Mario’s Pizza

I’ve been ordering from this place for YEARS… never any issue, nice bunch of guys. Until, one day I ordered delivery. Hour and a half goes by and I call because they usually do not take that long at all… the lady tells me «you didn’t order any food here» I told her I spoke to her and even told her what my total came out to. She said «oh sorry, it’ll be 30 – 45 minutes more. A little irritated, but I said alright. In a total of 2.5 hours that it takes the food to come. The delivery guy still insisted that I didn’t order previously. Then my wife, my kids and I are eating our food when suddenly my kid notices a plastic piece in her food. IT WAS A GLOVE. I was like wow… then I eat my food and their was a plastic piece. At this point I was furious only because God forbid if my daughter were to choke or something. I call and the manager says «idk what u want me to tell u because you have the food already» I’m like dude you know me, ordered there for many years, and that’s the response I get? It just wasn’t cool and totally didn’t appreciate that response to a long time customer.

Great food but the guy who answers the phones is a rude man who is very confused.

Marios is no good never was but now they use Spanish for their Italian business quantity over quality you want real Italian food Atlantic pizza in Freeport is legit Italian not this Spanish food

Outstanding service food and experience every time! Friendly staff and always welling to accommodate n get you what you want. Loveeee this place

The only place in Oceanside or surrounding area that has Gnocchi. They have the best salad dressing ever & they will even sell it to you! They need to improve their soup. Better prices than Villa & Pizzaiola and much faster delivery!

Fantastic pizza. They have a bunch of different style slices available at the front counter, such as chicken/​bacon, buffalo and baked ziti, which are all very good. I would also highly recommend pasta night on Thursdays– large portions, plus salad and garlic knots, and they even bring it to your table. There are many good choices for pizza in Oceanside, and Mario’s is one of the best.

I have tried practically every pizzeria in town and Mario’s is my new favorite. Thin crust. Sauce that is appropriately sweet and tangy. Big slices. And, they deliver to Oceanside high school which is a big hit with students who often want a little treat on Fridays.

I’ve stopped in here almost every year in December for the past 10 years. Really good thin crust, crispy pizza. Yes, it’s oily. Use a napkin to sop it up. Love their spinach pizza. Big slices. Small place, often frequented by local kids. They used to make baseball sized zeppoles, but it seems they stopped making it this past December. I was never actually that crazy about them anyways. A slight renovation removed the storm door and increased the seating area slightly. I’ll give it 5 stars when they renovate the unisex bathroom (It was clean, but it was essentially a broom closet) and if they put zeppoles back on the menu and offer to make them fresh to order.

There are a whole bunch of pizza joints in Oceanside. I grew up with Marios over the years, and I know some families who swear by it. I’m a Villa Formia boy (another Oceanside haunt), always have been, and I compare everything to their pizza.
The Mario’s pizza was a little too greasy for me. Maybe I caught it on a bad day, but there was just a teeeeeenie bit too much for me to really enjoy it.
The chicken rolls are pretty fantastic, though I’m not a big fan of ricotta and you can definitely taste it. They’re like glorified chicken parm sandwiches, just better and crustier.
Worth trying out if you’re passing by /​in the neighborhood. No great shakes, in my opinion.

This has been the standby for any random take-​out dinner night in the area. The pizza is good and the menu is actually pretty varied. One of the best gyros I’ve ever had came from Mario’s.
In high school, it was one of the few local restaurants you could get food from and make it back to class. They also had some random concoctions, like the «taco pizza», which is exactly what it sounds like: ground beef, taco sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese on a pizza crust.
yes, it was delicious.

Love the pizza! Spinach pinwheels are the best!