Lillian’s Pan Pizza

We love Lillian’s Pizza, especially the thin crust. Whenever we come to Perdido Key, Orange Beach or Gulf shores from Georgia we make a point to eat here. Love the buffet Monday — Thursday also.

Probably the worst service I have ever had. Our waitress had four tables of four or less people. She seemed so overwhelmed it was impossible to get anything that we needed which was not much! She completely forgot to put my husbands food in so it never even came out. Had to wait for refills wait to get our order taken had to wait to get our check, it was just awful! The pizza was nothing special! Super greasy and dough was raw. Asked to speak to the manager the owner came and he gave a flat «oh I’m sorry maybe she is overwhelmed, I can give you 25% off» after I spoke to the owner I still had to wait a good 15 mins just to get the check! If you are overwhelmed from 4 small tables you should NOT be waiting tables! Absolutely do not go here!

Great service and very generous portions. The pizza was good, better than most but not great/​exceptional. Very clean bathrooms with awesome t shirts for sale. My wife had lasagna which was very good. I’d return when in the area but I’m not going to leave town craving a return trip. Just being real. Overall good a B+

The «Pan» pizza label is a bit of a misnomer. Lillian’s does not resemble the pies of Chicago — or even the thickness of a Pizza Hut «pan» pizza. It’s a little thicker than what most folks would consider a hand-​tossed pie. In my opinion, this is a plus.
We arrived, ordered, and carried the pizza home. The staff taking orders were friendly enough.
Mommy ordered a 10″ super-​thin Vegetarian.
The kids and I ordered an 18″ Orange Beach Express with Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Black Olives and Feta.
Both pies were still hot when we arrived at the condo — about a 5 mile drive. Both were also delicious. The 18″ produced very large slices that are a bit unwieldy. Fork and knife required.

Best stuffed pizza EVER! We have ordered from here about half a dozen times and the food is always awesome!
Out of the 6 they messed up once. But they were awesome about it and made the correction hassle free. Great food and great service. A+++ in my book!

Lillian’s is superb. Not only is the service always great but the food is outstanding. We visit at least once a year and always order extra so that we have leftovers. My kids get the Alfredo pizza, my husband gets chorizo, and I get the spicy crab. If you haven’t tried Lillian’s, you must!

Went to Lillian’s for the lunch buffet one afternoon before heading to the beach. Nothing like a giant pizza buffet to make that buff beach body sing!
The quality of the food was great — enjoyed all the pizzas they had on the buffet. BUT the problem was that they didn’t replenish the buffet very often. There were long periods of time where the only pizza available was some crazy outlier that the customers kept ignoring, but every time the pepperoni or more traditional pies came out they were snatched up immediately. Made for a difficult buffet experience. Price was a bit high for a pizza buffet. We would return, as it was convenient and good pizza, but would probably just order off the menu next time for better quality and value.

We were hungry for lunch and pizza sounded good. We were seated the moment we walked in and it wasn’t a minute later and our server was ready to take our drink orders.
We ordered a medium Hawaiian Supreme. It was awesome. Service was fast and service friendly.
It was a great lunch and absolutely no complaints.

Pleasant atmosphere with chalk boards! Near the beach. Seems to be great for groups. And, there’s a bar. A vast number of selections on their menu, too. We ordered the Vegetarian Pizza (w/​spinach, tomatoes, onions, black olives, jalapeños [the latter in place of mushrooms] & lots of mozzarella cheese) — unfortunately, it was A-​OK (flavor was lacking). The Fettucini Alfredo (w/​no chicken /​shrimp) was creamy, though it could’ve used flavor as well. Their garlic bread = yum! Very friendly service was a major plus!

Terrible Pizza.
We had a 14″ pizza delivered to our condo in OBA. We ordered it with pepperoni and green pepper, although there were hardly any peppers.
What a disappointment. The pizza was undercooked and very doughy. The top of the pizza was a layer of grease and the cardboard box was soaked with grease.
Did I mention the cheese? It is the fake stuff that chews like a big hunk of bubble gum! The pizza was fairly expensive too — we paid $ 25 for a 2 topping 14″ pizza delivered with tip — and it was one of the worst restaurant pizzas we have ever had.
Instead of writing a bad review, we thought to be fair we would call Lillian’s and tell them. Well, their service is as bad as their pizza! They told us thank you for letting them know and made no offer to correct or make it right. Unbelievable!
Pretty bad when Papa Johns and other pizza chains are better than an Italian restaurant.

For being in the state of Florida I have to say the pizza here is great. The best part is they have a pizza/​salad buffet for a very reasonable price and you get to try so many different types of pizza… it’s awesome!