Cassidy’s Pub

This place is a hidden gem. Small bar/​restaurant. The bar is long with maybe 15 – 20 seats? Then to the left is the dining area that has about 10 tables. More of a bar you go to chill. Been here a few nights with live music. Have TVs to watch the games. But small, so could get noisey. Sometimes have a coupon in the paper. Right down the road from my house that I can literally walk — which is a plus! Older crowd most of the time. But I like to come here for an early dinner. I don’t eat wings but heard from my family they are out of this world. I love the Balsamic Steak Wrap — diced up steak, tomatoes, lettuce, and this garlic mayo? Not sure what it is but still delicious. Fries are crispy and thin. The mac ‘n cheese is great but very heavy that for the $ 9 they charge you should split as an appetizer. The Chili Nachos are good too, but some advice is to ask for the «homemade chips» or else they’ll come out on regular tortilla chips! Service is great, bartenders are friendly and do occasional buybacks, beers are good but normal drafts. Definitely try it out if you live in the area or want to try something new :).

Nice place but they really need to clean the outside of the building weeds growing in the front of the building and the parking lot needs to be resurfaced.

Second time there for take out buffalo wings and they didn’t disappoint.
Their Chipotle wings, BBQ wings and Buffalo wings all got compliments. They were greedily gobbled up by everyone.
What can I say. I’ll be back!

I just don’t know where to start with this review so I will start at the beginning. After seeing recommendations for this place on my town’s mom and dad FB page saying that even though this is a bar, it is family friendly I decided to give it a shot. I mean how can I pass up award winning wings?
I do want to say, regardless of the rest of my review the staff here was super friendly and appropriately attentive. As for the family friendly part, this place is indeed a bar. A pretty busy one at that, and while they do have a half wall of separation you cannot get away from the bar atmosphere. I do not suggest bringing the kids.
We sat at our table and immediately I saw the ‘yuck/​gross’ look on my neat freak hubby’s face. The table was filthy. Definitely needed a cleaning it was sticky. We started with a couple of drafts. Coors Light for me and Stella for him. It is a BAR, so I was expecting for at least the beer to be good. Um, no! They must be out of CO2 or there is something wrong with their system because both beers were completely flat. Since I am not a sender backer, I lived through it. I mean they have award winning wings, right?
Onto the appetizer. We got a combo of those wings, poppers, and mozzarella sticks for the boy. While the poppers and sticks were good, the wings actually were pretty good. I wouldn’t call them award winning, but they do have a solid wing. This is were the praise ends for the rest of the meal.
Hubby ordered fish and chips, and we both couldn’t stop looking at the dish when it was set down wondering if they know what fish and chips are. Generally speaking the fish is usually an nice fat piece of cod, dipped in a flour batter and fried to perfection. What he got was I believe tilapia fillets, bread crumb battered and fried. Not good.
I ordered the Shepard’s pie, which is one of my faves. In a pub, it has to be good right? It was in the favorites section of the menu. Well it looked good when they put it down in front of me, but wow was it bad. Clearly the peas and carrots were a frozen bag and the meat was kind of weird. Some was chopped meat and some was big pieces. After stirring it up, I realized that was because it was a broken up frozen hamburger patty. It was watery and gray and not the rich thick brown stew that it should be. It just lacked any flavor whatsoever. I was extremely disappointed. I think what put me over the edge was my husband opened the bottle of ketchup to put on his fries and it literally exploded when he opened it. It was disgusting. From working in the restaurant business for years it is common practice to condense your ketchup bottles at the end of the night. In this case this bottle was probably added to too many times and the ketchup had all air bubbles and smelled bad. In addition when he took the cap of it was caked with old ketchup. Nasty.
Overall, I guess if you drink bottle beer and stay at the bar and only eat wings, you should be good.

The place looks like a dump on the outside, it really needs to be cleaned to look more inviting.

A+ for food and typical bar atmosphere. Wing special for monday night football which is always appreciated. Service was eh, beer selection could be better and not enough tvs to accommodate Sunday football. Since I was there on Monday night it wasn’t an issue, and I really liked this place. Will definitely repeat.

After visiting a few times, becoming a regular, and giving some careful consideration towards the food… I must admit… This place is great!
The wings are better than any franchise ive had (not including buffalo wild wings)
And the cuban sandwhich is 3^rd best behind cheesecake factory and miami, FL.
Mmmmmmmmmm… Cant wait for my meal to arrive! Im starving!

I go here often, almost every 2 weeks. I got my fiancé hooked and I meet the town moms there from school often as well. We can go there and eat and drink like kings and it will never cost more then $ 25 each. BEST wings around! also the blue cheese on the side I could drink. They know us and greeted happily every time we come in… The whole staff is great. They make fabulous martinis. There guacamole is one of the best I have had and you can get chips or fried noodles with it. I could rave about everything on the menu but you just have to try it yourself :)

Best wings in Bellmore and top 5 in Nassau no question. Not too big. Not too small. Just enough fry time so that there’s a crunch without drying out the meat. Homemade blue cheese is outstanding.

Awesome place with great food!!! Wings are out of this world!

Great local pub, the bar staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about what they serve.
Some of the best bar food around. 5 Stars all the way!