Squish Marshmallows

SOOO YUMMY!!!
I had my first Marshallow almost two years ago and I’m hooked! My favorite being Mangococo Ice Cream and seasonal flavors. ohh heck they are all good you place that Banana Pudding into a latte with almond milk and this combination is to die for.
As an Educator, for career day I thought it would be a great idea to invite the owner to present and distribute Marshmallows to seniors in the Bronx it was a sucess! My students loved the idea and creativity of creating something amazing and selling it! and of course enjoyed sampling several flavors.
Squish Marshmallow’s is a winner in my eyes!

With a name like Squish, I wasn’t expecting the textural contrasts that are the best part of their product; they’re also not nearly as dry as some specialty marshmallows, placing them right up there with City Bakery (& more convenient before HBO flick in Bryant Park). Their bag of 6 is inexplicable $ 6.50 rather than $ 6, so just order your 6 or more a la carte like I did, sampling each flavor available — birthday party, tiramisu, s’mores (toasted*), rocky road, banana pudding, pb&j time, lemon meringue pie.
*but not in s’mores form for $ 3 for 2 ‘mallows plus graham and presumably chocolate =
Single Marshmallow x 7 ($ 1.00 ea.) $ 7.62
PS Their logo on the Square receipt renders much like the middle ground between the two feedback smileys below it.
PPS$ 5 cc minimum
PPPS not in results for a ‘squish’ query

Caught them at Hester Street Fair by sheer chance and it made the experience that much better.
The mallows are about $ 1 a piece, which I thought was a bit much AT FIRST… But after tasting, I realize it’s worth the Washington.
I had the S’mores (like the true mallow fan I am) and Tiramisu. When heated/​toasted, the mallows are SUPER fluffy and airy, like eating a mouthful of flavored nothing! xD When eaten at regular temp, they are still softer than the regular mallow.
So my chinky tastebuds will tell ya that the S’more is WAY sweet, but I appreciate them putting dark choco pieces in there so it ain’t just pure sugar cube.
I absolutely LOVED the tiramisu puff cuz of the [lack of] sweetness and the ladyfingers chunks inside. Really adds texture to the soft mallow and tastes AWESOME with coffee! Makes for good gift option to that sweet tooth friend of yours~

Here’s the deal. Katherine is making gourmet marshmallows. I’ve never been much for mallows and was pretty happy when I thought the craze died out a few years ago. I was WRONG.
She has a variety of flavors. As I prefer savory to sweet, I went with ‘peanut butter jelly time’ all while pretending I was the dancing banana singing the repetitive verse reminiscing to 2002 when my college roommate was obsessed with this song.
(with a baseball bat?)
Oh. My. Goodness. I would have had ZERO idea this was a Marshmallow. The strawberry jelly was melted throughout the mallow and enough peanut butter chips that each bite was a perfect blend. I mean seriously, it was awesome.
You know what else she does? Because she’s that good? She TOASTS it if you ask. Yep. Marshmallow of your choosing, on a skewer, wand lighter out, enjoy.
She sells bags of 12 for $ 12.50. If you’re looking for a unique gift for a friend or housewarming, pick the $ 19.50 which comes with two bags of 6 (can choose two different flavors), 12 wooden skewers AND the refillable wand lighter for do it yourself at home toasting.
Yeah, she’s also really friendly. Wouldn’t you prefer to do business with friendly people? Thanks Katherine for sharing your treats.

I had a couple of these at a Unilocal Helps event and they were so good! I had the birthday cake one which was gluten free and dairy free. The smokes one was just as good especially once it was grilled a little! I wish the owner had a store front but hopefully that will come soon!

I attend an EE Unilocal event and they were one of the vendors. Yummy selection of marshmallows that were on display at their vendor table. Being a marshmallow lover, it was hard to decide which one to sample… I wanted to sample all, but with others in line waiting, and me trying not to be a pig, I tried the banana pudding. She asked if I wanted it toasted so of course I said Yes! Oh so Good! Not sure what the price point is since it was complimentary at the event. I will buy some fo shue next time I’m in the area! I

Had the chance to try Squish Marshmallows at an event this week. They were surprisingly delicious. When I think of a marshmallow I think of those tiny white blobs in hot chocolate, or rubbery burnt marshmallows on smores. Squish Marshmallows were so delicious, I don’t think I can ever go back to the sub-​par marshmallow experience I’ve been putting up with all these years.
The flavors are inventive, and are as good irl as they are conceptually. The actual consistency of the marshmallow is chewy but not rubbery, very soft, melt in your mouth kind of texture. My favorite is the banana pudding. It’s too bad their storefront is in the middle of nowhere (–1 star). I’ll have to order some off of their website or keep my eye out at 3^rd party retailers.

Had some marshmallows at an event catered by squish, and I was super impressed.
I had the peanut butter jelly time (cmon, say it out loud, I know you want to), and the rocky road which is gluten free!
Here are my pros:
— the marshmallows are soft to begin with, but she brulees them with a touch so it’s that slightly melty goodness of childhood
— there are real ingredients in the marshmallows. I got pb chips and jelly flavor in that marshmallow which was incredibly awesome. That rocky road was equally good and full of ingredients
— there are gluten free options
My only con is that she doesn’t have a storefront yet, BUT she sells online. Her packages are in her website. I’m really darn impressed with the marshmallows and will think of their urban marshmallow kit for my birthday :)

Such an original and absolutely tasty approach to marshmallows! The flavors are delicious and mouth-​watering. You’d be crazy not to try them!

Such great flavors — makes for awesome gifts/​treats. They are hand made with love!

Banana pudding marshmallows all day, everyday! Amazing treats, melt in your mouth fantastic! So many different flavours too. Brilliant!
:)

Innovative and fun marshmallows! Highly recommended!

An accurate synonym for Squish Marshmallows is scrumptious! I have never tasted a marshmallow this good and truly am a fan of all the flavors. A night doesn’t go by without having my squish to end the day with a cup of coffee, also tastes great inside the cup of coffee. I love the density of the marshmallow, it is very satisfying and only 45 calories per marshmallow, making it a wonderful guilt free treat. I purchased some as gifts for friends who are now loving them as well and placing orders. I’d recommend readers out there to place an order and see how incredible they truly are.

These marshmallows are seriously amazing — not like the store bought kind I used to put in hot chocolate as a kid. I brought 6 bags home for my family for Christmas and everyone loved them! Highly recommend as a gift for anyone with a sweet-​tooth! My favorite flavor is S’Mores, but Gingerbread was phenomenal as well.

best marshmallows ever and sweetest customer service, pun intended. makes for a great/​memorable gift.

Best marshmallows around! Each one is made with great detail and love! And the flavors are so good!!! Low in fat and great taste! Ricky road is my favorite! I hope a squish store is in the making :).

Squish Marshmallows are one of my absolute favorite snacks! The variety of flavors is on point, and while they are amazing to munch on by themselves, they also go brilliantly with a hot chocolate or a cup of coffee. My fav flav is S’mores… but I’ve had (and loved) them all!

I brought a few packs of these cute little marshmallows to a friend’s birthday picnic in Central Park. They were such a hit! These are not your bagged mallows from the store! They are gourmet and such a cute, unique alternative to the tired «designer cupcake» trend.

If I could buy all of the marshmallows I would. I would eat the whole business. It’s the best and I hope after reading all these positive reviews you make the right decision and place an order.
These are not your average marshmallows. they are a great combination of not too sweet with a delicious flavor of gingerbread or pb&j! They are so soft too! Mmm I am craving them right now!

Amazing and really creative flavors! I am constantly surprised at how much more I like each flavor than I think I will — so take my advice and try some stuff you might not even expect to like.
They’re pretty limited-​batch & hard to find out where you get your hands on em, so follow their social media feeds to stay on track of where you can pick them up.