Pasquale’s Pizza & Pub

I was very happy to hear that Pasquale’s pizza was in the Dublin area. To begin, the building for this place is basically a barn and it’s on the corner of Hyland Crow and Ryan Pkwy if you’re looking for it– took me a while to realize it was a barn. Also the address is Plain city but it’s not really in Plain city at all.
The pizza tasted so good. I ordered a large pepperoni and they loaded the pepperonis on the pizza. They put something on the bottom of the dough that made it taste really good. The sauce tasted like actual spaghetti sauce, very strong flavor to it and the cheese tasted strong too. My best guess is that they used provolone and undercooked. The only somewhat negative side to this was that the crust was a little burned (Yes I know it’s weird that the cheese was a little undercooked while the crust was a little over cooked) — but I still ate the whole thing. It was also $ 17, but I got a $ 2 off coupon for my next visit that came on the box. The expression «you get what you pay for» is true here.

A wise man once told me that you can’t debate taste. I did not enjoy their pizza. The cheese was burnt on the Village Fries, making them almost inedible. The chicken parmesan sandwich wasn’t bad and the plain fries that came with it were ok.
Service was slow despite being almost empty. I won’t be back, there are too many good alternatives nearby.

If you visited Pasquale’s in Westerville, this is the new home with same great pizza and calzones. They don’t have all the pasta and baked goods of Westerville (but one can hope.) There are burgers, sandwiches and bar fare to go with the new «Pizza and Pub» name.
In the upper level of the Jerome Village Community Center, much of their business seems to be carry-​out. We arrived at 6pm on Sunday and while our order was taken right away, we were told it would be 35 minutes because the kitchen was backed-​up. The barn-​like beamed JVCC has multiple TVs and clubhouse seating (sofa’s and over stuffed chairs) in addition to the restaurant tables, so a wait was not foreboding.
Unfortunately our wait turned longer as a mix-​up in the kitchen sent our order out as take away, discovered only when the it reached it’s destination and they called to report they had the wrong food. They put in our order again, and since the owner himself was our waiter, he comped our dinner and asked the kitchen to rush.
We enjoyed the founder’s pizza, a calzone and a gluten free Bianco pizza, as well as some «Village Fries» with bacon and cheese and a side of ranch dressing.
The food is very good. Unfortunately they seem to need some help in the kitchen and additional wait-​staff.
With so few choices near Jerome Village, Pasquale’s is a great option for those in upper Dublin, Jerome Township or who hanker for the pizza they remember from Westerville.
In spite of the long wait and kitchen mix-​up, I am sure we will be back.

Bringing the best pizza found in Westerville to the Jerome/​Dublin area. Amazing pizza with great flavored. My favorite is with pep, sausage and banana peppers. They have great appetizers and cold beer/​drink specials. You can also order and carry out. You must try Pasquale’s– you will love it!

This place is a hidden gem tucked away in a Dublin neighborhood. Really good place for families and friends. Great pizzas (haven’t had a bad one) and huge calzones. Garlic bread with cheese is awesome. Best of all, a small but really great beer selection. Thumbs up … twice!