this part of NewYork.

This was the most horrible dining experience I have ever had. Walking in, the waiters were extremely inattentive and rude. When we inquired about the complimentary wine they serve, the waiter gave us attitude and said «I gotta see some IDs.» Service was really slow and we were sitting down for 15 minutes before we even got water or a waiter. When we got the bread basket, there was a BUG in it. We tell a second waiter, and he said «Wow this is the second time this has happened. You guys should order the pasta instead.» WHAT… That is insane. Anyways, our waiter did not even apologize to us for the disgusting bug and unsanitary conditions. We left before getting our food. I never really write Unilocal reviews, but this experience was so bad that I made an exception.

Perfect for the whole family, something for everyone: pizza from the wood fired oven, pastas, salads, etc. Friendly, warm environment.

I am very picky with pizza but when we traveled to NYC for our anniversary trip we stumbled upon this place. This pizza was the most delicious pizza and fresh like they just picked the tomatoes and made the dough. We liked it so much our last day here we ate there again.

Good pizza. Good service. Seating! We had the Margheritta and the Reale and both were excellent. Light crust. Generous portion of prosciutto on the Reale. Fresh mozzarella.

Loved stumbling into this place while wandering around our hotel neighborhood. It was warm and cozy and the pizza oven smelled delish.
After a nice basic Caesar salad, we had a terrific pizza and a nice glass of wine with a big bottle of pellegrino.
The tables upstairs are clustered but not overly close. I love to innocently eavesdrop and this place was nosy tourist heaven with the lunch girls bitching about their jobs on one side and the large family group in front. The group of all women with a hand full of kids included one woman visibly crying. Oh to be a writer and be able to capture and recreate these moments.
A good value FOR NYC and a nice neighborhood pizza spot. Wood fire oven pizza is a bit more rare in ATL but it’s our favorite and this spot didn’t disappoint.
Check it out!

La pizza perfecta! Venimos de Venezuela a conocer un poco la ciudad, nos recomendaron este buscador para tener restaurantes acertados. Y asi fue! Eso fue lo que sentimos desde que entramos! Aunque subimos unos cuantos escalones un poco empinados, eso no fue nada al sentirnos bienvenidos a esta pequeña pizzería, con un personal muy atento! El menú muy completo! Pedimos la napoli y la San Diego… Fue perfecto! La textura perfecta… Mis amigos quedaron encantados! La mejor pizza que han comido en su vida! Asi tal cual fue el comentario luego de comer el último pedazo!