Gino’s Pizzeria

I love Gino’s pizza. It is just as pizza should be. Cheesy and delicious. I am not even sure they have anything but pizza and garlic knots and some pops. There pizza is what we always get. The only tip I have is they are like the Soup Nazi in there. Just order your food and don’t ask any questions ;)

This is the most consistantly good pizza place in all of Long Island. A+ product! Some of the staff are the nicest people you’d ever meet and some are well … true Ny’ers LOL the pizza is Top Notch!

This place is ridiculous. It is 8:30 on a Saturday night and I call to place a simple order. They tell me they are closed because they have to clean up after a parade they had in town. Let me tell you something, I have worked in restaurants my entire life (and managed a successful pizzeria), this sounds like a lame excuse for «we are too tired to work anymore today.» Lazy! Will not ever order from this place, should have a better work ethic than this.

i order at least two pies every friday night. i love Old Guy, the grumpy old bastard.

Excellent quality food and stellar service. I ordered catering and I got the works. Lasagna, ziti, pizza, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, fresh salads and dressings, zeppoli enough to feed 60 people! First of all I placed my order directly with the owner and he was great to deal with, (and he gave me a good discount on that huge order). Secondly the food was delivered right on time. Last but certainly not least 60 people loved the food! They were eating, asking for more and bombarding me with compliments on my taste in Italian food! Choosing Gino’s made my event a huge success and months later, people still mention how good the food was. I could not have stumbled across something better.

Pizza is a bit above average, the garlic nuts are the best. Service is by grumpy old men… so it’s quiet entertaining. Definitely the best garlic nuts though.

This is a tiny little pizza place but the food is great. I wouldn’t take a date here for a sit down meal but if your staying at home and watching a movie grab something from this place to go and you will be happy. I’d give it 5 stars but it’s a little bit more expensive than other places.

Grandma slice, excellent. Regular slice better than average. For Suffolk pizza this place is bad ass. One of the reviews below was comical. Because the Unilocal review wrote this long review about being called a «fudge packer» and the staff is rude. I was just there today, staff is fine. Pizza rocks for Suffolk county. Thumbs up for the «fudge packers»
Lol

Ive been coming to this place for years and the pizza is good but some of the staff that work there (1 guy in particular) is rude to me all the time! Just yesterday I went in to have pizza and stayed with my slices as I always do and the guys were having popsicle sticks then one of the guys went back and got fudgesicle sticks and asked the rude employee «you a fudgepacker?». Rude employee proceeds to say: «be careful he is sitting right there.» implying that I was a fudgepacker and i know he was talking about me because i was sitting in the first table closest to where they were standing. Whats worse is the boss/​owner of the place was there at the time a few feet away from them behind the counter. I pretended not to mind or hear him say that but I did.
Plus there were plenty of other times I ate in at this place in the past and heard some of the other guys behind the counter make fun of other customers after they left with their pizzas to go. This place can be professional at times then there are times where they don’t give a crap (not the word I want to use but Ill keep it clean) about anything. If you dont mind being served by sometimes rude employees who will probably say something bad about you after you leave but want delicious pizza go to Ginos. But if you want good pizza (and less costly) as well as friendly service from employees then go to DelFiore pizza down the block on Main Street by the Theater! Which is probably what Im going to do from now on, not to mention DelFiore was the original pizza place I always went to in Patchogue when I was a kid growing up before I even knew Gino’s existed so screw this place! Im going back to my roots!

I have no idea what these other reviewers were thinking. This place is mediocre (at best) and it’s actually terrible if you have high expectations. AVOID!

I love walking through the ally to smell your pizza. I have been coming here since I was a kid walking through the little ally inside. I remember looking through the windows and coming there to play your video games. Pole position. My wife and I love your pizza. I will be back Thank you Ginos.

Visiting Long Island from seattle with my wife. Stopped in for a quick bite while walking around patchogue. Entering right in kitchen area and pizza making process. Fun!
Ordered three various slices from available pizzas. These were heated to piping hot, delicious. awesome! This is what we wanted for a New York pizza!
One star off because no beer.

What place in 2015 doesn’t take credit cards? Bbq slice tasted like chemical!
Not happy. Garlic knots were very stale!

Pizza is best in the area. Not much of a selection on the menu. No seafood. And unfortunately the guy on the phone is really rude.

Family has been getting pizza from Ginos for years. They have amazing pizza, good deals/​coupons and a buy ten get one free stamp system that is great. Orders are quick and service is great.

Gino’s is definitely the best choice for straight pizza in Patchogue. You can get better entrees or pizza creations at other pizzerias, but if you just want a good old fashioned slice of pizza, Gino’s can’t be beat.
Their specialty slices, i.e. Chicken Ranch, Buffalo, Barbecue, etc. are all in the $ 4 range, but they are gigantic. A modest person could probably make a meal and a half out of them.
Regular slices are in the more normal, $ 2 range. Their crust can’t be beat. Has a good flavor to it, but is still crisp yet chewy.
As an aside, not sure if they do this for everyone, but if you order to stay, there’s a good chance they’ll bring you your food. Not an official waiter service, but a nice gesture.

Good pizza. I liked them better than the other two in the immediate area (think L and DF). Great loyalty program and coupons in the local town crier every week. My go-​to pizza place in Patchogue.
update: been disappointed in ginos recently. Took my business elsewhere.

Great classic slice, nothing too fancy.
Does occasionally undercook the pie (sloppy cheese, chewy dough).
2^nd best slice in the Village.

Gino’s has the BEST grandma slice i’ve ever eatten (~$ 3.50/slice). Large rectangular slice of cheesy, saucy, tomatoe-​y, crispy, soft goodness. They sprinkle some (what i believe is) pesto sauce within it, which makes it taste SO delicious.
The seating area is dimly lit and little dingy, but who cares they make delicious pizza!

located on Main street in Patchogue
I came only because of the reviews
first visit I did not know it was a cash only so my son and I left
BUT I knew we would be back
I am so glad I didnt let the anger of no plastic get the best of me
(I was starved that first time)
we returned and returned and then we brought a guy a visiting soldier friend (from the State of Washington via Afghanistan)
This is really good pizza I mean really!
and one of the best things! THE PRICE 13 bucks for a pie and sodas
served fresh and hot in the little dining room in the back Its a throw back to 1985 but who cares the pizza is 5 star