Nicolo’s Pizzeria

Great place! Looks like a good place to have sit down and have pizza with family.
Ordered the Hawaii pizza there and loved it! Usually I have to ask them to put in some extra sauce, but not here
Keep up the good work guys!

Nicolos pizza is really really good. Being from Brooklyn I have high expectations. Nicolos is damn close. No one beats Brooklyn pizza but I really like nicolos.

Worst sandwich I ever ordered. Not only was the order wrong but the sandwich had 1 skinny piece of turkey on it. My husband’s sandwich was also wrong and had the same little skinny piece of roast beef on it.
I’d call back to complain but I don’t want a sneezer to replace these sad excuses for sandwiches. That’s 14 bucks I’ll never get back.
I’ll never order from them again.
I wish they could get no stars.

Food used to be better with the old owner but still without a doubt is one of the best plain slices around here

Not only great pizza, but an amazing catering menu. The food is all made fresh and the staff is amazing. The owner will work with you to ensure you are getting a great deal. We have used them for many of our past events and will continue to use them because of their great food and service!

I stopped by for a quick bite on my way between business appointments. I’m a big advocate of Buffalo Chicken pizza and heard that they had the best in the area so I had to try it. Boy was that a good idea!
The pizza was hot and fresh and the chicken was nice and spicy, enough to almost make me sweat a little. Lol. I was very pleased and will definitely be coming back for another slice in the future.

Use to be the place to go. Now A&S and better than both Bonettis is much better for the dollar.

BOTTOM LINE:
Great Broccoli White Pie with Ricotta!
I wanted to review this place because it has so few reviews, and sometimes you can’t trust Unilocal when there haven’t been that many reviews yet. My GF and I ordered out from here for the first time yesterday, and we only got one pie, so take what we say with a grain of salt.
The pizza crust was excellent — a little chewy, with the right amount of breadiness and crisp to the crust. They also have options for Sicilian, thin crust, and pan pizza for those who want it, but we did not try those.
Since we got white pizza, we do not know how their sauce is. The cheese was very yummy, and they were generous with the amount of cheese and ricotta — almost too generous with the ricotta to the exclusion of broccoli.
We asked for extra garlic on the pizza and they delivered on that front. All-​in-​all, we were very satisfied with the pie.
The location looks a little run down, but the pizza counter and dining area looked clean and pleasant once inside. The two guys working there at the time I came to pick up also seemed really nice.
PRICING:
The Gourmet large pie we got was $ 16 which seemed reasonable, or a little pricey, considering there was no sauce even. However, they run great deals — check out their website for coupons — 2 large plain pies for $ 17; 1 large one-​topping, plus fries, plus wings, plus a Stromboli for $ 25; etc.
I definitely recommend.

I used to live a few blocks away from Nicolo’s and it was where Friday night dinner was bought from. They had something for everyone and everything was delicious! We live on the West Coast now and my wife and I stil mention ordering from Nicolo’s as a joke. Great food, good prices and large portions. A chicken parm dinner easily feeds two people and the pizza is fantastic. When in South Old Bridge make sure you visit Nicolo’s you won’t be sorry you did.