I would give this place zero if it were an option. Note to self never prepay. I was told they use real butter and make everything from scratch. The frosting tasted exactly like Crisco and imitation butter flavor. It was also supposed to have raspberry filling and didnt. No offer of any partial refund even. $ 50 for a small 9 inch plain white cake with imitation frosting! You suck! Buy Walmart cakes. You’ll be better off.
Morgan L.
Place rating: 1 Columbus, OH
One of my friends used this baker for her wedding. When I went to pick up the cakes the day of the wedding, the order was wrong and she was shorted a cake(for which she had already paid). I was at the shop about five hours before the wedding, so I suggested making another sheet cake. The shop was being watched by the baker’s parents, who were perfectly nice and tried their best to handle a difficult situation. However, they informed me they didn’t bake. I understand that mistakes and misunderstandings happen, but it’s bad business to have someone taking care of your business who doesn’t have the necessary skills to do so. Someone needs to be present that can handle a situation like this, or a variety of other unforeseen circumstances.
Denise L.
Place rating: 5 Pickerington, OH
Very cute place outside and in. She has a variety of sweet treats to satisfy most everyone. My husband got chocolate ice cream which was very good. I got a salted caramel cupcake which was delicious. The cake part was so moist! Looking forward to bringing my mom here when she visits. Will definitely be back for the ice cream at the very least. Please support this local business!
Re J.
Place rating: 5 Pickerington, OH
I love this place. They have a little of everything, but my favorites are the macarons(the best I’ve had anywhere and no, not macarOONS, those are different), the handmade oatmeal cream pies, and then my favorite cupcake is the strawberry one. Also worth noting — a cannoli cupcake. Froggy’s also makes cakes for any occasion. They also have seasonal items that I can’t wait to come out — for example, they had white chocolate covered marshmallows on a stick that were decorated as snowmen. I love chocolate covered marshmallows — the white chocolate here is some of the best I’ve had. I don’t normally choose white chocolate but Froggy’s is very good.