Little Italy Pizza

Horrible slow service order 2 hours in advance maybe it will arrive when u want I will never order from again

The past two times I ordered from Little Italy I did not receive what I ordered. The first time this occurred, the man working was apologetic and corrected the issue without question. However, the second time this occured was a much different experience. Upon ordering, the man was very rude and it seemed as if I was inconveniencing him. It was 45 minutes before closing which may have triggered the attitude but either way, it’s unacceptable. When I realized that my order was wrong, I called back just to make them aware. I understand mistakes happen and wasn’t looking for a refund or free food by any means. The man proceeds to tell me that is not what I asked for when I told him what I had ordered. For starters, why would I bother to call if the order was indeed correct? In addition, I currently have braces so I can only eat certain foods and the food I received was inedible to me. I feel as if this establishment solely cares about making money with no regard to the customer’s experience and I will not be ordering from them again.

I wish I could get my money back. This place was such a mistake. Awful, terrible experience. A personal pizza and a side salad for delivery 0.5 miles away took an hour and a half?!
My pizza arrived cold (actually had to reheat it in the oven) and has absolutely no flavor. Oh and it wasn’t even cheap! $ 20 for cafeteria quality food. Literally just wasted $ 20. The staff is really friendly but that’s the ONLY pro of this place. This is not the first time the delivery took an unacceptable amount of time. I gave them the benefit of the doubt that perhaps that first time was a fluke but I will absolutely never order from this place again and sadly would not advise anyone else to – It’s certainly not worth the wait for seriously sub par food and service.

Incredibly disappointed and never ordering again. This has been our go-​to pizza place and they are always later than promised… But this was the last time. We ordered a large cheese pizza, and a side salad. It was promised in 45 – 60 min. It took 1 ½ hours and we had to call twice. On top of the long wait, our pizza was cold by the time it arrived.
Very unfortunate because they do have good food, but it’s just not worth the aggravation.

The pizza SUCKS. Ive tried it 3 times now hoping something else was going on. Just awful. Today my bf ordered some before I came by. I took a bite of the greasiest pizza Ive ever had. The dough tasted sour but also tasteless somehow.
Because it was so bad I KNEW he got it from there. I even went to him and asked «is the from Little Italy» and he said «yeah why?» we both started laughing cuz he knew I could tell how gross it was.
The other food is fair. Salads are big.

I will NEVER order from this place again!!! They delivered my food to the wrong person and when I called back they refused to either refund my money or deliver my food to me. The owner was so rude to me on the phone and made me feel like *I* did something wrong. So I’m supposed to pay for the fact that somebody lied to their driver and stole my food? Any reputable business owner would have made it right and at the very least redelivered my food to me. Don’t trust this sham of a business.

great place — my go to for good, cheap pizza. sometimes have tendency to pull out the pizza’s early when busy — i usually ask them to cook it well done.

Delicious pizza that’s reasonably priced and quick with great people working there! Could go once a week at least!

Pickup is ready in under 20 mins and the food is delicious! Everything we’ve had has been excellent. The hot sandwiches I believe are on sarcones rolls, can’t beat that. Definitely are go-​to neighborhood place.

Grandma’s Sicilian is so friggin’ good but maybe even better is the Primo Mista salad. There isn’t anything special in it but the balsamic dressing is really good, the fact that the yummy croutons are the same size as the feta just makes it perfect. Very happy! And the Sicilian reheats really well

Ordered a few times and always have been satisfied. Love the chicken cheesesteak. Love the broccoli tomato ricotta pizza. Buffalo chicken Stromboli had too much cheese. Appetizer sampler had plain chicken wings instead of fingers so I didn’t eat them. Tomato pie was pretty good too. Five stars– even though it’s not the best, it’s good, and because the delivery is always super fast, they’re nice, and prices are really reasonable.

I just ordered here for the first time via GrubHub. I was looking for Gluten Free pizza. What I received was inedible. The crust was compltely soggy and the pizza warm not hot.
Looking from the reviews the regular pizza seems good but if you are looking for Gluten free, don’t get it from here.

These guys should be in jail for impersonating to know how to make a pizza and highway robbery. I ordered a Margarita Pizza with a side of anchovies along with 6 chicken wings. The pizza tasted like they bought a frozen store brand and let it defrost. The sauce had little taste, I don’t know how they sliced the mozzarella so thin it looked like they painted on the pizza, with very little flavor. The wings were the the smallest wings I ever saw. They charged me $ 3.50 for the anchovies that never came. They also charge $ 1.75 for delivery. No stars for this place.

I love this place, and it’s also the best Sicilian style pizza I can get delivered. They have garlic knots (huge plus after 10 years in nyc!) but they’re not always available for delivery. Friendly service, fast, accommodating, can’t complain!

Dear Little Italy,
First of all, I want to thank you for never sounding judgey when you already know my address before I say it. You know I’m about to get the best greasy pepperoni in the area, I know I’m about to get the best pepperoni pizza in the area, and I appreciate how we mutually pretend it’s not a regular occurrence.
Secondly, thanks for your awesomely fast delivery. It’s a small moment of gratification when my food gets here before my wife’s, and the smell of deliciousness can permeate the air before her thai food arrives. (She has an addiction. It’s a problem. Does she not understand the perfection of your pizza? But I digress.)
Little Italy, I am about to move, and I really need you to consider opening up a franchise in San Juan, because I just don’t think I can do this alone.
Love, Amanda.

This is above your average run of the mill pizza spot. Sal takes a lot of pride in his service. All pizza products are fresh and there’s a great variety to choose from. His buffalo chicken and barbecue chicken slices are some of the best in the city. And the Grandma slice is a must if you’ve never been here. Pesto pizza is pretty damn good too.

Tried the pizza for the first time tonight (delivery) and it was not what I expected. We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom and got a square Sicilian style pizza when we were expecting a round– thinner crust pizza. It was still ok although not at all what I was expecting. I skimmed Unilocal before ordering and didn’t see any mention of the style of pizza it was so I guess it’s my fault or assuming.

I live less than three blocks from here and am delighted to have these guys here. They run a terrific pizza shop. We started ordering from their original location at 9^th and south before they opened this one but having them this close for pickup is super convenient. Everything they do is top notch! Their pizzas are thin crust with a great sauce. We often get their margerita as a less indulgent option with all the flavor.
Their sandwiches come in individual styrofoam containers and the bread is soft and fresh. The Italian hoagie is great!
The staff are always courteous and friendly and they always have a soccer match on the TV when you walk in!
So glad their in the neighborhood… keep up the good work guys!

This is your quintessential corner pizza shop. Literally, it’s on a corner. Also, they make some kick ass slices.
We’ve got plenty of gourmet pizza in Philadelphia but something I was lacking was the neighborhood spot where I can roll in and get a great NY style slice. I’ve found it and they have two locations!
I got one plain and one with eggplant and basil. The plain was perfect, just like I remembered from my childhood when I would ride my bike to my local pizza shop, play video games and eat slices. Even though I don’t live around NYC anymore, I still ride a bike and still love a good slice of pizza. This place is my new jam.
The sauce wasn’t too sweet, slightly tangy and when I picked up the slice, it didn’t flop down like a wet sock. My requirements have been met.
Bonus: They were speaking lots of Italian in here which is fun since I have a place I can go practice.

I live across the street from this spot and have seen the transitions it has been through with other owners. Little Italy 2 is definitely a huge improvement!
Though mostly a take out place it is also a pleasant place to sit in, spotless with pretty décor and friendly staff.
On to the food… The pizza is pretty much perfect for my liking. Thin chewy crust. Slightly sweet sauce. Fresh cheese. And a variety of yummy toppings!
The cheesesteaks are standard, tasty and on delicious rolls. The chicken cheesesteaks are even better. Had a hoagie once and it too was delicious. The can compete with most good joints in Philly.
Just tried the cannoli and it too was really good. You can definitely tell you’re not too far from the Italian market!
So this is a pretty rock solid, consistently good pizza shop right in Queen Village! I will have to try some of the speciality dishes soon but would recommend this place to anyone.