Eli’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream & Soda Shop in Payson, UT

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	7 S Main St, Payson, UT, 84651
Categories:	Cafes Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations	No
Delivery	No
Take-out	Yes
Accepts Credit Cards	Yes
Good For	Dessert
Bike Parking	Yes
Good for Kids	Yes
Good for Groups	Yes

Attire	Casual
Noise Level	Average
Alcohol	No
Outdoor Seating	Yes
Wi-Fi	No
Has TV	No
Waiter Service	No
Caters	No

Today

Today	11:00 am – 10:00 pm Open now
Local time (Payson)	7:37 PM Tuesday, June 3, 2025

Business hours

Monday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday	11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday	11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday	11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday	–

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:

GameLand World

32 E Utah Ave

150

El Tapatio

47 S Main St

280

Wee Blu Inn

39 N Main St

290

Fuji House

17 S Main St

320

Fantasy Acres Miniatures Museum & Model Shop

96 S Main St

340

Dilly’s Mobile

147 S 300 E

11 reviews of Eli’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream & Soda Shop

No registration required

Chad N.

Place rating: 2
Payson, UT

Cool old place. Took the family there. Honestly we’re not fans. The quality of the ice cream tastes just like the stuff you’d buy at the grocery store. I was expecting more of fresh old fashioned tasting ice cream, even home made. I was hoping for something unique that stood out. Nope bought and resold ice cream with standard flavors. We may try it again but first impressions does not have us running back.

Zac R.

Place rating: 3
Provo, UT

They’re just serving BYU ice cream. I’m not sure why that’s so special. It’s not even fresh. My wife got the cookies and cream and the cookies tasted old. Plus, they don’t even have that great of a selection. I know some people don’t like Coldstone since they massage the ice cream but at least their ice cream tastes fresh and they’ve got a huge variety of flavors and mix-ins.

Christina S.

Place rating: 5
Los Angeles, CA

Best spot in Payson by far! Amazing Ice Cream, fun pinball, and walk-in bank vault from the 1800s. Random, but amazing and one of the coolest things I’ve seen in a long time.

Jeanette M.

Place rating: 5
Payson, UT

Nothing is better than an old fashioned hand-scooped ice cream cone on a hot summer evening. Plenty of flavour choices, along with the helpful and courteous staff, makes this one of our very favourite treat destinations!

Shad F.

Place rating: 5
Orem, UT

Delish! I got the Graham Canyon ice cream, my daughter got the Play dough ice cream, and my wife got the Raspberry Cream ice cream and a peach Italian soda. We left satisfied and smiling…

Kimball S.

Place rating: 5
Montrose, CA

A nice small shop, great atmosphere, and delicious ice cream (BYU Creamery ice cream). Part of the same building and owned by the same people are a comic/game store and used bookstore – also great places. I got the banana split – one of the best I’ve had.

Miranda P.

Place rating: 5
Springville, UT

This place has great ice cream, atmosphere, and it pretty cheap. I got a bowl of ice cream for under $ 2 and it was so rich I probably could’ve had a smaller portion. Way good!

Joy M.

Place rating: 5
American Fork, UT

Good olé time ice cream place. Homey atmosphere, like it! Their hot coco is a must try! It is a very nice place for the locals, the owner ad staff are very friendly and accommodating.

Shane H.

Place rating: 5
Springville, UT

Man I love this place! Every city needs a really good old fashioned ice cream joint and this place delivers.
Built in the 1880’s, the gorgeous brick building has some serious personality. Soft swing and big band music plays quietly as you select from a nice variety of ice cream, Italian sodas, milkshakes, and anything else along those lines. The friendly, smiling staff is a joy to talk to. It’s the perfect ambience for a family ice cream outing.
Eli showed me around as I enjoyed my maple-nut ice cream. He has kept a lot of fascinating bank memorabilia from back in the day including a check for one dollar and a ton of fake movie money.
My family of five paid only $ 11 for four ice creams and some delicious lemon poppyseed bread. We will definitely be back.

Preston S.

Place rating: 5
Salt Lake City, UT

Really great place and location. They’ve taken the old bank and kept that theme for an ice cream parlor. Eli told me they use only the best of ingredients. This makes sense because their peanut butter cup shake is delicious. I highly recommend this place and will definitely go back with the whole family!

Dan M.